Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
From the first bite to the last, every slice at NY Pizza Suprema tells a story—of family, tradition, and the unmistakable taste of New York. Whether you’re a lifelong New Yorker or visiting for the first time, we invite you to join our table and be part of our history.
Established Madison Square Garden-area staple serving pizzas whole and by the slice.
Hours
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–12 AM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–12 AM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 413 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001
Phone: (212) 594-8939
Website: https://www.nypizzasuprema.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
NY Pizza Suprema: Home
413 8TH AVE, NEW YORK, NY 10001. OWNED BY THE SAME ITALIAN FAMILY FOR OVER 56 YEARS, SAME LOCATION! © 2025 NEW YORK PIZZA SUPREMA. All Rights Reserved …
NY PIZZA SUPREMA (@nypizzasuprema) – Instagram
14K Followers, 437 Following, 265 Posts – NY PIZZA SUPREMA (@nypizzasuprema) on Instagram: “Serving slices of New York since 1964 Rated best slice of #pizza …
Behind the Scenes at NY Pizza Suprema – Scotts Pizza Tours
Suprema is a classic slice shop located directly across the street from Madison Square Garden and Penn Station.
Reviews
Aigerim K
NY Pizza Suprema is one of those rare places that doesn’t just serve food — it serves memories. I still remember the first time I walked in, carried by the warm smell of fresh dough and melted cheese drifting out onto the street. It felt like stepping into a pocket of New York where time slows down just long enough for you to breathe.
I was tired that day — the kind of tired that settles deep in your bones after hours of rushing through the city. But the moment I stepped inside, something softened. The staff greeted me with that unmistakable New York mix of warmth and confidence, like they already knew I was about to have a great slice.
When I took my first bite, everything else faded away. The crust — perfectly crisp; the cheese — rich and comforting; the sauce — bright, warm, almost familiar. It tasted like care, like tradition, like someone put a little heart into it.
Sitting there with my slice, I felt a small moment of peace in a city that never stops moving. NY Pizza Suprema isn’t just a pizzeria — it’s a place where you feel grounded, welcomed, and reminded of how simple joys can turn a day around.
I’m genuinely grateful for every visit — for the flavor, the kindness, the feeling of home tucked inside a perfect New York slice.
… moreI was tired that day — the kind of tired that settles deep in your bones after hours of rushing through the city. But the moment I stepped inside, something softened. The staff greeted me with that unmistakable New York mix of warmth and confidence, like they already knew I was about to have a great slice.
When I took my first bite, everything else faded away. The crust — perfectly crisp; the cheese — rich and comforting; the sauce — bright, warm, almost familiar. It tasted like care, like tradition, like someone put a little heart into it.
Sitting there with my slice, I felt a small moment of peace in a city that never stops moving. NY Pizza Suprema isn’t just a pizzeria — it’s a place where you feel grounded, welcomed, and reminded of how simple joys can turn a day around.
I’m genuinely grateful for every visit — for the flavor, the kindness, the feeling of home tucked inside a perfect New York slice.
Medha Khatri
Lovely experience, great ambience and close to Flix bus stop. Lots of vegetarian and vegan options and really good ones too! The slice of the pizza is reallly filling and a great choice. Must have!
As they say, they only serve pizzas but are the best at this!
I liked the amount of veg options that you have.
Also have a bus in 40 mins so perfect spot to eat and wait!
… moreAs they say, they only serve pizzas but are the best at this!
I liked the amount of veg options that you have.
Also have a bus in 40 mins so perfect spot to eat and wait!
Landon Bellamy
I was looking for some good New York pizza, and this place absolutely SLAPS! Very glad I found this place. There can be a long line, but it moves quickly. Also mind that seating can be limited and tables can be left dirty. However, everyone there was very friendly and had some nice accents.
Now onto the pizza itself: This is exactly what I’m looking for in New York. The dough was at a great texture, it can be greasy at times, but I absolutely love the sauce. Overall, I really enjoyed this place and would come back again.
… moreNow onto the pizza itself: This is exactly what I’m looking for in New York. The dough was at a great texture, it can be greasy at times, but I absolutely love the sauce. Overall, I really enjoyed this place and would come back again.
The Hands On Workshop
Best Pizza when you get off the train at Madison Square garden!
Great crispy thin crust. Balance of sauce and cheese. We’ve tried almost every type over the past year. Hands down favorite spot for a quick slice before hitting the town.
… moreGreat crispy thin crust. Balance of sauce and cheese. We’ve tried almost every type over the past year. Hands down favorite spot for a quick slice before hitting the town.
Stephen sC
Superb family owned pizza restaurant with excellent food at great prices. Handbags a slice and enjoy, its amazing.
Lots of different options and lots of classics.
A must do NY restaurant and a great place to grab a slice and a break.
Very close to madisson square garden if you are visiting there.
… moreLots of different options and lots of classics.
A must do NY restaurant and a great place to grab a slice and a break.
Very close to madisson square garden if you are visiting there.
Emily Boudreaux
Amazing slice of pizza — truly a quintessential New York experience. The moment you walk in, you’re greeted by a lineup of pies like they’re auditioning for your stomach, and yes, you can even go wild and add extra cheese.
The slice itself? Chef’s kiss. Crispy, balanced, and just the right ratio of everything. Was it the best pizza I’ve had in my entire life? Honestly, no — Canadian pizza still has my heart (they flavor the crust at my go-to spot, and that’s hard to beat).
But this? This is officially the best slice I’ve had in the U.S.
… moreThe slice itself? Chef’s kiss. Crispy, balanced, and just the right ratio of everything. Was it the best pizza I’ve had in my entire life? Honestly, no — Canadian pizza still has my heart (they flavor the crust at my go-to spot, and that’s hard to beat).
But this? This is officially the best slice I’ve had in the U.S.
Skylar Taylor
A typical classic slice of NY pizza! Has the reheat flavor to it, sauce was very tomato forward, and honestly quite greasy. Overall basic, nothing crazy or worth extreme hype over. Pretty easy to get in and out of (on foot of course) and convenient. Prices are expensive depending what you get, however that’s typical for NY. We ordered a full pizza, but if wanting to try multiple pies or alone, by the slice may be smarter as they are large slices! Wouldn’t travel here only for the pizza, but would come by if I were in the area due to the convenience and speed.
… moreMassimo
This is a great spot for a classic New York slice. The location is perfect, right by Hudson Yards and Penn Station, which makes it super convenient. Service is fast, so you can grab a slice and go without waiting long.
The pizza itself is very good. The crust has a nice balance of crisp and chew, and the sauce is flavorful without being overwhelming. It really delivers on what you want from a New York style slice. I especially liked the burrata and meat lover options, and the mushroom pizza was excellent too.
The ambiance is fine – nothing fancy, but that’s not really the point here. It’s all about the pizza, and they do it well.
… moreThe pizza itself is very good. The crust has a nice balance of crisp and chew, and the sauce is flavorful without being overwhelming. It really delivers on what you want from a New York style slice. I especially liked the burrata and meat lover options, and the mushroom pizza was excellent too.
The ambiance is fine – nothing fancy, but that’s not really the point here. It’s all about the pizza, and they do it well.
Won Joon Yun
Suprema Pizza turned out to be a surprisingly great choice for my very first pizza in New York. Much better than expected, it set a strong first impression of New York–style pizza.
Prices vary by slice, but they’re around $7.75 each. The pizza follows an Italian-style approach with a thin crust that’s crispy on the outside and soft on the inside.
We ordered four slices in total: Suprema, Fig, Hot Buffalo, and Hot Honey, ranked in that order of preference.
The Suprema slice was the clear favorite. It’s a tomato-based pizza topped with vegetables, and the bell peppers were especially flavorful and memorable. The Fig slice was also delicious, with sweet fig jam complementing the cheese well, though the jam wasn’t spread evenly across the slice, which was a slight downside. The Hot Buffalo slice was spicy and savory, making it enjoyable, while the Hot Honey slice — topped with burrata and hot honey — lacked a strong impact compared to the others.
One thing to note: although they seem to normally accept cards, the card machine wasn’t working at the time, so they were only taking cash.
… morePrices vary by slice, but they’re around $7.75 each. The pizza follows an Italian-style approach with a thin crust that’s crispy on the outside and soft on the inside.
We ordered four slices in total: Suprema, Fig, Hot Buffalo, and Hot Honey, ranked in that order of preference.
The Suprema slice was the clear favorite. It’s a tomato-based pizza topped with vegetables, and the bell peppers were especially flavorful and memorable. The Fig slice was also delicious, with sweet fig jam complementing the cheese well, though the jam wasn’t spread evenly across the slice, which was a slight downside. The Hot Buffalo slice was spicy and savory, making it enjoyable, while the Hot Honey slice — topped with burrata and hot honey — lacked a strong impact compared to the others.
One thing to note: although they seem to normally accept cards, the card machine wasn’t working at the time, so they were only taking cash.
revelynjl
The best upside down pizza ever. I had a Sicilian slice and loved it as well all the BBQ chicken! So yummy affordable and great friendly atmosphere. I ate there and it felt so cozy on a cold winter afternoon.
… more