Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 636 Union Blvd #3113, West Islip, NY 11795
Phone: (631) 661-6246
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Our Little Italy Pizza Pasta, West Islip, NY
We offer an extensive selection of pizzas, from classic Neapolitan-style to innovative gourmet creations. Our pasta dishes showcase the diversity of Italian …
Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta – West Islip, NY – 636 Union Blvd …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta in West Islip, NY. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Our Little Italy – West Islip, NY 11795 (Menu & Order Online)
Online ordering menu for Our Little Italy. Welcome to Our Little Italy in West Islip, New York! Our menu features Italian cuisine such as pasta, heroes, …
Last Updates
Reviews
J
A friend of mine told me to come here and try there pizza, he said it was really good. Uhhhhh not the one I had. Maybe he was talking about a specialty slice. Had the regular and it was ok.. it was too fluffy for me. Its not like a a real NY slice thin flat and crusty with crunchy bubbles on the edge. I think people forgot what NY pizza is..
… morematt lopez
Great food!! Service is excellent (ask for Ashley when she’s there.) Owner is also a great guy, on site, hands on, and lots of involvement with the local community
… moreEzgi Bebek
I came here all the way from Türkiye. My husband has been showing me around Long Island, and we stopped here on the way to the beach. The pizza is amazing; I love the macaroni and cheese pizza. Two birds, one stone! It’s also nice to see that they support the police department!
… moreRyan Koziol
Ordered through door dash, order never came. Said it was out for delivery and then the time of delivery just kept increasing every minute. DoorDash said you use your own couriers so I guess you didn’t have any drivers available. If you can’t deliver please don’t accept the order. I can’t rate the food because it never showed up, if the atmosphere is anything like the service then you can check that star.
… moreAl Y
Came in for the first time for a grandmother slice, the environment was very clean & the employees were okay.
However
The 2 grandma slices I purchased both tasted like pepperoni witch was an unpleasant experience as I do not consume pork & would appreciate using different utensils for each one of the different slices of pies, it genuinely tasted more like a pepperoni pizza, that left an unpleasant impression on my taste buds.
Once I finished the first slice at home & started eating the second slide I noticed a very small piece of plastic on the pizza then I realized I have to come and write this review , for these reasons I’d suggest the owner make some changes as I won’t be returning anytime soon & would rather drive to Lindenhurst for pizza now.
… moreHowever
The 2 grandma slices I purchased both tasted like pepperoni witch was an unpleasant experience as I do not consume pork & would appreciate using different utensils for each one of the different slices of pies, it genuinely tasted more like a pepperoni pizza, that left an unpleasant impression on my taste buds.
Once I finished the first slice at home & started eating the second slide I noticed a very small piece of plastic on the pizza then I realized I have to come and write this review , for these reasons I’d suggest the owner make some changes as I won’t be returning anytime soon & would rather drive to Lindenhurst for pizza now.
Glider RS
This was my first eatery I tried when stopping in Bay Shore for work. I ended up going here a lot. The options are great and it’s quick and easy. If it isn’t broke, don’t fix it.
… moreSandra Colasante
I ordered a pizza today pretty early and I have to say it has to be the best pizza I’ve ever eaten.The sauce is homemade and like no pizza I’ve ever tasted before.And the owner or worker was very hospitable.Ten outta Ten Happy customer
… moreDanielle
I used to love coming here but today was my last time. The pizza was luke warm and the cheese was like plastic. The white slice had caked on ricotta cheese…Last few times, the pizza has been cold, and just not good.
… moreJohn Jordan
We had an appetizer that was out of this world. We ordered mussels with marinara sauce, this is the third time I’ve ordered this – I’ve never been let down. The mussels were perfect, soft not rubbery combined with garlic infused sauce. Superb! Highly recommended. We also had the lunch special . Good portions, baked ziti and stuffed shells. Very satisfying and not saturated with enormous cheese nor salt.
… moreRichard Ferrick
Amazing neighborhood restaurant with friendly staff and some of the best tasting pizza I’ve ever had… and I’ve had a lot. Gotta try the Penne Alla Vodka. It’s very tasty. You won’t go wrong here.
… more