Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 691 Old Town Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Phone: (631) 473-3712
Website: https://www.oldtownpizzali.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Old Town Pizzeria | 691 Old Town Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY …
Treat your taste buds to a specialty pie from Old Town Pizzeria. Take the night off from cooking and enjoy the cheesy concoctions crafted at Old Town …
Old Town Pizzeria | Port Jefferson Station NY – Facebook
Stop in today and grab your favorite slice! 691 Old Town Road, Port Jefferson Station (631) 473-3712 #OldTownPizza #PortJeffStation #LongIslandPizza # …
Old Town Pizza – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Port Jefferson Station, NY! Old Town Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Reviews
avery
Every time I come here with my mom we want to buy literally everything, they have the best vodka and regular slices and it’s delicious every time, owner/workers are also so kind.
… moredalaa
I never write bad reviews but the treatment that I got as a loyal customer today was disheartening. First of all, I ordered buffalo wings 2 hours before it came, and when they came they demanded a tip after being late, and for giving me wrong order which they gave me bbq wings which I’m allergic to that. Anyways they kept going back and forth with me over the tip but their service wasn’t even worth it or worth a dollar. They lost me as a customer forever. Will not ever come here ever again!
… moreJac Wright
Wow. Just wow. If you’re ever craving a slice of pizza that tastes like regret and broken promises, this is the place to go.
They proudly advertise “Hot and Fresh!” which must be their idea of a punchline, because what I got was a lukewarm, rubbery triangle of sadness. The crust of my chicken parmesan was chewy like a gym mat, the cheese had all the flavor of wet cardboard, and the sauce? Oh wait…was there sauce? Could’ve fooled me.
Honestly, if you’ve ever wondered what it feels like to bite into a pizza that’s been sitting on a windowsill during a mild thunderstorm, this masterpiece is your answer. Tasteless, stale, and served with a side of disappointment.
Five stars… if the goal was to make me never eat pizza again.
… moreThey proudly advertise “Hot and Fresh!” which must be their idea of a punchline, because what I got was a lukewarm, rubbery triangle of sadness. The crust of my chicken parmesan was chewy like a gym mat, the cheese had all the flavor of wet cardboard, and the sauce? Oh wait…was there sauce? Could’ve fooled me.
Honestly, if you’ve ever wondered what it feels like to bite into a pizza that’s been sitting on a windowsill during a mild thunderstorm, this masterpiece is your answer. Tasteless, stale, and served with a side of disappointment.
Five stars… if the goal was to make me never eat pizza again.
Marissa Fromwiller
I ordered a Caesar salad wrap and got this pathetic lettuce wrap for $15. I asked for extra dressing. There was not a spec of dressing on it, no cheese and no croutons. And last time I checked a Caesar salad comes with croutons. This place use to be one of the best in town. Ever since management changed the quality went down tremendously while the prices went up. Also my chips tasted like fish which I hate seafood so I noticed right away.
… moreJoseph Fontana
I have found steel wool in my food on more than one occasion… Ownership is indifferent to it, which should tell you everything you need to know. It’s truly a shame because the food is delicious when you’re not in danger of choking.
… moreDaniel del Valle
I’ve never had a problem here. But the pizza I got last night was horrible. If it’s going to taste like this here on out I’m going to have to find a new go to pizzeria
… moreVal
Good but it seems like they would rather die than make the slice you want unless you order it online if they don’t have it the worker isn’t doing anything.
… moreCongo Bongos
Its good food if you go there but forget about ordering from here. Every time they mess it up. last time they forgot a salad and didnt put mozzarella on the mozzarella garlic bread. This time they gave us a disgusting pizza with oil all over the bottom of the box and under the pizza making the entire thing a soggy mess. The garlic knots we ordered because we didnt trust them to put mozzarella on the bread this time was cold… not room temp… COLD!!
… moreAry
Ordered an eggplant parm hero, it’s tasted really burnt but didn’t look burn so maybe old oil? Either way waste of money, which was unfortunate
… moreJosue Z Martines
A year ago they banned me from coming back… just for trying to buy pizza for a homeless man. He threatened to call police on me. There are 1000 better ways in which he could’ve handled the situation.
… more