Airy eatery is a family-friendly destination for seafood, with a sushi bar & frequent live music.
M
Old Florida Fish House truly delivers the full experience with a beautiful setting, great service, and freshly prepared, delicious food. What more could you ask for?
I visited during the off-season (and record cold temperatures!), and the cozy atmosphere was especially appreciated. The menu features classic Florida seafood with something for everyone, and it’s easy to see why this spot is very popular during high season.
The fish tacos were outstanding, and the staff was incredibly personable and welcoming. A wonderful dining experience all around. Highly recommended! I look forward to returning soon!
… moreDuplantis • Coastal Curator
A buddy and I stopped in for lunch. We decided to sit at the bar so we would be able to watch football. We ordered the gumbo, lobster wontons as well as the tuna dip. The gumbo was so good I forgot to take a picture of it. All were excellent. So good I forgot to take a picture to show here. we got prompt service from the bartender(Zac) who surprised us with this knowledge of the food as sushi menu. Was an excellent experience and can’t wait to go back!
… moreF J
We had a wonderful family lunch while we waited to check into our next home. Thank you Sky for the fabulous service and welcoming hospitality! The food was delicious and our 3 boys really enjoyed fishing from the doc while we enjoyed the patio too. We hope to be back soon!
… moreTyler Richardson
First time visit. Parking is complimentary valet, they pack the cars in! I asked to park my car myself and they happily allowed that for us.
Our server Amanda, was amazing. She knew the menu very well and hitting the highlights and explained our the 3 kitchens work separately and the food comes out as its made. We loved this. Our first two dishes came out within 3 minutes of ordering.
We ordered the A5 Wagyu. It was such a great experience and definitely a treat.
Sushi (for stateside) as well as the braised beef were some of best we’ve had.
We will certainly be back to enjoy more food from Old Florida Fish House!
… moreAshwin Moses
So first and foremost, do not be deceived by portion sizes here. I started digging in before I got a picture it looked so good. I got the grouper and my wife got the jerk mahi and let me tell you, it will fill you up and leave you feeling satisfied without feeling stuffed. Every ingredient is made from scratch and you can tell. Our server Jacob Socolow was hands down one of the best servers I’ve ever come across. Very knowledgeable and fun to be around, humble, and made our experience incredible. They have fireplaces around to keep you warm outside with string lights to really set the vibe. Go inside for live music and a more lively experience or sit outside for a more chill vibe this place was top tier. Is it pricey? A little bit but it was so worth it. Oh and did I mention the Key Lime Pie? Best I’ve ever had.
… moreCorner Deals
The atmosphere here is amazing and we had very high expectations upon arrival. We had reservations and arrived a little early. We went to the bar for cocktails while we wait. It took about 30 minutes to receive 2 martinis as they only have a few bartenders for a very large area (they are making drinks for the entire place). Our server Renee was very attentive and timely. The food was just ok. The best part of the meal was the Lobster Wontons. They have a large sushi menu but the quality is 4/10. I only give 4 stars for service due to bar service. The Key lime pie was good.
… moreRosemary Williams
Oh my goodness, the food was absolutely delicious! I had the House Grouper and devoured every bite. And I’m so glad I treated myself to dessert because, if Heaven can be tasted, it is their deep dish key lime pie. The staff was particularly attentive to our large party, and we felt well cared for. The whole setting is rich with charm and warmth. I would recommend anyone visiting the area to make this a mandatory stop.
… moreRon Blevins
The red snapper was perfect and Mardi Gras pasta was so delicious and to top it off for dessert was Keylime pie the best!! My only complaint is it was a little over priced for what you got, if they would add a small salad and dinner rolls to the entrées then the price would be fine. Atmosphere and the outdoor dining was great and dog friendly for us it was a big plus.
… moreYana Powers
Great atmosphere, you’re in a little cute bubble when you get there with all the lights, plants, fire pits and live music. The service was great, everyone was very nice and quick to help with any of our needs and the food came very quickly. And of course the sushi was delicious especially the sashimi. We will definitely be back.
… moreShell Peterson
Food was incredible. Best meal I’ve had in months. Fish was super fresh. I had the fish bites and grouper sandwich. Lemondrop and key lime pie. Their cocktails are wonderful. The deserts are out of this world. Homemade whipped cream and perfect graham cracker crust. We sat by the water and watched the fish jump the whole time. Absolutely beautiful view!! We heard about this place and this will now be one of our top picks for this area.
… more