Jeremy Tish
Last night 12/26/25 bought a large pizza it was burnt. Definitely the worst I have ever had from there. Usually not burnt as much. Definitely disappointed. All it tastes like is burnt.
… moreNancy Pierce
Cool, funky pizza joint with excellent pizza and great staff! Nice selection of brews, bottled and on tap. They have shows out back, recently featuring Dog Bite Harris and the Pine Box Boys!! The acoustics are really good. It gets breezy in the evening, so bring a jacket.
… moreCynthia Heath
Pizza was outstanding! Had the FLP and the Heart and Hands. It was fresh, hot, full of flavor. The crust was thin and chewy.
The owner and wait staff were very friendly and kind.
The atmosphere had a 70’s vibe to me. An air hockey table sat off to one side. It was really noisy when I phoned in around noon indicating business was good. I arrived around two o’clock and it was quiet with an occasional customer coming and going. I will definitely return to this pizza shop next time I really have a hankering for a slice . Two 18” pizzas for two people means lots of leftovers! $47 well spent.
… morealex burks
Got pizza for me and some family last night, it was delicious. Staff was super helpful and kind over the phone, and in person. The pizza crust is sooo good. Probably in my top five favorite places.
… moreErin Stangel
This pizza is the best! I love the homey atmosphere, they have always had the best customer service and my kid is obsessed with their giant cookies. I highly recommend!
… moreKaliko Maciel
Passing through town, this spot called to us. Upon arrival, we were warmly welcomed by the owner, Karen. We ordered the combo, and it hit all the marks; perfectly crispy crust, depth of flavors in the sauce, perfect cheese pull, and fresh toppings paired with a nice craft beer. 10 out of 10. Bonus, nice conversation with Karen. Give it a try, you will be happy you did.
… moreIan
James is the best bartender EVER. This guy is the man. Let me tell you I might be coming back every week just to talk to this guy. Not to mention the food is great. Best pizza in town.
… moreMatthew Sartori
Who knew that we’d find some of the best pizza we’ve had in Oregon in the small town of Willamina? We’ve been looking for some top tier quality pizza for almost a year now, and Odd Fellows is the first place that checks all of our boxes.
The atmosphere is pretty chill and family friendly, and the service is busy but attentive, just as you’d expect in a small restaurant that stays busy.
We have tried a few pies, but recommend the meat lovers, which boasts a great blend of flavors. The sausage is yummy, and all the flavors blend well. Leftovers reheat well in a toaster oven, but it’s peak if you can eat it right there.
The only downside is how long it can take to get your food – grab a beer and expect to wait a bit, maybe half an hour. It’s worth it, though… We are glad to have this gem of a pizza joint close to our new home!
… moreVictoria Sesney
The food was a little underwhelming with a huge bowl of salad and only a few cold tiny pieces of deli chicken for my Ceasar salad. They made up for it with excellent service, great atmosphere and the event that they put on was absolutely wonderful!
… moreAlex Jamerson
Outstanding pizza. The staff are great. Get the taco pants pizza, you won’t regret it.
… more