Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Pizza, Meatball Bar with pool table, dart boards and bowling! Enjoy a dog friendly huge covered patio with a fire pit, corn hole, giant Jenga, and Connect four! Free s’mores for all! Winner of the Midwestern Pizza competition in 2024. Come, check us out!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3490 Old Troy Pike, Riverside, OH 45404
Phone: (937) 233-3490
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Old Dayton Pizza at Riverside Hideaway – Facebook
Old Dayton Pizza at Riverside Hideaway, Riverside. 3793 likes · 13 talking about this · 1596 were here. Fun bar/pizza joint with a pool table, 2 dart…
Old Dayton Pizza at Riverside Hideaway reopens for good
Old Dayton Pizza reopened as a bar on March 10 with plans to do “pop-up” events where they would serve pizza and meatballs. This would ensure …
Old Dayton Pizza at Riverside Hideaway | Toast
All are made hot and with our fresh Roman style dough; wrapped, baked and topped with butter and Parmigianino Cheese. Served with your choice of Kettle …
Reviews
Jaime Burke
We visited for the first time yesterday, after seeing the Air Force Museum.
Our server was very friendly and welcoming.
We ordered a variety and shared between three of us because everything sounded good.
Our Caesar salad was brought out first, and it was fantastic. One of the best I’ve had. Loved their homemade dressing, and it had the perfect amount of cheese and croutons. Just thought it was funny that the small salad was served in a large bowl because they were “out of small bowls.” As in no one to wash small bowls or literally out of small bowls? lol
Then we proceeded to wait nearly an hour for our pizzas and subs. There was no explanation for it, and they weren’t visibly busy at all. Other than a few people at the bar, we were the only table there. No one appeared to be picking up carry out orders or anything, so I don’t know what was going on, but it was a bit ridiculous. I honestly don’t mind waiting for food if I’m prepared to wait and I know why I’m waiting, but nearly an hour without any explanation or warning was too much.
Anyway! The pepperoni pizza was delicious. The sauce was very flavorful and fresh tasting, really unique, setting it apart from the ordinary pizza. The crust was rustic with a great texture and chew, perfect amount of cheese, and crisp pepperoni. The Ranch pizza was good, the actual ranch dressing was delicious, but it was lacking something, we all thought. Not bad but just seemed to need something else.
The subs, which were more like calzones, were very messy and hard to eat. All of the ingredients separately were good, but all together, in the way they were prepared just didn’t work for us. I don’t like big hunks of ham in my “sub” or even my calzones. It’s just texturally strange. The sauces served on the side were delicious, but mayo on the side for dipping was weird. We ordered it, thinking it would be on the sub. Again, very messy and actually, impossible to dip without falling apart. For the price of each “sub”, they just didn’t wow us or justify the price. You’d think the server would explain ahead of time that their subs aren’t traditional subs so we’d know what to expect. I believe there was something mentioned on the menu, but still, not at all what we expected.
So, overall, the pizzas and salad were great. Excellent quality. Our server was very nice. But, the extremely long wait and the unusual subs were disappointing. If I’m ever in the area again, which I’m sure I will be, I might order a pizza to go, but avoid dining in!
… moreOur server was very friendly and welcoming.
We ordered a variety and shared between three of us because everything sounded good.
Our Caesar salad was brought out first, and it was fantastic. One of the best I’ve had. Loved their homemade dressing, and it had the perfect amount of cheese and croutons. Just thought it was funny that the small salad was served in a large bowl because they were “out of small bowls.” As in no one to wash small bowls or literally out of small bowls? lol
Then we proceeded to wait nearly an hour for our pizzas and subs. There was no explanation for it, and they weren’t visibly busy at all. Other than a few people at the bar, we were the only table there. No one appeared to be picking up carry out orders or anything, so I don’t know what was going on, but it was a bit ridiculous. I honestly don’t mind waiting for food if I’m prepared to wait and I know why I’m waiting, but nearly an hour without any explanation or warning was too much.
Anyway! The pepperoni pizza was delicious. The sauce was very flavorful and fresh tasting, really unique, setting it apart from the ordinary pizza. The crust was rustic with a great texture and chew, perfect amount of cheese, and crisp pepperoni. The Ranch pizza was good, the actual ranch dressing was delicious, but it was lacking something, we all thought. Not bad but just seemed to need something else.
The subs, which were more like calzones, were very messy and hard to eat. All of the ingredients separately were good, but all together, in the way they were prepared just didn’t work for us. I don’t like big hunks of ham in my “sub” or even my calzones. It’s just texturally strange. The sauces served on the side were delicious, but mayo on the side for dipping was weird. We ordered it, thinking it would be on the sub. Again, very messy and actually, impossible to dip without falling apart. For the price of each “sub”, they just didn’t wow us or justify the price. You’d think the server would explain ahead of time that their subs aren’t traditional subs so we’d know what to expect. I believe there was something mentioned on the menu, but still, not at all what we expected.
So, overall, the pizzas and salad were great. Excellent quality. Our server was very nice. But, the extremely long wait and the unusual subs were disappointing. If I’m ever in the area again, which I’m sure I will be, I might order a pizza to go, but avoid dining in!
Theresa Dlugopolsky
Honestly best pizza I’ve had in town I think. Absolutely delicious, friendly staff, and great service.
… moreElisabeth
They’re back, baby—and my taste buds are throwing a party! This cozy little spot has reopened, and the food is still absolutely chef’s kiss. The owners are total sweethearts, the kind of people you want to succeed just because they care so dang much about their craft (and the neighborhood).
I got a pizza whose name I can’t remember because my brain short-circuited from happiness after the first bite. Those tiny pepperonis? Crispy little flavor bombs, oven-kissed like they were blessed by a pizza fairy. Not burnt. Not bland. Just perfect. (Hog Roast Pizza )
So do your taste buds and your community a favor—grab a pie, pull up a chair, or carry it out like a pizza hero. Support this awesome small biz and get fed like royalty.
… moreI got a pizza whose name I can’t remember because my brain short-circuited from happiness after the first bite. Those tiny pepperonis? Crispy little flavor bombs, oven-kissed like they were blessed by a pizza fairy. Not burnt. Not bland. Just perfect. (Hog Roast Pizza )
So do your taste buds and your community a favor—grab a pie, pull up a chair, or carry it out like a pizza hero. Support this awesome small biz and get fed like royalty.
Ken Elrich
After seeing the recent posts about Old Dayton Pizza at Riverside Hideaway, we made our first visit this evening. We ordered garlic bread with added cheese and marinara sauce, Momma Sherri’s meatballs, Farmers Garden Pizza, Mediterrean Pizza and a Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza. The food and service was on point! My wife claimed that this was the best pizza she’s ever had. Our server Beth, was very attentive and made sure we were hydrated and happy. The owner, Steve stopped by to check on us and gave us the history of this establishment. If you haven’t been here, it’s definitely a scrumptious place to be.
… moreEric
In town for Business found this family owned and run spot I stopped in to order dinner to go. I was talking with a gentleman who said I couldn’t go wrong with any choice. He was right I ordered the round up pizza. I also heard about the owners mom’s recipe for meatballs. I ordered a meatball sandwich with chips for work tomorrow. The food is prepared Roman style the ride to my hotel was a challenge! the aroma in my car was amazing. It didn’t take me long to try the Pizza it was delicious. I have no doubt my lunch tomorrow will be as delicious thank you Beth for your excellent service tonight. If you’re in the area near Old Dayton Pizza at Riverside Hideaway it’s a stop you won’t regret!
… moreTodd Brumbaunt
Update***** went back and everything came out super fast. Italian sub is one of the best things I’ve ever eaten and the salad is incredible. Can’t wait to come back. Changed to 5 stars.
Review is more like a 3.5 but the time waited was a bit extreme. Came on a Thursday barely anyone there. Drinks are great and cheap. Bartenders give great reccomendations and they were super friendly and helpful. The food that came out on time was awesome. Salads fresh and came out first. Otherwise, all of the food came out about 25 minutes after ordering besides one pizza which came out 35 minutes LATER at exactly 1 hour after ordered. Nothing was mentioned and nothing was comped etc. (my opinion is that the pizza should’ve been taken off or we should’ve just rejected it) however I am excited to go back but in the future, but I would speak up if a food item took an hour. Everything is fresh and delicious though. I think if they were busier, the issue that made it take so long wouldn’t have been there. Bathrooms were okay… not the cleanest but it’s an old building. Food wise the pepperonis, the crust, and the sandwiches (crust is Roman style) were phenomenal. Better than most places around for sure.
… moreReview is more like a 3.5 but the time waited was a bit extreme. Came on a Thursday barely anyone there. Drinks are great and cheap. Bartenders give great reccomendations and they were super friendly and helpful. The food that came out on time was awesome. Salads fresh and came out first. Otherwise, all of the food came out about 25 minutes after ordering besides one pizza which came out 35 minutes LATER at exactly 1 hour after ordered. Nothing was mentioned and nothing was comped etc. (my opinion is that the pizza should’ve been taken off or we should’ve just rejected it) however I am excited to go back but in the future, but I would speak up if a food item took an hour. Everything is fresh and delicious though. I think if they were busier, the issue that made it take so long wouldn’t have been there. Bathrooms were okay… not the cleanest but it’s an old building. Food wise the pepperonis, the crust, and the sandwiches (crust is Roman style) were phenomenal. Better than most places around for sure.
Angela Montgomery
We absolutely loved the food and service here. The homemade meatballs are delicious and the pizzas were cooked to perfection. The dough is homemade as are the sauces both were great! We will be bringing friends back with us. The drinks we ordered were really good and the patio and fire pit area are really cool. Please don’t pass the place without eating. The prices are great for wonderful food.
… moreB SNOW
Our server Collette was awesome! All of the pizzas we tried were baked to perfection. Meatballs were very good, but the portion size wasn’t enough to share.
… moreJami Harris
Such a great overall experience! Steph was our server and she was very attentive and fun. We would recommend all the food we got but especially the Caesar salad! It was the best Caesar dressing we’d ever had. The homemade meatballs were great, we loved the Italian sub and all the pizzas we got were perfect. We aren’t in the Dayton area often but we will definitely visit the next time we are back!
… morebwalusis
Tried the pizza and garlic bread for carry out. This place is aptly named. It’s got a great old school vibe. Looks like a good spot to watch a game, have a cold one, and visit with friends. The pizza was excellent. Great crust, flavorful sauce, tasty cup and char pepperoni. They are small Pies. I give the garlic bread a 7/10 but not bad. The ladies behind the bar are friendly.
… more