Pagliai's Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Murray, KY 42071

Pagliai’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant, 970 Chestnut Street ~ Murray, KY (270) 753-2975. Voted Murray’s Favorite Pizza! Home bullet Menu bullet About bullet …

Pagliai’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant 970 Chestnut Street – Order Online

Pagliai’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant. 970 Chestnut St, Murray, KY 42071, USAOnline ordering hours: 10:45 AM – 7:40 PM.

Pagliai’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant (Murray) – Kentucky Tourism

Pagliai’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant (Murray). (270) 753-2975 970 Chestnut St., Murray, KY 42071 … Pagliai’s Pizza not only serves the best pizza, but …

Reviews

Jim Thompson

Even though the place was dead quiet, our server, Cheyenne absolutely CARRIED the whole experience. So attentive, so kind, and genuinely made us feel welcome instead of forgotten. Checked in just the right amount, great energy, and clearly cared about doing an amazing job. The lasagna was bomb, but the service is what really stood out. Please protect and promote this server at all costs — they deserve all the praise. Will 100% be back because of her alone.

… more

Jess B

I came in Wednesday and had the pleasure of having Shianne as my server. She was very attentive and knowledgeable of the menu. She got us what we needed before we even knew we needed it. She is an absolute treasure and y’all need to give that girl a raise. Will definitely be back and asking for her!!

… more

Gary Farmer

Lasagna and salad were GREAT!
Service was GREAT!
Restaurant was CLEAN!

… more

Donna Lynn

I ask for the pizza to be “well done.” Try it once that way; when you do you will never go back!
If I could make one HUGE suggestion… please get a deep fryer. Forgot, this is how it’s always been; think about what it can become. Fries with every sandwich! Mozzarella cheese sticks in your marinara sauce! An appetizer entree- cheese sticks, zucchini sticks, and mushrooms; oh my!

… more

teresa hamlet

This is one place I will not return our waitress was a young girl that when asking a question no one could u dwestand what she said after the 3 time of asking to repeat I gave up the food was so so not fresh and no variety of pizza at all and the it was skimpy on topping. The salad bar was Fresh and tasted good but the pizz was a waste then when trying to pay the employees talked to each other and laughing when we are standing and waiting to pay

… more

Matt Biallas

Honestly I didn’t want to eat here. Some friends and I were trying to agree on a dinner place and I had already used my veto. But it turned out far far better that I thought and we had a nice evening. The wait staff were surprisingly engaging & friendly and the food was tasty. Strangely enough, my favorite thing was the poppy seed salad dressing – holy crap it’s addictive. Pretty sure the next time in the area, I’ll swing by again!

… more

Lance Allison

Every time I’m in town I have my favorite Pepperoni and Italian Sausage pizza. Sooooooo good!

… more

Willow & Ivy Toggenburg

First time in the restaurant. It was slow, not many customers. Right away I could tell it was not a popular restaurant for a Friday night. We ordered two buffets and the waitress knowing it was my first time said I could also order a pizza with 3 toppings. Surprised we ordered one right away. The Buffett food was cold and looked old. None appealing spaghetti, other dried out pasta, and cafeteria salad bar that was edible and old pizza sitting under lights. To say we were not impressed is being very kind. We decided to stick it out as we thought a fresh pizza was on the way. We waited 50 minutes with the waitress apologizing for the pizza being late and noticing us annoyed two other times. Finally we stood up and she said the pizza had been placed on the buffet bar?!? Why would she not let us know? Irritated we paid full price for a couple very small salads that were edible and nothing and our sodas. We also still tipped the waitress but wish we didn’t. This restaurant needs to do so much better with the quality of the buffet bar and explaining the process. We ended up ordering a pizza at pappa johns.

… more

Shauna Crane

Best Italian food in Murray. Everytime we are in town we have to stop by. I love the thick crust pizza. Ohh and you have to get a side of Blue Cheese. Sooooo good.

… more

Brent Webster

I enjoy the buffet for lunch and dinner. The pizza is quite good, and the salad bar is decent, and the pasta adds some nice choices. Most of the servers are excellent. Shianne was wonderful, so sweet and welcoming and attentive! I recommend asking for her to be your server! Also, I like that the noise level is relatively low, even when the restaurant is full – it’s easy to relax while enjoying good food and service.

… more

… View more

Pagliai’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results