Eugene Kosoy
Perfect Greenport gem — a former bait shop turned locals-run oyster and wine bar run by a local family that keeps things simple and spot-on. The oysters are clean, and briny; the wine list is small but smart; and the vibe is pure North Fork: unpretentious, welcoming, and absolutely what you want after a walk by the water. A quick, delicious stop that feels authentically local without trying too hard.
… moreHouston Terrazas
Best oysters in Greenport! Avoid the “little” spots in Greenport and come to the Old Bait Shop!
… moreIrina Gofman
Great place! Family business, rooted in the community. Come for oysters, clams,
delicious oyster Rockefeller and local wine, but don’t forget to look at the walls for old family pictures!
… more