Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Southold Pagano’s Closes; Pizzeria Opens at Greenport Location
This past Saturday was the last day of service at Pagano’s — a longstanding place for pizza and other Italian cuisine in downtown Southold.
Paganos Pizzeria & Restaurant – MapQuest
Pagano’s Pizzeria in Southold, NY offers a menu featuring classic and specialty pizzas, along with pasta, soups, and crab cakes.
Pagano’s Pizza
Pagano’s Pizza. 0. Home; My Cart0; Inbox · Contact Us · Search · Sign In … 46455 ROUTE 48 SOUTHOLD, SOUTHOLD, NY, 11971, US. Get Directions. Phone Number …
Reviews
Danny Cee
Always consistent, excellent pizza with spectacular service. Their specials are reasonably priced and change daily.
Best buffalo chicken slices in New York.
I’ve enjoyed paganos for the past 20 years. You can’t do better than this local gem.
… moreBest buffalo chicken slices in New York.
I’ve enjoyed paganos for the past 20 years. You can’t do better than this local gem.
Jonathan Siegal
The service was friendly and the establishment was clean. Unfortunately, the quality of the ingredients seemed really cheap, especially the cheese, and it was no less expensive than other pizza places that have fresher, tastier options.
This is also not a review from someone who has been there once. This was an experimental trial after giving up on this place a year ago and I’ve known the name of this pizzeria for over twenty years having eaten there as a kid.
… moreThis is also not a review from someone who has been there once. This was an experimental trial after giving up on this place a year ago and I’ve known the name of this pizzeria for over twenty years having eaten there as a kid.
Michael J. Lees, ABD
Great Pizza…borderline the best I have ever had. ONLY reason I did not give a 5 star rating on this order was because I ordered a BBQ Chicken pizza that says it has “Chicken and BBQ Sauce;” however, it also had onion on it, and that is literally the one thing I despise the most in life. I noticed the SLICELIFE website I ordered from does not say onions, however, the other ordering sites appear to be correct. The main website, and DOORDASH appear to be correct. I hope they update the online ordering to reflect there is onion on this pizza so I can order it without next time. Kinda ruined the experience for this pizza…will not stop me from ordering again – albeit, I will be a bit more careful.
… moreSteven Barraco
Good pizza but outrageously priced if you add toppings. Today I purchased two pies. One large cheese pizza and one large pizza, half vegetable and half sausage. With tax it came to over $46. Then to add insult to injury they charged a fee for using a credit card. Grand total – over $48 for two pizzas. Disgraceful.
… moreJean Kruk
Great pizza! And The Manicotti is awesome! Chicken parm hero was delicious too! I order from them all the time. They always deliver in a timely manor and it’s still nice and hot!
… moreAmber Moriarty
The person behind the counter was rude and aggressive. I asked if they had pepperoni and he told me they did and proceeded to throw a bunch of cold pepperoni on top of an already cooked cheese slice. Yummy??? Needless to say the pizza was mediocre and surprisingly expensive… my kids weren’t even interested in eating it. Not a winning combination.
… moreKathy Palmer
Ordered a pizza and wings. Was told it would be 30 to 40 minutes. Left and came back 40 min
Later. The wings were still not ready and the pizza was sitting on top of the oven. I commented on that fact and was told in a not very nice way “oh dont worry it’ll (the pizza) will be fine.” Eventually the wings were done and we got a pizza that had been sitting out for too long. Yuk
… moreLater. The wings were still not ready and the pizza was sitting on top of the oven. I commented on that fact and was told in a not very nice way “oh dont worry it’ll (the pizza) will be fine.” Eventually the wings were done and we got a pizza that had been sitting out for too long. Yuk
APEX GENERAL
Friendly staff, great pizzas and the garlic knots are the best I’ve ever had so tasty and fluffy. Love in every bite..
… moreRachelle Chills
Sorry to give this review but hopefully they will improve as a result and go back to how they used to be. Maybe i went on an off day but pizza was super old, tasted bad and not even cooked all the way. Flys everywhere too will not be going back anytime soon 🙁
… moreMike Macheski
Pizza is the best on the North Fork! We visit here each summer and always get pizza from Pagano’s. We always leave stuffed and very happy! The staff is also very friendly.
… more