Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
We are the ORIGINAL Anthony’s NY Pizza of Orlando, founded in 1987 (and the best in town)! When you are craving the best pizza in Casselberry, this is the place! We are YOUR local pizzeria of choice for Casselberry, Winter Park, and Maitland for over 37 years! We’re don’t just sell pizza, though – we also have mouth watering chicken wings, pasta, salad, and the best hot and cold subs to fill your gut (without emptying your wallet). Feeling like a chicken parm sub, anyone? Original Anthony’s NY Pizza in Casselberry is honored to be your local pizza favorite. We use only the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes, and we offer dine-in, takeout, and delivery options.
Informal pizzeria serving New York-style pies, plus a standard roster of subs, pasta & calzones.
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1455 FL-436 #105, Casselberry, FL 32707
Phone: (407) 657-5384
Website: http://originalanthonys.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Original Anthony’s NY Pizza – Casselberry
A combination of delicious food and heartfelt service that nurtures our community, makes Original Anthony’s New York Pizza in Casselberry, Florida a cherished …
Anthony’s Pizza-Pizza Place, Brick-Oven Pizza | Altamonte Springs …
At Anthony’s Pizza in Casselberry, Florida, we know how to make authentic New York Italian pizza. Because we use the best cheese and the freshest ingredients, …
OriginalAnthonys | Casselberry FL – Facebook
OriginalAnthonys, Casselberry. 58 likes. We are the ORIGINAL Anthony’s NY Pizza of Orlando, founded in 1987 (and the best in town)! When you are craving…
Reviews
Ale Colmenares
I ordered to take away this penne pasta with shrimp the truth the portion was for two people because of the amount of pasta but only brought the dish 6 shrimps and it was disappointing for me, and the pasta lacked flavor or salt, what I liked the most was the bread that came additional with this dish. It wasn’t bad but it wouldn’t be a dish I would order again.
… moreAshlyn Williams (Ash)
My friend and I pop in every 3-6 months and the place doesn’t feel like it disappoints. The portions are filling and the staff give good service. I wanna say that if you order anything on the menu (dinner menu) you have to be hungry.
On our recent visit we came in to try some sandwiches as we thought those would be light. Not sure why I did it, but I ordered the AlexSandwich the Great and my friend got an Italian Combo. Getting a side with a sandwich is extra but when you see it you know why. The sandwiches are served open face a look huge. The AlexSandwich the Great felt like it could be split among two people, add an order of some garlic knots and you would be happy. If anything that if a good sandwich to have before going out drinking as your stomach will be padded.
… moreOn our recent visit we came in to try some sandwiches as we thought those would be light. Not sure why I did it, but I ordered the AlexSandwich the Great and my friend got an Italian Combo. Getting a side with a sandwich is extra but when you see it you know why. The sandwiches are served open face a look huge. The AlexSandwich the Great felt like it could be split among two people, add an order of some garlic knots and you would be happy. If anything that if a good sandwich to have before going out drinking as your stomach will be padded.
Smiley
This place should’ve been named “Delicious Anthony’s”, seriously! The food is always amazing, I haven’t been here (in person anyways)since 2018 and the service is even more stellar than it was pre-Covid, my server Rachael was an absolute doll to have, my shy daughter even came out her shell around her. Great dine in experience and amazing food! Been high recommending since 2016!
… morePaul Hernandez
AMAZING. I’ve been to a lot of restaurants, I’ve searched for the best sauce in central Florida. When I tell you that this was the best Italian food I have ever eaten in my life, I promise you that is not an understatement. Even the house wine was amazing!
BEST SAUCE BEST PIZZA BEST SERVICE BEST ATMOSPHERE. That is not an exaggeration!
I want to thank Anthony’s for making one hell of a meal tonight & I also want to thank Sammi for the best service I have had in a long time.
Thank you!
… moreBEST SAUCE BEST PIZZA BEST SERVICE BEST ATMOSPHERE. That is not an exaggeration!
I want to thank Anthony’s for making one hell of a meal tonight & I also want to thank Sammi for the best service I have had in a long time.
Thank you!
Defying Entropy
First let me say that everyone that works there are incredible, friendly and a blast to know. I have been eating there for years and I have to give props and my compliments to the “Chef Mike”!! what an amazing baked ziti. You know when someone cares about their craft. Excellent Job Mike.
… moreMia Erickson Stevens
This is the absolutely BEST pizza in Orlando! They create this Margarita Pizza with additional toppings just for us! You should try it, I guarantee you’ll be hooked!
… moreWes Alcorn
Very disappointed for a $30 14” pizza. The cheese was so thick I couldn’t even pick up a slice without everything sliding off. The food was barely warm. Honestly I never thought I’d be angry while eating a pizza, but Anthony’s made that happen. They gave us blue cheese when the order was for Ranch as well. Do yourself a favor, if you want to spend a ridiculous amount of money on a pizza and actually enjoy it, go to Mellow Mushroom.
UPDATE: The owner wishes to trade blows rather than take it on the chin when his business clearly underperformed. You’re right sir, I spent $60 on an order so I could ruin it before enjoying. You’re correct, I didn’t reach out. Why would I? Your pizza is the worst I’ve ever had in my life. Pro tip: it’s not a good look to comment on reviews in the way you did. Not only does everyone know you’re food is bad, but now they know you handle criticism in an incredibly unprofessional manner. Improve your product, and if you choose not to, expect more reviews from other folks like me who were unfortunate enough to waste their hard earned money on the poor service you provided. To insinuate that I somehow chose to sabotage my meal, when there are countless other reviews and photos matching my experience is outright childish. Your professionalism is just as bad as your food.
… moreUPDATE: The owner wishes to trade blows rather than take it on the chin when his business clearly underperformed. You’re right sir, I spent $60 on an order so I could ruin it before enjoying. You’re correct, I didn’t reach out. Why would I? Your pizza is the worst I’ve ever had in my life. Pro tip: it’s not a good look to comment on reviews in the way you did. Not only does everyone know you’re food is bad, but now they know you handle criticism in an incredibly unprofessional manner. Improve your product, and if you choose not to, expect more reviews from other folks like me who were unfortunate enough to waste their hard earned money on the poor service you provided. To insinuate that I somehow chose to sabotage my meal, when there are countless other reviews and photos matching my experience is outright childish. Your professionalism is just as bad as your food.
Josh Curtiss
The staff and food here deserve 5 stars! Maria is a wonderful waitress! She made sure our order was correct and even gives some great recommendations. The owner Randall gave us a free dessert as this was our first time here. I’ve been to the other location in Casselberry, but I can easily say that this is the best location I’ve had! Pizza is fresh when brought out to your table… perfect temperature, great taste, full of flavor in every bite! Props to the chef for making a tasty and flavorful Alfredo sauce. It tastes as close to an authentic Italian Alfredo sauce. It’s perfect for dipping the pizza crust in. I would definitely be back!
… moreChris Sterba
Best pizza in FL. Perfect crust, perfect hold, and topping are fresh. No need to go to NY, just come here.
These people who say 1 star are just crazy. Just doing my part to report their reviews and report them as reviewers.
… moreThese people who say 1 star are just crazy. Just doing my part to report their reviews and report them as reviewers.
J D
I’ve been coming here for over 19 years, and it used to be the best New York–style pizza around. Unfortunately, it’s gone downhill.
Lunch specials are now priced like regular entrées, $60 for three people which is no longer affordable. The pizza by the slice was very floppy, overly greasy, and wet, with cheese sliding off. Couldn’t stand on its own like true NY-style pizza. The overall food quality isn’t what it used to be. The atmosphere felt dull, and service was minimal we had to get up to pay.
Sad to see how much this place has changed. I’ll be looking for better NY-style options elsewhere.
… moreLunch specials are now priced like regular entrées, $60 for three people which is no longer affordable. The pizza by the slice was very floppy, overly greasy, and wet, with cheese sliding off. Couldn’t stand on its own like true NY-style pizza. The overall food quality isn’t what it used to be. The atmosphere felt dull, and service was minimal we had to get up to pay.
Sad to see how much this place has changed. I’ll be looking for better NY-style options elsewhere.