Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Local pizzeria doling out New York-style pies, pastas & other Italian eats in an informal setting.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 960 Colonial Grand Ln, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Phone: (407) 936-3300
Website: https://www.papajoesfl.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
MENU | papa-joes-pizza
Click for Takeout Menu Page 1 & CATERING MENU. JPEG_20241214_190601_1127183362371025148_converted.pdf. Click for Takeout Menu Page 2.
Best Pizza Lake Mary | Papa Joe’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant …
Pizza & Italian restaurant, family owned since 1988. Serving chicken, veal, seafood, appetizers, salads, desserts, eggplant, beer and wine. one f central …
Papa Joe’s | Lake Mary FL – Facebook
Papa Joe’s, Lake Mary. 2159 likes · 6 talking about this · 2821 were here. Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant with full menu offering dining and pick up….
Reviews
Khoi R
Our waitress Kim was very friendly, helped us out with any question we had. We appreciate her for the service she gave us and the friendly attitude she had. 100% recommend the food here, it was all delicious. The Grilled Chicken Breast meal was on top with flavor! The seasoning was absolutely perfect. The Tuxedo Boome was a delicious way to end dinner. Thank you so much, Kim and all the chefs that were here tonight!
… moreDaniella Brenes
The food was delicious — fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. The pasta I ordered tasted homemade, the sauce was rich and balanced, and the portion just perfect. My daughter had the Alfredo and devoured it. She said it was the creamiest Alfredo she’s ever had. The garlic knots were amazing! Who is even complaining about those? They were PERFECT. Every dish felt like it was made with real care. The dessert was the perfect finishing touch, especially the cannolis, they were light, creamy, and fresh. Our waiter and staff were very friendly and attentive.
Overall, this restaurant exceeded my expectations in every way. If you’re looking for amazing Italian food paired with great service this is the place to go. Highly recommend!
… moreOverall, this restaurant exceeded my expectations in every way. If you’re looking for amazing Italian food paired with great service this is the place to go. Highly recommend!
The Everyday Life
The food here was delicious.Especially the meatballs and pizza.The breadsticks were super tasty.Good vibe and I received excellent service.Very reasonable prices too.You can watch all my reviews on my YouTube channel at EverydayLife4u
… moretroy griffin
I thoroughly enjoy the pizza at Papa Joes. The cook (Miguel) does an excellent job with all of the food. The service from Kim is always outstanding. My wife and I have been going there for more than 15 years and it never disappoints. I highly recommend this as a great dining experience before a movie at Santikos Theatre in Lake Mary.
… moreChristoper Y
I’ve been going to Papa Joe’s for nearly 20 years, and hands down, they have the best spaghetti and pizza in Central Florida. The food is always amazing, and the staff makes you feel like family.
Huge thanks to Mike G for always taking great care of me and my family—we truly appreciate it. I make sure to stop by for a pizza whenever I’m in town.
Highly recommended!!
… moreHuge thanks to Mike G for always taking great care of me and my family—we truly appreciate it. I make sure to stop by for a pizza whenever I’m in town.
Highly recommended!!
Alonna Thomson
Absolutely amazing PIZZA! The Best in the area! Dawson was by far, the sweetest and most responsive server! We are from Daytona and will definitely be back. I’m from NJ, so good pizza will always bring me back!
… moreJamie
Im sorry man, I just wanted to grab something to eat after the movies, the service was really nice, and I really wanted to like it, but when the cook can’t make a burger you know something’s wrong. My burger arrived completely raw which I noticed after eating some due to its repulsive texture and aftertaste. I was comped for my food and got a free slice of pizza, but it was disappointingly greasy as you can see in many images other reviewers have shown. I did not enjoy a single thing I ordered. Thank you for serving me, I’m sorry you had to give me that burger.
… moreMegan Haskins
Food was great, dining on the patio was cozy and our server Ryan was awesome! He was so attentive and kind, and I’m so glad our family chose to go there for dinner! Pizza was absolutely delicious with a crunchy crust and quality toppings. I’m sad I don’t live close enough to make this a regular place to eat!
… moremaster mindz
Normally when me and my family comes, it’s a great experience came in Tuesday evening. The new server was not on point Juan The pizza came out first everything else came out second third and last if you order appetizers they should come first right not sure if it was miscommunication with the Kitchen, but we put everything in at one time I tried to call the Restaurant today to talk about it and whoever answer the phone had an attitude
… moreJulianna Hardenbrook
Honestly, If you haven’t been here to dine you’re missing out!!!! The pizza is honestly the best we’ve had in FL. The chicken parm is another favorite of ours, Everything is made from scratch!! Just WOW.
Can’t forget the best part, the service! Antwon has served us multiple times and he is AMAZING, attentive, quick & so sweet!! 10/10 go here!
… moreCan’t forget the best part, the service! Antwon has served us multiple times and he is AMAZING, attentive, quick & so sweet!! 10/10 go here!