O’Toole’s Irish Pub

  4.3 – 169 reviews   • Bar

O'Toole's Irish Pub 43068

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

O’Toole’s Reynoldsburg – Home

O’Toole’s Irish Pub, nestled in the heart of Reynoldsburg, has been a beloved gathering spot for 30 years. It boasts a vibrant party atmosphere with daily …

O’toole’s Irish Pub Reynoldsburg – Home | Facebook

O’toole’s Irish Pub Reynoldsburg, Reynoldsburg, OH. 189 likes · 5 talking about this. Just for fun.

O’Toole’s Irish Pub, 7578 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, US

Located in Reynoldsburg, OH, O’Toole’s Irish Pub is a cozy haven for locals seeking a taste of Ireland right in their backyard. With its warm ambiance and …

Reviews

Laura Hanson
Went here with a few friends Saturday night and witnessed a bartender making a scene up and down the bar because some woman wrote something on the receipt about her tip or something. I can’t understand how hollering up and down the bar is going to help anything. It was so unprofessional and if I were the owner, I would be so embarrassed by that behavior in my place of business.
… more
Anne Grossman
Monday Karaoke night is so fun! Great sound system, large screen for the lyrics, nice outdoor patio, darts and pool tables. Attentive bartenders. And happy hour til 9pm on Mondays.
… more
D Socolov
Andrea was an attentive bartender. Very cool. The people there were chill and friendly. Nice local bar to tip a few.
… more
Stephanie Harley-Grove
Had Margarita on the rocks with salt. Great drink and good atmosphere! Not busy so it was great for just being able to chill
… more
Todd Travis
Great neighborhood bar with great staff we played in the band tonight and the crowd was lively – fun place
… more
Ashley Norris
First time here as a new resident of the Columbus area… Very friendly service. They don’t have a kitchen, but are next to ‘Donatos’ and have a window that makes it super easy to order and get food from there. I came on a Monday night so it was pretty slow, looking forward to checking the place out on a busier night
… more
Jon Keeling
I’d like to echo what Geoff said. Every time I’ve been there it’s like a new experience — almost as if it’s a brand new place. That’s the mark of a great bar. Staying unique. Staying fun. Love it.

UPDATE: HUGE fan of the tomato bisque. Tastes like how Mom made it before she died. God, I miss her.
… more
Marc Lichon
Hometown bar, great bartenders (especially Mandy and Alexis), good neighborhood crowd. Newly renovated from the ground up.
… more
Christina Miranda
I have to give a huge shout out to bartender Mandi!! Not just for the great service, but for being so honest when she didn’t have to be! Last evening my husband and I went to this bar for the first time, the day bar tender (also wonderful service and greeted with a big smile!) swiped our card to start a tab, my husband, being use to not swiping our card at our regular pub signed off on the receipt and paid cash – Mandi took the time to locate me on Facebook and send me a message to let me know that this happened and to hold our money at the office for us! Thank you Mandi for everything – you have defiantly earned 2 new customers!!
… more
Dustin Eades
This local spot is a great place to catch a game or shoot some pool. There used to be live music and karaoke most likely discontinued till covid has lifted its grasp. Remodel was major upgrade!! As the drink prices seem to upgrade as well. Atmosphere has always been good with great service. Definitely stop in if you dont already know.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment