Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
North Lake Inn, an Italian restaurant in North Lake, WI, has been delighting the community with authentic Italian cuisine for 42 years. Our mission is to provide a warm dining experience where tradition meets impeccable taste. We offer a diverse menu featuring all Italian food, including our renowned garlic bread, pizza, and lasagna. Savor our specialty offerings, such as fried fish, roasted chicken, and homemade breads and sauces, all crafted from scratch. Enjoy our to-go service for a convenient dining option. Whether you’re a local or visiting, our welcoming atmosphere invites you to indulge in the rich flavors of Italy. Discover more about our menu and book your next meal on our website!
Long-running destination for Italian & American standards served in a homey setting.
Address and Contact Information
Address: W315N7707 WI-83, North Lake, WI 53064
Phone: (262) 966-2782
Website: https://northlakeinn.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
North Lake Inn – North Lake, WI
Nestled in North Lake, WI, North Lake Inn has been a beloved dining destination since 1983. Serving the communities of North Lake and Hartland, …
North Lake, WI
Nestled in North Lake, WI, North Lake Inn has been a beloved dining destination since 1983. Serving the communities of North Lake and Hartland, …
North Lake Inn – Facebook
North Lake Inn, North Lake. 2332 likes · 40 talking about this · 2506 were here. Fine Italian Dining.
Reviews
Chris D
We decided to try this place at the last minute, on a Sunday, about 4:30. We had heard so much about their pizza, we just had to try it. We were not the first ones in, but the bar and dining room were not crowded. We were welcomed like old friends, which was nice. We chose a table near the bar, and as time went on, the place filled up. It appears many regulars like it here, and Bar Dice was banging on the bar often.
We were told they were known for their lasagna, pizza, and garlic bread, so we started with the garlic bread, which was thick and very buttery. But I did not taste much garlic until I was told there was a shaker of it on the table, and I could add more myself if I wanted. Done.
We then ordered a sausage pizza, which came out super hot (yay!) with really crispy crust, just the way it should be. But the sausage was minimal and kind of bland. All in all it was an OK pizza but not our favorite.
I did not see an entrance that was accessible for those with mobility issues. The bar area is crowded and not good for easy access, even just walking through. The dining area was more open, if you can get in the door.
Apparently, business is really good, so I have to assume it is more my taste that wasn’t matched. I’m glad we tried it just to see what everyone talks about.
… moreWe were told they were known for their lasagna, pizza, and garlic bread, so we started with the garlic bread, which was thick and very buttery. But I did not taste much garlic until I was told there was a shaker of it on the table, and I could add more myself if I wanted. Done.
We then ordered a sausage pizza, which came out super hot (yay!) with really crispy crust, just the way it should be. But the sausage was minimal and kind of bland. All in all it was an OK pizza but not our favorite.
I did not see an entrance that was accessible for those with mobility issues. The bar area is crowded and not good for easy access, even just walking through. The dining area was more open, if you can get in the door.
Apparently, business is really good, so I have to assume it is more my taste that wasn’t matched. I’m glad we tried it just to see what everyone talks about.
Eric Paulsen
If you live old school Italian food and old school Wisconsin bars, this is a fantastic combo. A relaxed bar atmosphere (with a separate restaurant area, we just stayed at the bar) coupled with delicious Italian classics. The crunchy cracker crust style pizza, generous servings of pasta (plus nice 1/2 order options for when you’re just kinda hungry), and irresistible cheesy garlic bread hottubbing in butter means I’m going to work out more so I can come back more often. Peroni on tap is a nice plus!
… moreDan Giampetroni
At was fine.
Dining area in the back was terrible. Bad service took too long for the food. Half of it was warm. One pizza had onions on it that we did not order. Just bad experience. Hope it was an anomaly.
… moreDining area in the back was terrible. Bad service took too long for the food. Half of it was warm. One pizza had onions on it that we did not order. Just bad experience. Hope it was an anomaly.
Tim Grossmann
We called for carry out. The person who answered spoke clearly and with ambition.
Pick up was on time and still very friendly.
The food was hot, tasteful and a hit out of the park! Thank you staff for making us happy.
… morePick up was on time and still very friendly.
The food was hot, tasteful and a hit out of the park! Thank you staff for making us happy.
Kevin Golliher
First time at this Italian restaurant in North Lake. Their menu is very similar in items and taste as the classic Mama Mia’s from Milwaukee.
We ate at the bar. The place was busy, but we were still checked on regularly. The atmosphere reminds me of up north bars/restaurants.
I ordered the Lasagna special, which includes soup, salad, garlic bread, lasagna and ice cream. The soup was delicious; the salad was simple, lettuce with meat, cheese, pepperoncini, but the dressing made it special; the garlic bread made this trip worth it, thick crisp buttery, will go back just for this; I was initially disappointed in the lasagna, so much cheese made it hard to eat. Suggestion, start in the middle where the noodles and meat are and work your way out to avoid only cheese. Once I figured that out it was very good.
I will go back here again and could easily see raising this rating to a 5.
… moreWe ate at the bar. The place was busy, but we were still checked on regularly. The atmosphere reminds me of up north bars/restaurants.
I ordered the Lasagna special, which includes soup, salad, garlic bread, lasagna and ice cream. The soup was delicious; the salad was simple, lettuce with meat, cheese, pepperoncini, but the dressing made it special; the garlic bread made this trip worth it, thick crisp buttery, will go back just for this; I was initially disappointed in the lasagna, so much cheese made it hard to eat. Suggestion, start in the middle where the noodles and meat are and work your way out to avoid only cheese. Once I figured that out it was very good.
I will go back here again and could easily see raising this rating to a 5.
Jen Fredrich
We had never been here before but we will definitely be back! Peggy was our waitress and she was great! The food was also amazing and we can’t wait to go back.
… moredave crupi
Fantastic Italian Food ! The portions were like I was sitting at my Nonna’s. Service was great and you could feel the fun in the air
… moreJuga
We ordered 2 pans of lasagna with garlic bread and salad to go, for a party. It was excellent and everyone (a group of 12 guys) raved about the food! Would definitely do their catering again.
… moreRobert Jenkyns
My wife and I stopped by for a brew and appetizer. We had a Franziskaner and egg plant fries. Both were REALLY good. The service was quick and awesome! We highly recommend this place! (Their pizza is also out of this world good!)
… moreEdee Jen
Just picked up 2 small pizzas and a small Italian salad. Each pizza was $25. I ordered the veggie pizza with no black olives, and of course it had black olives. Crust was totally stale. The worst part was the small Italian salad. It is tiny but cost $8.50. Save your money and get good food anywhere else. Picture of $8.50 salad included.
… more