Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Airy, colorful pizzeria with a modest patio & menu of thick- or thin-crust pies, pasta & subs.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 224 W Cottage Grove Rd, Cottage Grove, WI 53527
Phone: (608) 839-3102
Website: http://www.papajimmys.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Jimmy’s Pizza PJs – Cottage Grove, Wisconsin –
Order online, call us @ 608-839-3102, menu, pizza & calzone, Jimmy’s Munchies, pasta, subs, salads, beverages, ice cream, full menu, deals, lunch combos, …
Pizza and Wings – Cold & Hot Subs | Cottage Grove, WI – Valpak
Specialty Pizza | Sub Sandwiches | Homemade Lasagna | Fresh Salads. Print your Papa Jimmy’s pizza coupons here! Papa Jimmy’s Pizzeria is a family-owned …
Papa Jimmy’s Pizzeria (@pjspizzeria) · Cottage Grove, WI – Instagram
253 followers · 93 posts · Fresh, homemade pizza. Just the way you like it.
Reviews
Liv K.
Besides the marinara sauce, I wasn’t impressed with anything we ordered. The mac was bland and not cheesy. The cheese bread had no color, just melted mozzarella on top. And the lasagna was just a thick stack of noodles coated in sauce. I still need to try the pizza; I hope it’s cheesy!
… moreTrinatronMon
Rock solid pizza joint. Great pizza. Expensive…but if you want a quality pizza every so often, it’s worth it.
Spinach delight, belly buster and hot honey heater are among the best.
Love that they also serve ice cream, and the kids that work here are always friendly.
See you again soon!
… moreSpinach delight, belly buster and hot honey heater are among the best.
Love that they also serve ice cream, and the kids that work here are always friendly.
See you again soon!
Mrs. J Roth
Our first time. A lot to choose from (pizza, subs, chicken bites, salads, pasta, ice cream) including appetizers. We tried the lasagna, their pepperoni pizza by the slice, garlic bread and cheese bread. All in with 2 drinks was less than. $30. They give a discount if you use cash.
… moreLacey P.
Ordered online-2 pizzas. First time from this restaurant. The beef & pepperoni pizza was burnt. Black spots all over the crust. Normally, it doesn’t bother me, but they were so big It just tasted like char and it was not edible. The cheese pizza was seriously over cooked. Dark brown/black but the crust wasn’t black. Not acceptable for 60.00 worth of pizza. That should have never left the restaurant.
… moreAndrew West
My wife and I had the pleasure of trying Papa Jimmy’s Pizzeria tonight.
We both really enjoyed the thin crust pepperoni pizza. If you like pizza with a good crunchy crust like we do, then you will throughly enjoy this. Cheese great, pepperoni excellent, and when you add in some tasty sauce it’s amazing.
The breadsticks were really soft and pillowy. These were my wife’s favorite and she especially enjoyed the dusting of parmesan cheese on top.
I ordered the mozzerella sticks for myself (no I did not share lol). These are my favorite mozzerella sticks. There are a few places that carry similar tasting versions of these, and I thoroughly enjoy them every time. Yum!
And we can’t forget to mention the ice cream. The Chocolate Shoppe has THE BEST ice cream ever and shout out to Papa Jimmy’s for serving it.
Will eat again
… moreWe both really enjoyed the thin crust pepperoni pizza. If you like pizza with a good crunchy crust like we do, then you will throughly enjoy this. Cheese great, pepperoni excellent, and when you add in some tasty sauce it’s amazing.
The breadsticks were really soft and pillowy. These were my wife’s favorite and she especially enjoyed the dusting of parmesan cheese on top.
I ordered the mozzerella sticks for myself (no I did not share lol). These are my favorite mozzerella sticks. There are a few places that carry similar tasting versions of these, and I thoroughly enjoy them every time. Yum!
And we can’t forget to mention the ice cream. The Chocolate Shoppe has THE BEST ice cream ever and shout out to Papa Jimmy’s for serving it.
Will eat again
Kenny Broyles
1- Pizza with a side of deception on pricing…(Paying for toppings that aren’t there)
2- Also, I Ordered a 14″ but it was measured at 13″.
2- Middle crust was a soggy mess
So I ive in McFarland and wanted to try a new pizza place. So I Ordered a 14″ Supreme pizza. I don’t eat sausage and not a fan of olives on pizza, so I replaced sausage with beef, and olives with spinach leaves.
The medium pizza ended over $30. I think it was like $31 and some change.
After I got the pizza I asked for a receipt because I was trying to understand why it was so much for a Medium pizza.
Immediately after asking for the receipt, the guy said “are you wondering why the pizza was expensive?” (As if he already knew that it was kind of shady on how I was charged) and I said yes, exactly…
He said well when you replace toppings, it doesn’t actually replace the toppings. You get charged as if you were adding more toppings. It’s just how the system works he told me.
Well Papa Jimmy’s, your system sucks, and next time maybe don’t sound like you already know it’s deceptive, and pull it off like there is nothing you can do other than tell me it’s just how the system works.
What a disappointing experience.
… more2- Also, I Ordered a 14″ but it was measured at 13″.
2- Middle crust was a soggy mess
So I ive in McFarland and wanted to try a new pizza place. So I Ordered a 14″ Supreme pizza. I don’t eat sausage and not a fan of olives on pizza, so I replaced sausage with beef, and olives with spinach leaves.
The medium pizza ended over $30. I think it was like $31 and some change.
After I got the pizza I asked for a receipt because I was trying to understand why it was so much for a Medium pizza.
Immediately after asking for the receipt, the guy said “are you wondering why the pizza was expensive?” (As if he already knew that it was kind of shady on how I was charged) and I said yes, exactly…
He said well when you replace toppings, it doesn’t actually replace the toppings. You get charged as if you were adding more toppings. It’s just how the system works he told me.
Well Papa Jimmy’s, your system sucks, and next time maybe don’t sound like you already know it’s deceptive, and pull it off like there is nothing you can do other than tell me it’s just how the system works.
What a disappointing experience.
Olivia Deedrick
We did Papa Jimmy’s Pizzeria takeout for our wedding rehearsal dinner and everyone loved it!
We were planning on having a casual sit down dinner at a bar/pizza restaurant that was connected to the hotel, but it closed a month before our wedding. Our venue’s owner told us that if we were looking for Pizza, Papa Jimmy’s was the way to go. We tried it that day. It was delicious, but they did not have the dine-in space needed for our large family. We decided we would use a meeting space at the hotel and order the pizzas for takeout. They were delicious, offered a gluten free option for those that needed it, and everything was hot and ready on time. They were very grateful we chose them and were very sweet. We will definitely be back.
… moreWe were planning on having a casual sit down dinner at a bar/pizza restaurant that was connected to the hotel, but it closed a month before our wedding. Our venue’s owner told us that if we were looking for Pizza, Papa Jimmy’s was the way to go. We tried it that day. It was delicious, but they did not have the dine-in space needed for our large family. We decided we would use a meeting space at the hotel and order the pizzas for takeout. They were delicious, offered a gluten free option for those that needed it, and everything was hot and ready on time. They were very grateful we chose them and were very sweet. We will definitely be back.
Monica Wichgers
Excellent service,very friendly staff. Best wings , crispy and delicious. I will order chicken wings from here for my next party.Thanks, Monica
… moreSteven Johnson
Called to order a deep dish pizza – luckily I asked if the sauce was on top like a traditional Chicago style deep dish to clarify, it is not, it’s simply a thick crust pizza. (They said their Pizza is like Pizza huts – disgusting!) Why do pizza places continue to misuse terms and call pizzas deep dish or New York style when they are not those styles? It makes me doubt the entire restaurant, I won’t eat here because they don’t know what pizza is, how could they possibly make it right?
… moreJacob Zuehlke
This is a fun pizza place with ice cream and pizza. Pickup times are quick and the pizza was made with quality. The only reason I give it 4 stars is the price. I paid $17.50 for a 10″ pizza. If prices could be a bit more reasonable, I would rate it 5 Stars. Will definitely go again in the future.
… more