Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1198 E Summit St, Crown Point, IN 46307
Phone: (219) 662-9999
Website: https://theoldmillpizza.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
The Original Old Mill Pizza
Take-out and delivery orders may be placed by phone (219) 662-9999 or the “order now” link above. Take-out orders are picked up through the entrance pictured …
The Original Old Mill Pizza Crown Point | Toast
The Original Old Mill Pizza Crown Point · X-Large 16″ Pizza. $24.00 · 6 Pieces Wings. Extra-large wings fried to perfection and spun in your choice of sauce.
Menu | Old Mill Pizzeria
View Old Mill Pizzeria menu specializing in pizza, pasta, lasagna, seafood, steak sandwiches, wraps, and milkshakes.
Reviews
Alex Bokodi
Just wow. Terrible. Pickles burnt to a crisp and over salted, pizza crust has zero flavor, globs of plain cheese, sauce had nothing but acidic tomato taste.
… moreG An
This pizza was good. A little light. I asked for extra sauce, which I regret. Tasted good, but I think the crust would have been better with regular sauce. I’ll eat this again.
… moreJennifer J
Ordered take out tonight. Chicken was black it was so burnt. Burger could have been used as a car tire. Pizza crust was black and crumbled it was so burnt. Whoever cooked our food 10000% knew it was inedible trash, yet packed it up anyway. Hope you have the day you deserve!
… moreBeast Dog
June 4th 2024. Specifically asked for heavy sauce on my pizza as I do whenever/wherever I order. Heard that they were back in business and decided to give them a try. I’d love to give them a good review but just can’t. This is the closest thing to eating flavored cardboard. Let’s see if the business end is better. I’d like see if Old Mill management makes it right. Very very disappointed because I’m due for a colonoscopy Thursday and will not be able to eat Wednesday. Thought I’d go out with a bang and get a good pizza.
… moreShantel LeMonier
Old Mill CP was not good. Terrible crust & sauce. Tasted like canned tomato paste and not an actual sauce. Zero flavor to the pepperoni, all I could taste was the tomato paste. A super greasy mess too. Had to blot the top with multiple paper towels and cut it with my own pizza cutter because it was a giant blob. Big thumbs down!
… moreChris
I don’t know what some of these people are expecting, but this was great pizza. I remember going to Old Mill when I was a kid in Merrillville and if my memory serves me right, the pizza is very similar. The pizza was hot, fresh , fast, and piles of cheese, the sauce and sausage had good taste. Highly recommended. And for the record, the Langels at the Crown Point location sucked. The only one that is good is in Highland.
… morerick craig
this is not like the original old mill. ordered a small sausage pizza
i was not done all the way the crust was half the cheese was half melted and did not taste like the original. the next time i’m going to beggars pizza.
… morei was not done all the way the crust was half the cheese was half melted and did not taste like the original. the next time i’m going to beggars pizza.
David Davis
$1.00 convince fee for restaurant operations??? Was about to order a pizza and just couldn’t figure out why my math didn’t match the total. Then I looked closely and seen that. This was a online order by the way so I dont know about phone orders. Anyway even though its just a dollar. I did not order it and will not order from them till that is removed. I would rather give a homeless person the dollar then give a restaurant more for overcharged items already. Just my opinion.
… moreAlex
Pizza makes me wanna puke, I’d rather eat straw. I have atmosphere at 5 because it’s carry out only.
… moreSteve Solomon
The original Old Mill pizza restaurant was torn down years ago. Buddy and Pals bar took over saying that they kept the original recipe. It’s not even close! the sauce and sausage is bland, and the crust is mediocre! Never will I order from them again!
… more