Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Quaint, down-to-earth restaurant for multi-course Italian meals including pasta & seafood.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4286 Cass St, San Diego, CA 92109
Phone: (858) 272-7247
Website: http://oltremaresd.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Oltre Mare Italian Restaurant
I have found the best Italian restaurant in San Diego.” Collin B. Map. Information. Contact Us. Oltre Mare Italian Restaurant 4286 Cass Street San Diego, CA …
Oltre Mare (@oltremaresd) · San Diego, CA – Instagram
Wed-Sun 5pm-10pm. Great authentic Italian food ☕ · Our pasta is always fresh!!! Come see us and try it yourself! · New pieces available at my favorite …
Oltre Mare | San Diego CA – Facebook
Oltre Mare, San Diego. 652 likes · 1 talking about this · 1208 were here. Fine Italian food.
Reviews
Mykhailo Naumliuk
We recently dine here with my wife and got beef carpaccio, mushroom pasta and wild boar pasta. Everything was insanely delicious! Highly recommend to go try yourself. Just don’t forget to bring your own booze.
We’re looking forward to go there again and try mushroom risotto!
… moreWe’re looking forward to go there again and try mushroom risotto!
Jasmine T
The food is delicious but the service is very slow which is why I had to take off a couple of stars. I understand it’s a family run business but it often felt like we were forgotten about. It took a long time before even taking our order. We had to ask for wine glasses multiple times, and eventually were given plastic cups because they were supposedly out of wine glasses. Although BYOB is a plus. But as stated earlier, the food was very good. The pizza was fresh and hot. yhe mussels were good. The tiramisu was amazing. They just need to hire more staff because they are apparently busier than they can manage.
… moreBekah Staheli
Wonderful, friendly, and truly authentic Italian spot! We were visiting from out of town and were so warmly welcomed. The waitress/owner went out of her way to seat us without a reservation and was incredibly kind.
Delicious food, family-run feel, and multiple high chairs — one of the few places we would have felt comfortable bringing our twin toddlers. We wished we had found it sooner so we could go back again. Highly recommend!
… moreDelicious food, family-run feel, and multiple high chairs — one of the few places we would have felt comfortable bringing our twin toddlers. We wished we had found it sooner so we could go back again. Highly recommend!
Lindsay Masotta
As someone who grew up in an Italian family on the east coast – this is by far the best Italian food I have had in San Diego. We ordered three pastas and one pizza and every single thing was beyond good. The food is authentic and delicious. The owners are from Italy and are so sweet. I am so glad I finally found such a great Italian spot. I can’t wait to come back!
… moreJames Brannen
A qwant little place with authentic Italian cuisine, friendly staff, and great food. The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, a great place for an intimate dinner for two or a friendly gathering of friends and family.
Don’t forget to bring your favorite bottle of wine.
… moreDon’t forget to bring your favorite bottle of wine.
carol swihart
We love oltre mare! Whenever we visit San Diego, our son brings us to this wonderful
Restaurant. We love the new remodel: simple
And classy. The food is authentic Italian fare and every dish we’ve had has been memorable.The couple behind the restaurant are wonderful
People and make this place incredibile!!
… moreRestaurant. We love the new remodel: simple
And classy. The food is authentic Italian fare and every dish we’ve had has been memorable.The couple behind the restaurant are wonderful
People and make this place incredibile!!
Jeff P
Excellent dinner and service. Feels like a very warm vibe in there. BYOB. Focaccia was bomb. Burrata, mussels, pastas and pizza were excellent. My photo is missing half the pizza because it was so good it literally disappeared into my mouth. Tiramisu and Panna Cotta was delicious. This is a legit Italian restaurant with a mom and pop feel. 10/10 would return to eat there again. I wish I ordered more.
… moreFilippo Coco
GORGEOUS spaghetti alle vongole!
And the panna cotta so delicious.
The owners are fantastic.
A wonderful place I really suggest not to miss.
… moreAnd the panna cotta so delicious.
The owners are fantastic.
A wonderful place I really suggest not to miss.
Kash Alexander
Let me start with love by expressing my food was amazing. It was flavorful & delicious. In addition, it was extremely busy, which is typically an indication that people enjoy the food.
However, I feel compelled to leave a negative review, due to what I experienced while I was in the restaurant. It was distasteful, and quite honestly racist.
I walked in to pickup my online order. One lady, rushing back and forth between various tables and the kitchen, smiled to acknowledge me as she speed walked past, then on her return walk asked if I could wait. A callback to the love included at the start of my review, it was jam-packed + people in there were pretty boisterous… So of course I had no issue waiting. I smiled back, mouthed ‘okay’, and patiently waited because it was obvious she was dealing with a lot. At that time, I was the only person waiting to pickup/ be seated. By the time another lady walked out of the kitchen, maybe 4-5 minutes later, there was now one person behind me waiting to pickup her takeout order and 3 others groups/couples waiting for tables behind her. The lady came out of the kitchen walked right past me, greeted each of the patrons behind me asking if they were there to dine in or pickup before returning to me standing in front of everyone else. When she got to me she didn’t ask me anything, she just stared. we had an awkward silence of staring before I had to say I’m here to pick up MY order.
Understand this… I’m in town visiting from the east coast. I love Italian food. We google searched for the best Italian restaurants near our hotel And this restaurant popped up with great reviews. I have one sister-in-law that is Italian , two of my brother-in-laws are Italian. I include these personal details within my review only to emphasize how dumbfounded i was by the mistreatment I experienced by that lady. I was embarrassed. I advise anyone black or brown, take heed of my experience. I’d rather spend my money where I’m treated fairly.
… moreHowever, I feel compelled to leave a negative review, due to what I experienced while I was in the restaurant. It was distasteful, and quite honestly racist.
I walked in to pickup my online order. One lady, rushing back and forth between various tables and the kitchen, smiled to acknowledge me as she speed walked past, then on her return walk asked if I could wait. A callback to the love included at the start of my review, it was jam-packed + people in there were pretty boisterous… So of course I had no issue waiting. I smiled back, mouthed ‘okay’, and patiently waited because it was obvious she was dealing with a lot. At that time, I was the only person waiting to pickup/ be seated. By the time another lady walked out of the kitchen, maybe 4-5 minutes later, there was now one person behind me waiting to pickup her takeout order and 3 others groups/couples waiting for tables behind her. The lady came out of the kitchen walked right past me, greeted each of the patrons behind me asking if they were there to dine in or pickup before returning to me standing in front of everyone else. When she got to me she didn’t ask me anything, she just stared. we had an awkward silence of staring before I had to say I’m here to pick up MY order.
Understand this… I’m in town visiting from the east coast. I love Italian food. We google searched for the best Italian restaurants near our hotel And this restaurant popped up with great reviews. I have one sister-in-law that is Italian , two of my brother-in-laws are Italian. I include these personal details within my review only to emphasize how dumbfounded i was by the mistreatment I experienced by that lady. I was embarrassed. I advise anyone black or brown, take heed of my experience. I’d rather spend my money where I’m treated fairly.
Tom Donohoe
We had the absolute best time at Oltre Mare! Sara and the entire team were so accommodating and welcoming with our group of 25. The food was outstanding — everyone raved about the Wild Boar Pappardelle, and the pizzas, vongole, and desserts were all delicious. It was a fun, relaxed evening, and they were so helpful with our BYOB setup. Thank you, Sara, for taking such wonderful care of us and making the night so memorable!
… more