Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Busy outpost for tried-&-true Italian dishes & some signature twists in a shopping-center locale.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6385 NY-96 #200, Victor, NY 14564
Phone: (585) 742-2070
Website: http://www.ottotomottos.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Otto Tomottos | Italian Restaurant | Victor, NY
Otto Tomotto · Restaurants are located in the. Phoenix Mills Plaza Route 96 | Victor, NY 14564 · Restaurants are located in the Phoenix Mills Plaza | Route 96 | …
Otto Tomottos | Victor NY – Facebook
Otto Tomottos, Victor. 4378 likes · 22 talking about this · 5404 were here. Italian Restaurant.
Otto Tomotto’s | Victor, NY – Finger Lakes
Otto Tomotto’s. Great Italian food in house or catered. Don’t miss Mama’s. Visit Website ». 200 Phoenix Mills Victor, NY 14564. (585) 742-2070. TripAdvisor …
Reviews
Lucas LeRoy
4th time taking the family there- it’s been hit or
miss each time, but this was bad.
We were seated- then told that our specific table was reserved by someone else in an hour so we needed to be finished by then. The waiter said multiple times that he was flustered someone sat us there and he was thrown off his “game”
My kids got the kids pasta with meatball- pasta came out, no meatballs and my daughters pasta was wrong
My wife’s food came out with a hair in it- I picked the hair out in front of the server and put it on a napkin. No “I’m sorry” no “let’s get that replaced”… and my meal had so much thyme (spice) in it I didn’t even eat it. Literally left two fulls meals on the table.
But I made sure we were out of there right on time at 6:20 for you guys 🙂
… moremiss each time, but this was bad.
We were seated- then told that our specific table was reserved by someone else in an hour so we needed to be finished by then. The waiter said multiple times that he was flustered someone sat us there and he was thrown off his “game”
My kids got the kids pasta with meatball- pasta came out, no meatballs and my daughters pasta was wrong
My wife’s food came out with a hair in it- I picked the hair out in front of the server and put it on a napkin. No “I’m sorry” no “let’s get that replaced”… and my meal had so much thyme (spice) in it I didn’t even eat it. Literally left two fulls meals on the table.
But I made sure we were out of there right on time at 6:20 for you guys 🙂
Kayla Pizura
This was so amazing the food and the atmosphere everyone was awesome I got a appetizer 2 entrees and a dessert. I got the mozzarella bread stuff which was so good. The entrees I got was the carbonara and the 16oz steak and the we got there bills themed dessert. My brother got the clam pie which I tried and wasn’t bad. The bread and butter at the beginning was so good and the garlic taste to the butter was a nice surprise. I will for be going back.
… moreMichael Samodurov
Otto Tomotto’s has been recommended to us by a few family members, so we were looking forward to trying it. The atmosphere was lovely, the people were nice, and the food was good. I did also like the amount of options on the menu. The food was a little pricey though, so I don’t know if I would recommend it over my other local favorites like Prosseco. The big plus is that they have a more family centric restaurant with a party room.
First, the food was good. My wife tried the Tortellini Pomodoro, which was delicious. I would absolutely recommend trying it if you like very thick, creamy pasta.
I ordered the special intending to give that a review, but unfortunately they “literally just sold the last one” after I ordered it. Which was honestly very disappointing considering we were there at 6:30. The waiter recommended the Italian Fish Fry because it was similar, but fish instead of chicken. Unfortunately, I didn’t like it. It was extremely one note. The fish was pan fried and intended to be crispy, but it was soggy after sitting in the lemon butter sauce, which would be fine, if the sauce wasn’t basically lemon juice. All I tasted the entire time I ate was lemon juice. I didn’t taste any other flavors, just lemon. If I hadn’t eaten some of the pomodoro my wife ordered I would have given the food 2 stars.
We did try the cannolis, which we usually try at most Italian restaurants. And we did enjoy them. I felt they were worth the $7 for 2.
Unfortunately, I can’t review the salad because despite ordering it before our meal we never got it. It was only $2.50 for an add on salad, but we were disappointed that we had to let the waiter know we never received it.
I do want to mention that they do serve bread and it’s a nice Italian bread with a garlic butter that we did enjoy.
The atmosphere was comfortable. I liked the decor, but I don’t like restaurants that use paper to protect their table cloths. That’s just a personal preference.
Overall, I might give Otto tomotto’s another try sometime in the future, but it wasn’t my favorite place.
… moreFirst, the food was good. My wife tried the Tortellini Pomodoro, which was delicious. I would absolutely recommend trying it if you like very thick, creamy pasta.
I ordered the special intending to give that a review, but unfortunately they “literally just sold the last one” after I ordered it. Which was honestly very disappointing considering we were there at 6:30. The waiter recommended the Italian Fish Fry because it was similar, but fish instead of chicken. Unfortunately, I didn’t like it. It was extremely one note. The fish was pan fried and intended to be crispy, but it was soggy after sitting in the lemon butter sauce, which would be fine, if the sauce wasn’t basically lemon juice. All I tasted the entire time I ate was lemon juice. I didn’t taste any other flavors, just lemon. If I hadn’t eaten some of the pomodoro my wife ordered I would have given the food 2 stars.
We did try the cannolis, which we usually try at most Italian restaurants. And we did enjoy them. I felt they were worth the $7 for 2.
Unfortunately, I can’t review the salad because despite ordering it before our meal we never got it. It was only $2.50 for an add on salad, but we were disappointed that we had to let the waiter know we never received it.
I do want to mention that they do serve bread and it’s a nice Italian bread with a garlic butter that we did enjoy.
The atmosphere was comfortable. I liked the decor, but I don’t like restaurants that use paper to protect their table cloths. That’s just a personal preference.
Overall, I might give Otto tomotto’s another try sometime in the future, but it wasn’t my favorite place.
mypurplescience
This is my new favorite restaurant! We met family for a late evening dinner. The food was fresh and delicious. Portions were generous. Our waitress made sure our water glasses were always full. Tables are far enough apart that conversation was easy. So many traditional and unique choices. They also have a party room for larger groups. One of our party eats gluten free and there were many entrees to choose from, because they can customize.
… moreSonata Gill
I knew walking in and smelling the tomato sauce and experiencing the lovely, fakily-friendly atmosphere that this was going to be a great night! Have dined here before and it’s always a great experience.
Delicious food (I ordered the eggplant parmigiana). We had a wonderful, fun, attentive server. Good time had by all!
… moreDelicious food (I ordered the eggplant parmigiana). We had a wonderful, fun, attentive server. Good time had by all!
Ryan Hall
Went for lunch with my family. This place had alot of people recommending it. The inside was very nice, the food was average and the staff did not seem like the wanted to be there for a lunch crowd. Would not go back. The food was fine but did not wow me enough to want to make a second trip back.
… moreGary A
Our server, Mike, was friendly and attentive! We recommend the Crispy Cauliflower appetizer, Bruschetta Haddock, Cajun Shrimp Pasta, Cheese-filled Pasta Purses, and a big o’bowl of Penne. You’ll need a To-Go box because the portions are huge! Dine outside, if the weather is nice.
… moreNone Noone
Wonderful food. My family has goes here a few times a year. I don’t remember anyone ever getting a bad meal. It’s not the cheapest, but it’s quality food.
… moreDarlene Mascioletti
Oh my goodness-I found a new place I love! Otto Tomatto’s! I had the Seafood Pesto, and my husband had the C-food Medley. They were both seriously delicious!! We got a dessert to go because I had never heard of Tubolare before. I had no idea what I was missing! Suffice it to say, we’ll be returning!
… more