Jessica Williams
I want to start this review saying that I sure hope the manager that’s Not Steven doesn’t treat the employees like he treated us. We were headed to our hotel when other hockey team members called and said they were headed to Nitty-gritty to eat. We had seen the ads at the hockey rink and turned around and were the first ones there. I walked in and Not Steven asked how many. I explained I thought about 20-25 from our team were coming. He told us that he could not accommodate all of us in one area, that he had several teams coming in that had set reservations. He told us we should have made reservations months ago and made us feel like a complete inconvenience. I had never been to Sun Prairie and wouldn’t have any idea of that. We waited for our friends and eventually Steven moved us together, after Not Steven seemed to go out of his way to spread us across the whole building. I’m so glad that we did not just leave due to the way we were treated by Not Steven. Our server was Joe I believe. He was attentive and polite and did a wonderful job. Honestly all the other staff seemed happy to be there and seemed to enjoy working there. The food was fast, tasted wonderful, and was very well put together. We ordered a few different things. The nachos had great ground meat that wasn’t greasy gross. The flatbread was well made. Everything else was great also. The price for the plate size was good also. It’s a shame that my first and lasting impression is of how inconvenient we were to Not Steven. I do want to note that, while we were there, I never saw any part of any of the other teams there. There did seem to be a small gathering of adults at one time but no other teams. I truly hope the manager doesn’t treat his amazing team the way he treated new customers. Also, Steven was wonderful and was very welcoming.
… moreDonna Herrmann
We had a group of 24 and Claire, the Event Coordinator, took great care of us. We were set up in a side room. We had two servers and they were both terrific. The food was delicious and everyone was happy with what they ordered. All of the food was hot. We had everything from a children’s grilled cheese, to every type of burger, soup, chili and a scrambler. We had people from Oregon, Eagle River, Stevens Point, Madison and Milwaukee. Our group decided this was a good gathering place and we would definitely visit the Sun Prairie Nitty Gritty again. Thank you for making our gathering extra special.
… moreJulie Busch
When our family could finally get together from Iowa, Milwaukee and Sun Prairie for a late Christmas, we selected Nitty Gritty to meet….WOW, did they make us feel welcomed with a big comfortable table in a great spot and one amazing server who was so attentive. Our food looked like it came out of a food magazine. So delish! The manager/host was so cordial and accommodating! Great place, awesome for reservations and made for a very memorable day with our family. Thank you, Nitty Gritty!!
… moreMichelle K
As a celiac, I really appreciate that the Nitty Gritty has a separate fryer and offers a decent gluten free bun for burgers. My favorite is the Black and Blue burger but I also love the garlic burger. Just substitute the crispy onions for regular or fried. Yum! Whenever I am craving a burger, I go to Nitty Gritty.
The drinks are also priced decently and made well. Get the double – it’s worth it!
Service is always friendly.
… moreJoseph Haman
Very good burgers and service. Our hockey team of 12 players plus parents and siblings were in town for a tournament. The restraunt was able to get us in and sat us at a large tables next to each other. We had great service, the food was unbelievably, and they treated the kids great. Thanks. If we are back in the area next season, we will definitely come back here.
… moreJacqueline Vierbicher
Service was pretty slow for the amount of people in the restaurant. Drinks took a long time but the food was a bit quicker. Garlic parm wings were tasty. The nachos were good and a nice large order. The Italian sandwich was good.
… moreKy Hunter
Burgers taste great although only thing that I didn’t like was just how big they make the burger, so ask for Hella Napkins, it’ll fall apart. Also need to mention it’s almost impossible to take a proper bite of your monstrous Burger without the inherited risk of never breathing again. Lbvs
Not Hating just my Honest opinion
… moreKerstin Gorsuch
Awesome food and the service is friendly. The jalapeño popper burger is amazing. I am sad it is just a monthly special. Get it while you can though. It is super good.
… moreRachel
DELICIOUS burgers. Gluten free buns available. I was so into my burger I forgot to take a picture haha. Our server Wes was great, too!
… moreL Fev
We had 7 in our group and service was good. The place was getting busy – Sunday at lunchtime. Burgers were excellent! We ordered a couple different cheese burgers and 2 ordered the beyond burger. We also had different options for fries and the Chips & Guac were great. The grilled cheese for the little one was good too! We’ll be back when we’re in town!
… more