Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Matawan, NJ, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Matawan pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Matawan or stop by 1008 Highway 34 for carryout to order the best pizza in Matawan, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
1008 Highway 34 – Matawan, NJ – Papa Johns Pizza Locations
Call us for pizza delivery in Matawan or stop by 1008 Highway 34 for carryout to order the best pizza in Matawan, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza Stores in Matawan – NJ – Papa Johns Pizza Locations
PAPA JOHNS STORES IN MATAWAN, NJ. FIND A PAPA JOHNS NEAR YOU · All Stores · US · NJ; Matawan. Highway 34. 1008 Highway 34. Open Closes at 2:00 AM.
Papa Johns Pizza Delivery & Carryout – Best Deals on Pizza, Sides …
Enjoy the ease of ordering delicious pizza for delivery or carryout from a Papa Johns near you. Start tracking the speed of your delivery and earn rewards …
Last Updates
Reviews
Ali Syed
I had a great pizza from this location. The pizza tasted and smelled fresh.
Like a freshly baked bread. Try the Cheese bread too. But the best is the Garlic parm bread.
Good job guys.
And they have a free pizza coupon upon request. I took it .
… moreLike a freshly baked bread. Try the Cheese bread too. But the best is the Garlic parm bread.
Good job guys.
And they have a free pizza coupon upon request. I took it .
Gileum
Let’s play spot the pineapple, and spot the mushroom.
My order was a pizza with pineapple, normal.
The second pizza was a large pizza with double mushroom and green peppers.
What is the point of ordering double toppings when you only get a sprinkle anyway?
And no, they weren’t “under the cheese.”
I wasted one of the toppings in my order because double mushroom is apparently the same as normal mushroom.
I may as well pick three different toppings so I at least know I’m getting all three.
But judging from the pathetic amount of pineapple on my other pizza, maybe not.
I love this location, even though they won’t deliver to me because I’m two minutes outside of their delivery radius, and they’ve never really let me down until now or I’d be rating lower.
If this is normal, and I’m just overreacting, then disregard this review.
But it’s super disappointing to drive 17 minutes out to this place, only to get home and find the bare minimum.
The pizza is always good, the amount of cheese is fine, no issues with the sauce, but this was so disappointing I had to say something.
At least it’s not as bad as the other Papa John’s I reviewed when I lived in Ohio…they really screwed me over. It was just bread with sauce. I posted my review with pictures and a week later their quality improved tenfold. I genuinely hope this helps course correct this location.
We really love your pizza and we make the extra drive just for you guys, so no hard feelings are intended.
… moreMy order was a pizza with pineapple, normal.
The second pizza was a large pizza with double mushroom and green peppers.
What is the point of ordering double toppings when you only get a sprinkle anyway?
And no, they weren’t “under the cheese.”
I wasted one of the toppings in my order because double mushroom is apparently the same as normal mushroom.
I may as well pick three different toppings so I at least know I’m getting all three.
But judging from the pathetic amount of pineapple on my other pizza, maybe not.
I love this location, even though they won’t deliver to me because I’m two minutes outside of their delivery radius, and they’ve never really let me down until now or I’d be rating lower.
If this is normal, and I’m just overreacting, then disregard this review.
But it’s super disappointing to drive 17 minutes out to this place, only to get home and find the bare minimum.
The pizza is always good, the amount of cheese is fine, no issues with the sauce, but this was so disappointing I had to say something.
At least it’s not as bad as the other Papa John’s I reviewed when I lived in Ohio…they really screwed me over. It was just bread with sauce. I posted my review with pictures and a week later their quality improved tenfold. I genuinely hope this helps course correct this location.
We really love your pizza and we make the extra drive just for you guys, so no hard feelings are intended.
jonathan quevedo
Very pleasant experience, very kind service and the pizza smelled and tasted amazing, thank you to all the workers here! Did not have to wait long at all service is 10 stars!
… moreBhavik Kumar Jain
The best pizza here in the old bridge. I am a vegetarian but please do try the other options because I am pretty sure they will be tasty too. The garlic breadsticks as a side dish is the best option and also the garlic nuggets are also a good option. The cost of a large pizza is not that high. If you are three people within 30 dollars you all will be full. I can guarantee you because the size of the pizza is very good and also the taste is very good.
It’s better than dominos in comparison and the garlic dip sauce is the best dipping sauce they give you to have the pizza with. Don’t forget to have coke with it. Enjoy the pizza and have a great day ahead. Thank you
… moreIt’s better than dominos in comparison and the garlic dip sauce is the best dipping sauce they give you to have the pizza with. Don’t forget to have coke with it. Enjoy the pizza and have a great day ahead. Thank you
Basement Studio
Excellent Custmor server. One the most friendly. The most important the pizza is delicious and the cheese properly melted. It’s wonderful I will keep coming.
… moreSamreen Vora
Great food, tasted delicious! Cheese was perfectly melted and crust was soft and chewy. Would totally buy again! Overall awesome experience!!!!
… moreZeeshan
Great team, great service, great food! Let this location handle your dinner plans and enjoy an stress-free night and a delicious meal. Highly recommend!
… moreMohammad Hamza bacha
Best place to eat pizza , loved the food quality and taste.
The service was excellent, the store was very clean and staff was very friendly and nice,
From now on my favorite place to eat in late night.
… moreThe service was excellent, the store was very clean and staff was very friendly and nice,
From now on my favorite place to eat in late night.
bashir hussain
Delicious Pizza.
Especially the vegi with jelopino.
Garlic Parm bread is my favorite.
The kid behind the counter was fast .
… moreEspecially the vegi with jelopino.
Garlic Parm bread is my favorite.
The kid behind the counter was fast .
Ananya Gupta
I think a lot of the reviewers are already depicting the poor operational and careless standard at this location.
My experience was not much different. There were barely any pineapples and vegetables as part of the toppings. Mine was a carry out user l order, so I popped up the cover in the store to find that it had only a single pepperoncini and garlic butter container for a large pizza order. Why would you do that? If I did not check it in the store, I’d be sorely disappointed by the time I got home with the food. After asking for more pepperoncini, I did not have the heart to ask for another garlic sauce container.
At some level, this was just poor work conscientiousness.
The pizza otherwise was good.
… moreMy experience was not much different. There were barely any pineapples and vegetables as part of the toppings. Mine was a carry out user l order, so I popped up the cover in the store to find that it had only a single pepperoncini and garlic butter container for a large pizza order. Why would you do that? If I did not check it in the store, I’d be sorely disappointed by the time I got home with the food. After asking for more pepperoncini, I did not have the heart to ask for another garlic sauce container.
At some level, this was just poor work conscientiousness.
The pizza otherwise was good.