Social Profile: ![]()
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 380 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage, NY 11714
Phone: (516) 342-1732
Website: http://nostalgiali.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Nostalgia | Bethpage NY – Facebook
Nostalgia, Bethpage. 3945 likes · 57 talking about this · 3134 were here. NOW OPEN TUES-SAT AT 6PM, SUN AT 4PM! Located at 380 N. Wantagh Avenue,…
Nostalgia LI (@nostalgiabarli) • Instagram photos and videos
16K followers · 5.3K+ following · 2797 posts · @nostalgiabarli: “380 N. Wantagh Ave. Bethpage, NY 11714 Email [email protected] for any inquiries.”
Reviews
Adrian Hale
Awesome 90s vibe dive bar! First time here with a buddy of mine seeing a band! Music is kick ass so far. And you get a free drink if you give a 5 star review Imagine is an awesome bartender too, my favorite!
… moreKelly Sitler
I’ve been here since many times, and I’ve never had better service than tonight when Jay and Imagine were bartending. So incredibly personable! And if you don’t know what shot you want? Jay can come up with ANYTHING and will leave you beyond satisfied.
… moreMarissa
Spongebob Experience. Drove 2 hours to come. I really liked it, but the food sucked, just like multiple people said in the reviews. The prices were wayyyy too high also. It would have been fantastic all the way around, 10/10, if they had really good food. Big disappointment there.
The staff were excellent, and the theme was well done.
Edit to respond to owner’s response: the food was frozen/microwavable from the grocery store. I totally get that it’s a bar, but I’ve never had bar food that bad. Seriously. I manage a family-owned bar/café. I’ve been working in food service since I was 14 years old and have been bartending for 8 years. I loved the SpongeBob experience and your staff, but the food has got to change. And the other reviewers agree. I hope you’ll amp it up.
🙂 good luck
… moreThe staff were excellent, and the theme was well done.
Edit to respond to owner’s response: the food was frozen/microwavable from the grocery store. I totally get that it’s a bar, but I’ve never had bar food that bad. Seriously. I manage a family-owned bar/café. I’ve been working in food service since I was 14 years old and have been bartending for 8 years. I loved the SpongeBob experience and your staff, but the food has got to change. And the other reviewers agree. I hope you’ll amp it up.
🙂 good luck
Kayla Murphy
THIS IS THE COOLEST DIVE BAR I HAVE EVER BEEN TO
We came here for the Spongebob Experience and had the BEST TIME
From the decor to the menu, you could tell the team went all out trying to be creative as possible!
One of the coolest parts was the hand chalk-drawn Bikini Bottom scene from a local artist. And the bathroom is a 12/10 visit
For the haters taking trash about the food… IT’S A DIVE BAR Not Gordon Ramsy’s Hell’s Kitchen, get over yourselves! The Krabby Patty was DELICIOUS! Perfectly simple cheeseburger with some secret toppings! The fries were so crispy and good. They even had a Krusty Krab Pizza!
The drinks were good! The “Kelp Shake” was tequila and the “Glove World” had cotton candy!
THE ICONIC TRIPLE GOOBERBERRY SUNRISE. SHUT. UP. Next level place making my childhood foods come to life!
Meeting Spongebob was cool and we will 1000000% be coming back to see the next theme! I heard they’ve done Dragon Ball Z, Rugrats and more!
(The only trouble is parking – which I recommend using the neigboring side streets!)
… moreWe came here for the Spongebob Experience and had the BEST TIME
From the decor to the menu, you could tell the team went all out trying to be creative as possible!
One of the coolest parts was the hand chalk-drawn Bikini Bottom scene from a local artist. And the bathroom is a 12/10 visit
For the haters taking trash about the food… IT’S A DIVE BAR Not Gordon Ramsy’s Hell’s Kitchen, get over yourselves! The Krabby Patty was DELICIOUS! Perfectly simple cheeseburger with some secret toppings! The fries were so crispy and good. They even had a Krusty Krab Pizza!
The drinks were good! The “Kelp Shake” was tequila and the “Glove World” had cotton candy!
THE ICONIC TRIPLE GOOBERBERRY SUNRISE. SHUT. UP. Next level place making my childhood foods come to life!
Meeting Spongebob was cool and we will 1000000% be coming back to see the next theme! I heard they’ve done Dragon Ball Z, Rugrats and more!
(The only trouble is parking – which I recommend using the neigboring side streets!)
Carl Stalzer
Had a birthday party there last night and I had an absolute fantastic time. Seeing all the 90s stuff everywhere was awesome. Staff was top tier, personable, great to talk to and the mixed drinks were so good. 10/10
… moreToby Music
Cool place, nice staff and they have fun events, good food and drinks.. Imagine and Katie are the best.. (everyone is very awesome)
… moreAustin Devejian
This place is ALWAYS a good time! Very fun atmosphere with tons of that 90s ✨nostolgia✨ This place is part bar, part music venue with most nights being live music and some trivia nights sprinkled in. Bring your friends! Imagine was fantastic! The whole crew does a fantastic job.
… moreJenna Dincesen
I’ve been here many times. Tonight I was served by Jay and Imagine. Not only great drinks but amazingly personable and made the whole experience an awesome night!
… moreLucas Truisi
Second time performing here. Imagine is effortlessly kind and very helpful with assisting me in selecting drinks! Atmosphere always rules, and all the throwback content on the surrounding tvs choke me up with joy. Thanks everyone!
… moreMelissa Bunshaft
This place is awesome every time i come in here. Jay and Imagine are phenomenal and two of the best people i have met as bartenders.
… more