Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Delicious, freshly made pizzas delivered straight to your door! Our pizzeria specializes in takeout and delivery, offering a wide range of mouth-watering pizzas, sides, and drinks. Order online or call us today for fast, friendly service unbeatable flavors and prices”
A family-run fixture since 1958, this corner pizzeria offers brick-oven pizza & traditional pastas.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6001 Park Ave, West New York, NJ 07093
Phone: (201) 861-2000
Website: https://www.originalprestospizzanj.com/?utm_source=gbp
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: originalprestospizzanj.com
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Original Presto’s Pizza – West New York, NJ – 6001 Park Avenue …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-10:00 PM; Shop address is 6001 Park Avenue, West New York, NJ 070936001 Park Avenue, West New York, NJ 07093; (201) 861-2000.
Original Presto’s Pizza – 6001 Park Avenue, West New York, NJ 07093
Order online at one of the best restaurants in West New York, NJ! Original Presto’s Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Orignal Presto’s World Famous Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta – Facebook
Orignal Presto’s World Famous Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta, West New York. 399 likes · 310 were here. Specializing in brick oven pizza and authentic Italian…
Reviews
Lamar Myers
The staff at this pizza shop is very nice and friendly, which I always appreciate. Unfortunately, the pizza quality has declined noticeably over the past year or two. The crust lacks flavor and the toppings don’t taste as fresh as they used to. I think using better quality ingredients could really turn things around, because the service is already there.
… morenandani madhukar
We loved this place that we went twice in a week…!
This is a family owned restaurant with good Italian food. I tried the chicken fingers with honey mustard sauce, garlic bread with cheese, fries, penne alla vodka. Liked all of them. However, I wasn’t a fan of chicken rigatoni.
The owner was sweet and gave us free dessert.
If you are in the neighborhood, definitely give it a try!
… moreThis is a family owned restaurant with good Italian food. I tried the chicken fingers with honey mustard sauce, garlic bread with cheese, fries, penne alla vodka. Liked all of them. However, I wasn’t a fan of chicken rigatoni.
The owner was sweet and gave us free dessert.
If you are in the neighborhood, definitely give it a try!
Izzy Oropesa
Ordered through a company Slice!
Terrible service!! Taylor and Lucy at SLICE. A young man at the store could not help either on an order. Horribly disappointed! He made me hold, then hung up after a 10 minute wait.
Won’t pick up after that. Hence the dissatisfaction. If you are going to use a delivery company, BACK IT UP!
Your name is on the BOX! I ordered a lg pie
Never saw a receipt from SLICE! Upon delivery, the receipt magically appeared!
If I had seen a small I would have rectified an error. Sandwich!!???Nowhere near what an Italian made Sandwich should be. To Prestos, have pride on what you make and deliver!
My 77 y/o mom makes better sandwich on Wonder Bread than that, and she’s not even Italian! Poor Poor quality and what makes it worse is that nobody has held accountability for the errors that could had been corrected. I don’t pride myself ever in posting POOR reviews! I lost almost $55 with tip for a small pie and an under par of a sandwich, but a real review like this, costs both parties more!!!
Penny Smart Dollar foolish!
Good luck! Hopefully next time both parties will take care of issues and customers paying with hard earned $$$ a bit more like Customers, and not just like it does NOT matter. Look for a Pizzeria that handles their own deliveries, and have a sense of pride in what comes out of the Kitchen!
Many to choose from in the area.
My mistake!!! I’ll make sure it does NOT HAPPEN AGAIN!
In the end, DO NOT USE SLICE!!!!
Prestos, look and see who handles you FOOD, Delivery, and Phone complaints !
… moreTerrible service!! Taylor and Lucy at SLICE. A young man at the store could not help either on an order. Horribly disappointed! He made me hold, then hung up after a 10 minute wait.
Won’t pick up after that. Hence the dissatisfaction. If you are going to use a delivery company, BACK IT UP!
Your name is on the BOX! I ordered a lg pie
Never saw a receipt from SLICE! Upon delivery, the receipt magically appeared!
If I had seen a small I would have rectified an error. Sandwich!!???Nowhere near what an Italian made Sandwich should be. To Prestos, have pride on what you make and deliver!
My 77 y/o mom makes better sandwich on Wonder Bread than that, and she’s not even Italian! Poor Poor quality and what makes it worse is that nobody has held accountability for the errors that could had been corrected. I don’t pride myself ever in posting POOR reviews! I lost almost $55 with tip for a small pie and an under par of a sandwich, but a real review like this, costs both parties more!!!
Penny Smart Dollar foolish!
Good luck! Hopefully next time both parties will take care of issues and customers paying with hard earned $$$ a bit more like Customers, and not just like it does NOT matter. Look for a Pizzeria that handles their own deliveries, and have a sense of pride in what comes out of the Kitchen!
Many to choose from in the area.
My mistake!!! I’ll make sure it does NOT HAPPEN AGAIN!
In the end, DO NOT USE SLICE!!!!
Prestos, look and see who handles you FOOD, Delivery, and Phone complaints !
Angela Connell
UPDATE: They gave me food poisoning.
My original review was written yesterday and today, it appears that it was contaminated. I now have severe food poisoning.
Previous post:
I come here all of the time. This time was awful. I ordered Garlic Knots and they were served to me ice cold by the girl with the thick black framed glasses and slicked back ponytail. Her name is KARINA. She had an attitude and IN FRONT OF CUSTOMERS took my garlic knots that I BIT INTO, put it in the garlic knot tray and threw it in the oven. The couple that came in were disgusted and made a point about it and I’m so embarrassed and shocked. When I went to pay, she threw my debit card at me too. I am literally confused as to why she was so discriminatory towards me.
Management, please look at the timestamp of 12/01/24 timestamp 4:00-16pm.
The only good thing was my slice but I was only allowed to buy 1 because they refused to make more to sell. Plus an Amazon worker came in looking to buy some plain slices and he was turned away. Poor guy.
… moreMy original review was written yesterday and today, it appears that it was contaminated. I now have severe food poisoning.
Previous post:
I come here all of the time. This time was awful. I ordered Garlic Knots and they were served to me ice cold by the girl with the thick black framed glasses and slicked back ponytail. Her name is KARINA. She had an attitude and IN FRONT OF CUSTOMERS took my garlic knots that I BIT INTO, put it in the garlic knot tray and threw it in the oven. The couple that came in were disgusted and made a point about it and I’m so embarrassed and shocked. When I went to pay, she threw my debit card at me too. I am literally confused as to why she was so discriminatory towards me.
Management, please look at the timestamp of 12/01/24 timestamp 4:00-16pm.
The only good thing was my slice but I was only allowed to buy 1 because they refused to make more to sell. Plus an Amazon worker came in looking to buy some plain slices and he was turned away. Poor guy.
Elle Emme
The perfect pizza every single time! I’ve been dying for a great chicken cutlet sandwich and have tried several other places but am always disappointed. Decided to give Presto’s a shot and OMG, it’s the perfect sandwich! Exactly what my taste buds were expecting, and then some. My daughter had the meatball sub, you can taste the freshness of the meatballs. Overall yummylicious food. Can’t wait to try more items off their menu.
… moreDamian Hernandez
Nice to see the cook and owner smoking right by the entrance of the pizzeria. NJ law is clear, 25 feet from the main door. I’m sure they don’t wash their hands either. I grew up eating at Presto’s back when the original owners managed the place. Then the son took over and it remained fairly similar because the mother would come and cook and oversee the business. Now, the current owner is hardly ever there. They serve you the pizza after grabbing coins and cash, against board of health policy. The quality of the food is poor, no parking available. No air conditioner during summer and in the winter you freeze. The place is just poor overall quality. Take the ride and go to Sal’s Pizza in Bergenline Ave. Better quality, service and parking available.
… moreMauro Briceno
I am so disappointed of this place; I ordered a Medium Margarita Pizza and added Mushrooms. The price, $28.50 for a Medium Pizza . They took over 1 hour to Deliver the pizza, I still tipped the driver and gave him a pen because he didn’t have a pen and my pizza arrived cold.
The flavor…. Well, I know Margarita pizza has basil but I don’t know what they put on this one, but that was not basil on my pizza (see pic). At the end I spent $34 dollars for a Medium Pizza and cold with something that’s not basil…. This is not an Italian pizza. I’m never ordering from this place again. (The owner is really nice though). The Dough was good, the cheese was ok, but honestly, save your money and time abs spend it elsewhere.
… moreThe flavor…. Well, I know Margarita pizza has basil but I don’t know what they put on this one, but that was not basil on my pizza (see pic). At the end I spent $34 dollars for a Medium Pizza and cold with something that’s not basil…. This is not an Italian pizza. I’m never ordering from this place again. (The owner is really nice though). The Dough was good, the cheese was ok, but honestly, save your money and time abs spend it elsewhere.
Jessica Zerener
Half plain
Half meatball onion
Burnt like cardboard disgusting.
Owner is attitude snotty and was intoxicated .. I asked nicely why their was a jump in prices. Now a jump not slight increase he said because he can never again
… moreHalf meatball onion
Burnt like cardboard disgusting.
Owner is attitude snotty and was intoxicated .. I asked nicely why their was a jump in prices. Now a jump not slight increase he said because he can never again
Aaron Harvey
One of the best Margherita pizzas iv ever had! Fantastic service over the phone and fast delivery. Absolutely recommend the pizza from here!
… moreBrian Perlis
Ordered a Sausage & Onion pizza pie with a Diet Coke. Got a regular Coke, the pie was cold and it was clear the sausage and onion were placed on the pie AFTER it was cooked. Crust was dried out and pizza lacked flavor. Very disappointing….
… more