Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5216 Bethel Center Mall, Columbus, OH 43220
Phone: (614) 459-1111
Website: http://papagiorgiosohio.com/
papagiorgios.hrpos.heartland.us
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home | Delicious Pizza at Papa Giorgio’s
Explore Papa Giorgio’s for the best pizza in Ohio … Contact us and we can discuss what you need. Papa Giorgio’s. 5216 Bethel Center Mall, Columbus, Ohio 43220, …
Family Special – Papa Giorgio’s
Buffalo Hot Sauce base with chicken, mozzarella/provolone cheese and ranch drizzle on top. Veggie Pizza. $15.49 / $21.49.
Papa Giorgio’s | Columbus OH – Facebook
Try our Sicilian pan pizza at Papagiorgiosohio.com Use promo code 3free for three dollars off your online order. Or stop in for a jumbo slice. #pizzacolumbus # …
Reviews
Randi Mockensturm
Pizza crust had no flavor. Overall greasy. Contents seemed like they were out of a can. We had one slice each and threw the rest away. The guy who waited on me was personable and friendly.
… morelarry blythe
First time there and the pizza was awesome. Fresh made, delicious and very much like pizza i have had in New York. I will be back often now.
… moreT H
I never thought I would find a grease stain sexy ! Their pizza is delicious, service friendly, and best of all around two minutes away from where I live. Nothing negative to say and will be getting pizza from here frequently. Oh and not sure if their blue cheese and garlic sauces are made in house but they are delicious!!
… morejohn m
Great NY style pizza! This spot years ago had a great new style pizza then a new place took over that had bad thin crust. Now its another New York style place that AMAZING. The pizza has tons of flavor, clearly great quality ingredients. I love the Ezzo Old World pep they use and the cheese is perfect & stringy. This is my new favorite pizza place in the area. Finally something great!!
… moreLance Perry
I decided to give them a try tonight because I had a flyer w a really good coupon. I tried an Italian sub and a cheese pizza. This is a classic pizza joint. My order was ready in 10 minutes, and the food was really good. Excellent. The Italian sub was toasty, tasty, and loaded. So good. The pizza has a great thin crust, big slices, and great flavors. This will be my new go to pizza joint.
… moreRishi Malhotra (PizzaKong)
Your average NY style pizza. Conveyor cooked, the cheese was average quality (probably Grande). Good sauce, slightly acidic. A bit fresher than a good Sbarro’s pie.
… moreJ S
Went in with my 10 year old son to buy a cheese slice. Afterwards he rated it 3.3 out of 10 and said it was barely warm and really greasy. He said Sam’s club pizza is better. Never again
… moreTobias Simon
I really like this place, I really like this guy he is super friendly and it feels authentic. I just really need a dine in experience. These places make their money on take out I get that but want that as fresh as can be on the table with a crispy fountain soda
… moreLaura Clark
The pasta came in an upside down box spilling out. I still tried to eat it, but the meatballs were WET and had zero flavor. The pasta was way overcooked and the sauce also had no flavor. The brownie was so thin, it was also overbaked. I have no idea how this place is so highly ranked. It was a huge disappointment and a waste of money.
… morea k
This is hands down some of the best pizza I’ve had in columbus. Its as good if not better than the pizza I’ve had in NYC. The crust is just right, the sauce is great, the toppings are generous and there’s just the right amount of cheese. Everything works together to create an amazing pizza.
Its not a fancy pizza either. Its exactly what you think of when you think of a really good pizza. And it’s ready for pickup in liie 15 minutes which works even better. The only problem is that I had trouble stopping myself from eating 2 whole mediums pizzas in one sitting.
… moreIts not a fancy pizza either. Its exactly what you think of when you think of a really good pizza. And it’s ready for pickup in liie 15 minutes which works even better. The only problem is that I had trouble stopping myself from eating 2 whole mediums pizzas in one sitting.