At North Italia, we’re passionate about more than just our crave-worthy Italian food menu. We put our all into every detail, creating an environment that lets you know you’re in for something special. Every day there is a new delicious favorite made from scratch, like our Chef’s daily pizzas, waiting to be discovered and devoured. A tempting assortment of wines, beer, and house-made cocktails give you endless ways to treat yourself. From the moment you walk through our doors, to your last scoops of budino at the end of a satisfying meal, you’ll know you’re in good hands.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Italian Restaurant in Peoria – North Italia
North Italia: Handmade Pasta | Handmade Pizza
Peoria, AZ – Order Online – North Italia
Reviews
But what truly made the night was our server, Samantha—she was absolutely fantastic! Incredibly knowledgeable about the menu, spot-on with her recommendations, attentive, warm, and genuinely made the experience special. We’ll be back and requesting her section every time. Highly recommend—5 stars!
We began with the Chef’s Board, which was a fantastic appetizer. The selection of items was generous and beautifully presented — the only thing I would have liked was a little more bread since there were so many delicious accompaniments. Our favorite was the orange fennel mostarda, followed closely by the eggplant caponata.
I was initially disappointed to learn that the Braised Short Rib Lumache and the Sunday Night Lasagna weren’t available due to Spring Training starting that day and the kitchen not having them prepared. However, our server recommended the Braised Short Rib Marsala and the Roasted Butternut Squash Polenta — and I’m so glad she did!
The short ribs were melt-in-your-mouth tender, and the risotto was creamy and packed with flavor. The Brussels sprouts and carrots added the perfect contrast and balance to the dish. The Roasted Butternut Squash Polenta was cooked perfectly — creamy, cheesy polenta with the butternut squash adding just the right touch of brightness.
My husband ordered the Ricotta Cavatelli, which unfortunately was disappointing. There was very little shrimp, and the crab tasted overcooked and was not edible, so we sent it back. Thankfully, my entrée was generous in portion size, and we were able to share.
For dessert, I ordered the seasonal butter cake made with red velvet buttercream, strawberries, and raspberries on a bed of raspberry purée. It was delicious — but it still wasn’t the star of the night. My husband ordered the salted caramel budino, and it was absolutely to die for. Espresso fudge, banana chantilly cream, and toasted pecan toffee on top — after one bite, we both had a full “Ratatouille moment,” instantly transported back to a blissfully happy childhood memory. We are still dreaming about that dessert!
If you haven’t been to North Italia Peoria yet, go — and whatever you do, make sure to leave room for dessert!
The pasta is made from scratch and is absolutely delicious.
The little gem Caesar salad is very fresh crusty and scrumptious.
Strozzapreti was out of the world. The best mushroom pasta I’ve had so far!
Highly recommend
Chicken Parmesan was delicious creamy.
The building is new—clean and pretty—but the vibe and design don’t quite match the cozy feel of the other locations. However the parking lot is great, much better than at the other locations.
For food, I ordered the Hot Italian Stromboli and the Prosciutto Pizza (a favorite of ours from the other restaurants). Both were really good, and our drinks were solid as well. I tried the Gin Pomegranate Mule, which tasted nice, but I was a bit disappointed that it came in a regular glass instead of a copper mug—it didn’t feel much like a “mule” that way.
Overall, the customer service was good, and while this location has a different style and menu, it’s still worth a visit.
We have given North Italia multiple opportunities to improve, yet the same issues persist. At this price point, the inconsistency and declining food quality are simply unacceptable. The value no longer aligns with the premium pricing, and experiences like this are a major deterrent to returning.
This represents a significant failure in both execution and standards—and it warrants immediate attention