Social Profile: 
![]()
… View more
Inviting Ice Cream shop offering homemade ice cream and ice cream treats such as shakes and sundaes. Also offers cookies, pies, coffee, soft drinks, juice drinks and more. We incorporate flavors from all over the Old Mill Square for a full Old Mill experience! We have outdoor seating available.
Ice cream parlor with a mix of classic & signature flavors, plus cookies & to-go sandwiches.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 171 Old Mill Ave #3515, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863
Phone: (865) 453-4301
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Old Mill Creamery in Pigeon Forge Tennessee
Stop in and grab ice cream for the whole family to enjoy back at home, the cabin or campground! Call The Old Mill Creamery at 865-453-4301 to place your order.
The Old Mill
The Old Mill in Pigeon Forge TN is an authentic destination to eat, shop, sip and savor the real food, crafts, and other Smoky Mountain traditions.
Old Mill Creamery – Pigeon Forge, TN
Our cool updated ice cream parlor in Pigeon Forge, TN still churns traditional flavors to scoop into sugar cones or dishes, or turn into sundaes and shakes.
Reviews
Karen Brennfleck
My husband and I went here and got pumpkin cheesecake, coconut, and banana pudding flavors of ice cream and they were all delicious! We did a sample of the oatmeal cream pie, but just didn’t think it had much flavor. I would recommend tasting some samples before ordering to see which you like/don’t.
… moreB G
This is an adorable ice cream shop. We came mid afternoon on a weekday and it was not busy at all. The employees were all very nice! And the ice cream was delicious! I highly recommend the cookie dough and blackberry pie, yumm! They also have a little coffee/tea menu. Plenty of seating outside, very nice atmosphere.
… moreBrandi P
I got the waffle bowl which comes with two generous scoops of ice cream. I loved the brown butter black walnut and the espresso with the chocolate chips was really good. I also got an extra scoop of banana pudding for an extra dollar. I liked it. The quality of their ice cream gets a 5 star in my opinion. The selection is good and I’d come back for the brown butter black walnut for sure but I give their selection a 4 star because they don’t have any sorbets and they didn’t have any sherbets, even though they usually have orange sherbet I guess.
They have a really nice patio to eat on with lots of tables. However if it’s raining (like it was when we went) there is not indoor seating and there are only 3 benches that are under the awnings.
We would definitely go back
… moreThey have a really nice patio to eat on with lots of tables. However if it’s raining (like it was when we went) there is not indoor seating and there are only 3 benches that are under the awnings.
We would definitely go back
Arlene Murphy
This place is outstanding! Great for a quick dessert or snack if visitng the Old Mill shoppes. You can sample the ice creams before purchasing. Has made from scratch goodness.
Ordered the kid’s cup since I was so full from lunch. Had bear paw ice cream which was made with chocolate and caramel mixed together. A perfect combination! You can get sundaes here as well. Check the menu board for their current offerings. Definitely a great way to cool off on a hot day!
… moreOrdered the kid’s cup since I was so full from lunch. Had bear paw ice cream which was made with chocolate and caramel mixed together. A perfect combination! You can get sundaes here as well. Check the menu board for their current offerings. Definitely a great way to cool off on a hot day!
Louis and Elaine
The Old Mill Creamery is a well stocked ice cream shop with a super friendly staff. The stock a large variety of ice cream flavors as well as muffins and other delicious treats. There is also a very nice outdoor seating area with tables and chairs for the use of their customers.
… moreDalibor Labudovic
Ice cream was delicious. Great price and service was great.
… moreSteven Brothers
Seriously some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had. I want expecting it to be this great.
… moreNoneya Noneya
5 of us went in and had (5) different flavors. We were here several years ago and loved the oatmeal cream pie ice cream. This time it was a HUGE disappointment. All the Icecream had an artificial taste and a chemical taste. However, the old mill area is definitely a cute area and worth a visit. Not so much for the icecream shop.
… moreMatt
The ice cream is great!
I got the Oatmill Cream Pie ice cream and it was really good!
There is plenty of seating outside for your family to sit down and have a good time.
⚠️ One warning: When we went, there was only one chocolate ice cream flavor, so chocolate lovers beware.
… moreI got the Oatmill Cream Pie ice cream and it was really good!
There is plenty of seating outside for your family to sit down and have a good time.
⚠️ One warning: When we went, there was only one chocolate ice cream flavor, so chocolate lovers beware.
Armindo K
Pretzel was very hard , customer service wasn’t very friendly, the ice cream I ordered was missing the filling just an empty cone but the other one was full …. Just looking for consistency.
… more