Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Niagara Falls, NY, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Niagara Falls pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Niagara Falls or stop by 240 1ST STREET for carryout to order the best pizza in Niagara Falls, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Johns Pizza Niagra Falls Blvd
At Papa Johns Pizza in Niagara Falls, NY, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, …
papa johns stores in niagara falls, ny
PAPA JOHNS STORES IN NIAGARA FALLS, NY · 1st Street · Niagra Falls Blvd.
Pizza in Niagara Falls, NY | Papa Johns 1st Street
Order from Papa Johns 1st Street for the best pizza in Niagara Falls. Order online, call or visit for a selection of pizza and more for delivery or takeout!
Last Updates
Reviews
Radu Isache
My companion had a small pizza, it was very good and tasty. Friendly waiter and same, she served it when there weren’t so many people in the restaurant so the atmosphere was enjoyable, meantime I had the foot long hot dog from their neighbours.
… moreHO “gamerplyho33” gamer player
Without a doubt the pizza we had was really delicious. Whenever we are at Niagara, it’s hard finding some good places to eat. Papa johns did not disappoint. Pizza was cooked to my liking and was just bursting with flavour. The pizza maker when out of his way and really took care of us. I would highly recommend this place.
… moreLiME LiTE
This Papa Johns is attached to the Quality Hotel & Suites, and I stopped in here a few times during my stay. The staff were friendly and helpful and my food was made quickly.
… moreEmma Alberts
Horrible service, restaurant was upset I ordered in the evening and then burnt my food – skip this place, it isn’t worth the headache.
Ordered delivery through a courier at 9:35 PM, and the app said they close at 10:30 PM. Delivery driver arrived around 9:45 PM – restaurant had not started the order and claimed they never received it. When the courier kept telling them there was an order, they then said that they were closing. The courier continued to ask questions and then they claimed that someone had called out. The courier said that everyone was very rude and everyone was yelling. They did not start my order until a little after 9:50. When the order arrived, everything was burnt. It’s really easy to just call the person who ordered and cancel it in the app.
… moreOrdered delivery through a courier at 9:35 PM, and the app said they close at 10:30 PM. Delivery driver arrived around 9:45 PM – restaurant had not started the order and claimed they never received it. When the courier kept telling them there was an order, they then said that they were closing. The courier continued to ask questions and then they claimed that someone had called out. The courier said that everyone was very rude and everyone was yelling. They did not start my order until a little after 9:50. When the order arrived, everything was burnt. It’s really easy to just call the person who ordered and cancel it in the app.
Stephanie McGrew
The pizza was on par with my expectations for a Papa John, the staff was very nice, and the restaurant was close to the hotel. We got pizza for students we are at a conference with and it worked out great. This area is a very interesting set up. There is a bar and burger place also included in the area where you can get your pizza. There is not a lot of seating but there is some seating available. It is located and an area of downtown near a lot of the hotels. I have no complaints or negative feedback about using this establishment.
… moreHeli Mistry
Its a tiny place, found this place as we were wandering around and looking for food, turned out this place was open and we just ran since nothing else was open and were super hungry. The service is nice and quick! I believe the place is open till 11ish and there is also a bar on the side so easy access to drinks too. The food was great in general, just the garlic sticks were a little dry and they were huge, We did 2 orders of it and they were a lot even between 8-10 people
… moreLiu Hong Ying
Chanced upon Papa John’s and its Papa Bowl in Charleston, SC and we have loved it after since! Our go-to favourite is the for sure the Garden Veggie Papa Bowl, which has 6 different vegetable options to choose from, and is vegetarian but can also be customised to add-on meat protein options like chicken, for both vegetarians and non-vegetarians alike to enjoy! The sauce is always so flavourful, cheese is melted so well and we always enjoy our Papa Bowls as a hearty comfort meal, especially after our long walk exploring Niagara Falls State Park today Such an affordable price as well and pick up was prepared so quickly after we ordered online. We’ll surely be back for more!
… moreThomas R.
Wife had it delivered to the hotel! Most of it tasted about like any other Papa John, with the exception of the crust, which was a little different. If you order wings as for double sauce, it is drizzled in bbq sauce.
… moreBrigitta Jesslyn
Ordered The Works with stuffed crust, a mushroom pan crust pizza, and the mushroom Alfredo. Everything was delicious—great flavor and perfectly cooked. Definitely satisfied!
… moreKeith Newcombe
Absolutely horible seevice. Ordered pizza at 7:45 told itd arrive at 8:50 (alreadt ridiculous) athen at 9:05 I recieve a message saying ot will be here at 9:45. Thisbis after it has been sitting done for 25 minuts already.. Absolute joke. Manager had nothing to say but, “umm, ummm, ya we called doordash”
… more