Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 21609 Village Lakes Shopping Center Dr, Land O’ Lakes, FL 34639
Phone: (813) 501-8009
Website: https://nytimessquarepizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
N.Y. Times Square Pizzeria – Serving Tampa Bay since 2002
226 E. Bearss Ave. Tampa, FL. Land O Lakes. 21609 Village Lakes Shopping Center Land O Lakes, FL …
NY Times Square Pizza – Land O’ Lakes, FL – 21609 Village Lakes …
Get 5% off your pizza delivery order – View the menu, hours, address, and photos for NY Times Square Pizza in Land O’ Lakes, FL. Order online for delivery …
Order NY Times Square Pizza – Land O Lakes Delivery – Uber Eats
Use your Uber account to order delivery from NY Times Square Pizza in Land O Lakes. Browse the menu, view popular items, and track your order.
Last Updates
Reviews
Jason Ballard
YUM
Pizza tasted great! Salad was very good. Garlic knots were great.
2 18-inch pizzas, salad and garlic knots. Our family loved it and had plenty of leftovers.
They do not have fountain machine for drinks but they do have plenty of bottled drinks. That was the only thing I’d like…. since I enjoy iced-t.
Service was really good. Super polite manager / owner. The location itself only has about 9 tables but it’s enough. 5 of us sat at 1 table. Restrooms were clean.
I’d recommend you try this spot and leave a review to help others.
… morePizza tasted great! Salad was very good. Garlic knots were great.
2 18-inch pizzas, salad and garlic knots. Our family loved it and had plenty of leftovers.
They do not have fountain machine for drinks but they do have plenty of bottled drinks. That was the only thing I’d like…. since I enjoy iced-t.
Service was really good. Super polite manager / owner. The location itself only has about 9 tables but it’s enough. 5 of us sat at 1 table. Restrooms were clean.
I’d recommend you try this spot and leave a review to help others.
V C (VPB)
Absolutely love this place!
Our family has been coming here for years the pizza is always amazing, and you can tell they use fresh ingredients. My personal favorite is the calzone it’s honestly the best I’ve ever had!
The owner and his team really care about the food they make and the people they serve. You can feel the pride they take in being part of the community. Friendly folks, great service, and consistently awesome food.
Highly recommend !
… moreOur family has been coming here for years the pizza is always amazing, and you can tell they use fresh ingredients. My personal favorite is the calzone it’s honestly the best I’ve ever had!
The owner and his team really care about the food they make and the people they serve. You can feel the pride they take in being part of the community. Friendly folks, great service, and consistently awesome food.
Highly recommend !
Jenna Wright
I was googling “best pizza and wings in Land O Lakes” and upon reading some reviews we gave NY Times Square pizza a try. Ordered thru Slice app. Our order wasn’t quite ready when we arrived but the restaurant was super clean and comfortable while we waited. Garlic wings were delicious and reminded me of wings from up North (hard to find in Florida). Pizza was great but wasn’t hot (guessing it was timing with cooking the wings. No big deal). Very tasty. We look forward to ordering again and dining in for a hot pie!
… moreSunny Sonia
Wanted a snack so we had a hotdog. Wil have to return for their mega big chocolate chip cookies and pizza.
… moreSavannah Savvi
Food and service is always on point, they are popular with my household. Pricing is up there but worth it in my mind. Usually not a fan of red sauces myself, but theirs is good. I always get their calzones with a side of anchovies!
… moreBritney Smith
This was my first visit to NY Times Square, and I had an amazing experience! A staff member named Yawn noticed it was my son’s birthday and generously offered him a complimentary cookie! The customer service was excellent, the food was delicious, and the prices were reasonable. Thank you all for making our day special.
… moreRebecca Tiffault
Updated review
We loved this place so returned again today. I could not be more disappointed in their “white” pizza. It is advertised with ricotta and trying to find ricotta on this pizza was like trying to find a needle in a haystack. Only 2 slices had a tiny speck of ricotta. The pepperoni was fine and their crust is very consistently good.
Original review
We tried this place for take out and were not disappointed. The crust was perfect! Our kids loved it and said this is their new favorite. Definitely give them a try.
… moreWe loved this place so returned again today. I could not be more disappointed in their “white” pizza. It is advertised with ricotta and trying to find ricotta on this pizza was like trying to find a needle in a haystack. Only 2 slices had a tiny speck of ricotta. The pepperoni was fine and their crust is very consistently good.
Original review
We tried this place for take out and were not disappointed. The crust was perfect! Our kids loved it and said this is their new favorite. Definitely give them a try.
Kathleen Leone
Just moved to land o lakes from NJ and we have had a hard time finding good pizza. WE FINALLY FOUND IT HERE! Hallelujah! !
… moreAlex Sierra
Don’t do it. Idk how this place has the ratings that it does. Quality is so bad, I went because Suprema was too busy to pick up their phone amd took a gamble that I wish I hadn’t. The pizza taste like they added a seasoning to the sauce called “Pizza flavoring” wings were pretty gross too. I was extremely hungry so I suffered through it and my stomach has been turning all day.
… moreThe Non Roti Maker
I would recommend come here on weekday in the evening after 6. The owner of the place is a very friendly guy and makes you feel very welcome. You can have a nice chat while he makes your pizza. You exactly see what goes in. I feel that personal touch makes the food a bit better. The evening hour also makes it so that they can spend more time per pizza. We ordered a large cheese pizza with some veggies on it. Come and eat here.
… more