Joseph Flanagan
I really want to like Pantry Pizza. It is incredibly convenient to my house, and the owners and staff are always nice. That kindness is the only reason I’ve given them so many chances. The ingredients taste like the cheapest options available from the distributor (nothing is homemade I’m convinced), and the assembly feels slapped together with zero pride.
With better competition moving into the neighborhood, Pantry needs to understand that convenience isn’t enough anymore. You have to actually try.
Here is the breakdown of our disappointment:
– Cheese Pizza (2/10): It is baffling how a pizza can have absolutely no flavor; the sauce is bland, the cheese bland, and the dough bland!
– Calzone (1/10): I live a five minute walk from the shop, yet this was already a soggy mess by the time I got home.
– The Gobbler Sub & Boneless Wings (6/10): These are the only redeeming items on the menu and only things I recommend.
And my god the tomatoes they use!!! Please stop using these. They are the unripe, flavorless, watery stereotype of bad sub shop vegetable. Just leave out if you can’t get better ones.
I want to support local, but I can’t anymore. Please make some improvements.
… moreTerry Singh
Heart of savin hill. Best pizza and wings in the area . Very clean restaurant, a friendly service lady at the counter. It’s very nice. Fresh slices, ready to go I was in on Dorchester day and he had a special going on small Cheese Pizza for it. It’s six dollars is seventeen cent.. it’s a Boston thing.
If you know you know. I would like to go there and try other things next time. I’m around in that area.
… morekevin english
Overall I was disappointed with this experience. I placed a pickup order and was told it would be 15 minutes at 1252. I didn’t leave the store until 130 ish after arriving in 15 minutes. The cheesy garlic bread was okay but pretty bland, same with the chicken on the chicken bacon ranch fries. The wings were good but overall the food was good not great. The portion sizes are nice though.
… moreDennis Bowen
Online system took my money and the order never got to the store, they said it was just a hold on my card and to reach out to the card company or wait a few days, NO you should make sure your system works for 30 dollar pizzas. They are local and wanted to give them a second chance few months later. Same exact thing happened again with no recourse and same garbage customer service. I was in a rush and grabbed a couple chicken bacon ranch slices for 11.00 DOLLARS! and wow HORRIBLE!! luke warm zero flavor chicken tasted bland and boiled. Will never go back to this place. 0/0
… moreKim 02125
Ordered a steak and cheese sub and it’s disgusting. This isn’t steak. It’s hamburger and cheese on soggy bread and the cheese was an after thought.
Every time I try to give this place another chance it reminds me why I’d rather order from Uphams House of Pizza and get delivery then walk around the corner and eat this crap.
Just tossed this in the trash barrel.
… moreTheRealSatan
These folks work efficiently and have fresh and tasty ingredients. I cannot stop coming here.
… moreJosephine Swenson
Genuinely the nicest ladies at the front and are so kind and fun to talk to!! All the food is delicious as well, mozzarella sticks are amazing and the pizza too duhhhh!!!! Love it!!
… moreAnil N
We ordered pizza, garlic bread and fries. Pizza was very bad, tasted so bitter/sour felt like stale cheese or olives. I wouldn’t recommend having Pizza at Pantry Pizza. Garlic bread was edible, although fries are recommended.
… moreDesiree Modugno
We ordered an Alfredo chicken spinach and feta large pizza and large mozzarella sticks. On the phone we said the pizza name and they went “so you want a white pizza” no I want an Alfredo spinach chicken and feta. They said okay. We picked it up and it was just Alfredo and cheese. I went back and she tried saying thats what we ordered. The kid on the phone said we didn’t say anything about chicken spinach and feta. They said we didn’t even know the name of the store so it was our fault. I had to tell her that I did know the name and she confirmed it was in fact the name. That my order was repeated a couple of times so it’s not my ends fault. She was huffing and puffing at me. I tried getting a refund and she said they won’t allow it since I apparently wasted the pizza. Mozzarella sticks weren’t hot and the sauce was more liquid than marinara sauce. The second time I got my pizza not all the chicken was fully cooked. I had high hopes for this place but I wouldn’t recommend it at all.
… moreJoAnne Thompson
Pizzas were delicious and cooked perfectly per instructions. Sizes are slightly smaller than other pizzerias.
… more