Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Pasta, surf ’n’ turf & other basics are offered at this comfy spot with a patio & a casual ambiance.
Hours
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 3–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 3–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 74 Main St S, Bethlehem, CT 06751
Phone: (203) 266-5771
Website: http://paintedponyrestaurant.net/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Painted Pony | American Restaurant in Bethlehem, CT
Modern yet rural family dining with plenty of space for special events, known for our own Oven Roasted Prime Rib.
The New Painted Pony Restaurant | Bethlehem CT – Facebook
The New Painted Pony Restaurant, Bethlehem. 4199 likes · 85 talking about this · 3609 were here. Recently re-opened on October 2 2019, excited to bring…
The Painted Pony (@paintedponyct) · Bethlehem, CT – Instagram
493 followers · 46 posts · Come enjoy a cocktail an appetizer or an entree in our cozy atmosphere! ❄️ . . . New Website & Menu.
Reviews
Liv Danaher
We got the fig jam flat bread and the southern fried chicken sandwich and they were absolutely delicious! Service was fast and great. Restaurant itself if very clean and appealing to look at. Fair pricing as well.
… moreSusan
No joke, my boyfriend keeps talking about how this was the most tender chicken he’s ever had. He could’ve eaten it with a spork was so tender.
And I know everybody loves prime rib, and their location is the best location but, no joke, this is the best prime rib I’ve ever had the rub flavors ran deep and the entire 14 ounces was cooked to perfection. And the bartender was just such a beautiful soul. I would go back just for them and their mixology
Love love love this place!
… moreAnd I know everybody loves prime rib, and their location is the best location but, no joke, this is the best prime rib I’ve ever had the rub flavors ran deep and the entire 14 ounces was cooked to perfection. And the bartender was just such a beautiful soul. I would go back just for them and their mixology
Love love love this place!
Valon Sadiku
Amazing service is an understatement. The new painted pony restaurant is an amazing place for people of all Ages with events all through the week such as trivia on Tuesdays and bands every Saturday this place has it all. The amazing menu is only beat by the amazing food options. The fries are amazing and while there are many pasta dishes the chicken parm in particular is amazing don’t listen to what the haters say the painted pony is an amazing place for you and the whole family. I will be coming back.
… moreSteve Antonacci
We stopped here after our visit to March farm in Bethlehem where we picked up pumpkins and the best apple cider doughnuts. We stopped in at the Painted Pony around 3 in the afternoon . The place was empty which is a shame since it’s a good place . Everything was spotless and the service was good . My wife had the chicken avocado sandwich and a side salad , I had the flatbread topped with Asiago cheese, short rib and tomatoes. Both were presented well and tasty, nothing mind blowing but worth the money , if your in the area give it a try .
… moreTim Flanagan
Great friendly restaurant in the heart of Bethlehem CT. Service , food and prices all good. Owners are super nice. Great place for a meal or an event…
… moreHolly Mottai
Had a 70th birthday celebration including 16 family members and friends. The waitress, Helen, was quite attentive to our needs with timely service. The space was perfect and food excellent.
… moreErich Wenis
A really great place oozing atmosphere.
Great food residency priced, with many drink options.
The specialty drinks were not priced and cost more then we’d expected at $12, but we’re very well made.
Get the wings and the jalapeno dip (request extra jalapeno).
I’m told the calamari is very good as well.
Great attentive service, with smiles all around
… moreGreat food residency priced, with many drink options.
The specialty drinks were not priced and cost more then we’d expected at $12, but we’re very well made.
Get the wings and the jalapeno dip (request extra jalapeno).
I’m told the calamari is very good as well.
Great attentive service, with smiles all around
Eric Schofield
I’m so glad we chose to eat here! We called in an order for pickup and the order was ready before their estimate, I barely had time to finish a beer while I was waiting The food was really good, the portions are generous and the price is right.
We’re looking forward to the next time we have a chance to go back and try some more of what they have to offer. If the simple handhelds we got are any indication, their dinner offerings should be fantastic.
… moreWe’re looking forward to the next time we have a chance to go back and try some more of what they have to offer. If the simple handhelds we got are any indication, their dinner offerings should be fantastic.
Ernest Pitti
It was a beautiful drive there through the countryside and the foliage. And when we got there, the service and the food did not disappoint! I had the homemade pasta with white clam sauce and Maggie had their version of a seafood medley served on their homemade pasta and both were delicious! We topped of our evening with a exquisite rich chocolate cake and coffee. The cake was great but the coffee was a little weak. I’d definitely go back there again. Maybe next time it will be another Saturday night but this time we’ll make arrangements to enjoy their live bands!
… more