Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–8 PM |
| Saturday | 4–8 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 19152 Co Rd 46, New Paris, IN 46553
Phone: (574) 831-4160
Website: http://oldtimepizza.wixsite.com/old-time-pizza
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Restaurant | Old Time Pizza | New Paris – Wix.com
Old Time Pizza is a hometown restaurant serving pizza, broasted chicken & pork shops, sandwiches, salads & much more! Worth the drive.
Old Time Pizza – Facebook
Old Time Pizza. 1382 likes · 6 talking about this · 43 were here. Hometown business serving delicious pizza, broasted chicken, broasted pork chops, and…
Menu | Old Time Pizza – Wix.com
Old Time Pizza, a hometown restaurant in New Paris, Indiana serving big pizza, delicious broasted chicken, broasted pork chops, mojos, sandwiches, …
Reviews
Lindsay Johnson
They have amazing gluten free pizza crust! I have had ham and pineapple and sausage pizza! They both were so good!!!
… moreSheri Douglas
We try different pizzas to find the best in the area. I like meat lovers and it was good. Will go again.
… moreAna Marin
My son got a pizza and it looked so unappealing… I got the loaded nachos and it just looked like dog food on top of nachos with a drizzle of cheese and the nachos tasted like they were stale .. I never thought I would say this but gas station food is way better then this place
… moreRandall Perry
Nice small town restaurant with a good variety of food options.
They are generous with their mozzarella on pizzas, the breaded portobello mushrooms are great!
… moreThey are generous with their mozzarella on pizzas, the breaded portobello mushrooms are great!
Joe Miller
Average. I ordered the Super sandwich, which was like a pizza sandwich. Not impressed. They had absolutely nothing on the walls and for a town known for a Speedway, that was disappointing. Not recommended
… moreDonna Clifton
I will start off by saying the staff were friendly and the restaurant was clean. My husband and I ordered a salad and a pizza. The salad was good and fresh. The pizza on the other hand was terrible. It lacked flavor, sauce, and the crust was card stock thin and burned. It was the worse pizza we have ever eaten.
I returned to this restaurant and tried the chicken…it was excellent! I will add some star to my initial review. Get the chicken, not pizza.
… moreI returned to this restaurant and tried the chicken…it was excellent! I will add some star to my initial review. Get the chicken, not pizza.
Adam Storer
Pleasantly surprised by this pizza. Not what I recall from years ago, but a good improvement. I really like the meat pizza and my kids loved the cheese.
… moreMegan Stanger
We stopped in here on a Sunday evening with a group. We had my some birthday here and instead of carrying in food we brought the boys out. Old time pizza was very accommodating and helpful. Food came out really fast. Location is nice and clean.
… moreMatthew Wagner
Pizza is still decent, but the wait times are outrageous. We waited over an hour for our pizza. A gentleman came in with his parrot and ate in the restaurant and the owner never even batted an eye. I don’t want to be eating next to someone with a bird on their shoulder. That screams unsanitary.
It’s not like it used to be when Stumpy owned it. Slower service, smaller pizza, and lower standards. We won’t be going back.
… moreIt’s not like it used to be when Stumpy owned it. Slower service, smaller pizza, and lower standards. We won’t be going back.
Becky Moser
Excellent experience for where to dine in, or take out ! Pizza is very good & large you don’t need to a add more cheese ! Broasted fried chicken & or Pork Chops ! Every meal is $20.00 or less, dine in or carry out, you’ll be impressed !!!
… more