Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Specialty pizzas, an assortment of subs & even tacos & fajitas at this roomy pizzeria/restaurant.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1737 Orchard Park Rd, West Seneca, NY 14224
Phone: (716) 674-9066
Website: http://www.ninospizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Nino’s Pizza: HOME
WEST SENECA. 674 – 9066. 1737 Orchard Park Road West Seneca, NY 14224 (near Michael Road). MAP. HAMBURG. 648- 2500. 315 Buffalo Street Hamburg, NY 14075 (corner …
Nino’s Pizza | West Seneca NY – Facebook
Nino’s Pizza, West Seneca. 3045 likes · 5 talking about this · 2273 were here. West Seneca’s Best Pizza. Get special deals and the latest info.
Nino’s Pizza Review West Seneca NY – YouTube
Nino’s Pizza Review West Seneca NY 1737 Orchard Park Rd, West Seneca, NY 14224 #pizza #review #food #foodie #cheese #foodblogger #newyork …
Reviews
D Eckert
Ordered here for the first time yesterday.
We ordered a large cheese & pepperoni pizza with a double order of medium wings. Order was to be ready in 30 minutes and they delivered on that promise.
I’ll start with the pizza. It definitely makes my top 10 list of all of the different pizzerias I’ve tried in recent years. It was made with quality ingredients that they weren’t skimpy with and was cooked to perfection.
I’ll finish with the good about the wings. The homemade blue cheese was decent. Carrots and celery were a nice touch even though we don’t eat them. The bad… the wings looked great but looks sometimes cam be deceiving. They were cooked but definitely undercooked for a chicken wing. Probably only spent 12 minutes in the fryer when they should be in there for usually 15-18 minutes as the skins were rubbery and meat was tough to pull from the bones. Based on the fact that they’ve been in business many years, I think it’s safe to assume this was an anomaly.
The pizza definitely will bring me back for another soon and will give their wings will give another chance someday.
… moreWe ordered a large cheese & pepperoni pizza with a double order of medium wings. Order was to be ready in 30 minutes and they delivered on that promise.
I’ll start with the pizza. It definitely makes my top 10 list of all of the different pizzerias I’ve tried in recent years. It was made with quality ingredients that they weren’t skimpy with and was cooked to perfection.
I’ll finish with the good about the wings. The homemade blue cheese was decent. Carrots and celery were a nice touch even though we don’t eat them. The bad… the wings looked great but looks sometimes cam be deceiving. They were cooked but definitely undercooked for a chicken wing. Probably only spent 12 minutes in the fryer when they should be in there for usually 15-18 minutes as the skins were rubbery and meat was tough to pull from the bones. Based on the fact that they’ve been in business many years, I think it’s safe to assume this was an anomaly.
The pizza definitely will bring me back for another soon and will give their wings will give another chance someday.
Sandy Knox
Don’t know what’s going on here. Used to be great. Not anymore
Pizzas just OK but their subs are horrible. Chunks of lettece,not shredded, roll tasted stale and their oil is NOT oil. Taste like creamy Italian dressing. What a disappointment. Never again. Save your money!
… morePizzas just OK but their subs are horrible. Chunks of lettece,not shredded, roll tasted stale and their oil is NOT oil. Taste like creamy Italian dressing. What a disappointment. Never again. Save your money!
Mike R
Ordered a large cheese pep 1/2 green olive. This one doesn’t make sense no matter how you try and argue it..
I live 40 mins away and have claimed Ninos to be my favorite for years. Once in a while if I’m out that way I’ll order it as a treat.
The past few times definitely seemed to have gone down hill. But it’s not just here, it seems to be every place you go now a days messes up your order somehow. Silly me for not checking the box until I got home.
Food was still good. Girl at the counter was nice. Kids in the back need to stop smoking pot on break.
… moreI live 40 mins away and have claimed Ninos to be my favorite for years. Once in a while if I’m out that way I’ll order it as a treat.
The past few times definitely seemed to have gone down hill. But it’s not just here, it seems to be every place you go now a days messes up your order somehow. Silly me for not checking the box until I got home.
Food was still good. Girl at the counter was nice. Kids in the back need to stop smoking pot on break.
Jake P
I want to start off by saying, this place used to be great. Everything here used to be incredible but as of the last 2-3 years or so, absolutely not. This place had viciously downgraded in quality so bad, its a crying shame I can only get breadsticks here, because its the one thing they can’t mess up. Sub? It was like they grabbed half a brick of cheese and put it on mine, making it so gross and inedible I got it refunded. Okay cool, maybe a mistake happened, couple days later? A personal chicken finger pizza. Drenched with absurd amounts of sauce and cant even pick it up. The one night I went here with my family on a not busy night? THEY LOST OUR PIZZA. HOW?! This places quality took a hit as the teenagers just started doing whatever they want.This is the first and only place where I’ve actually had to get my food refunded due to there being an absolute lack of consistency. Hopefully there is a huge management overhaul before I have anything other than breadsticks…
… moreDante Terrana
I grew up enjoying Ninos pizza and wings for many years. It’s definitely not the same any more. Despite being on site to pick up my order fresh from the oven, it still sat on the warming counter for many minutes waiting for staff to hand it to me to leave (and they were not busy at all), making the pizza taste somewhat dried out. We’ve continued to give Ninos another chance every few years, hoping new management may improve the quality. Sadly, they’re not there yet.
… moreCynthia Matteson
I ordered a chicken Parm sandwich and this is what I got. So disappointed. Plus the order didn’t come with French fries like the person on the phone confirmed. There goes $14.
… moreKaren Ovitt
Ordered for a office party. They forgot the 2- 2 liters of soda and plates and napkins. We asked for 2 large pizzas to be cut into squares to get more pieces out of it (it was not), not to mention the carrots and celery were frozen. We also ordered a party pizza and the slices were not consistent, some pieces were very big and some very small. Absolutely terrible! We will not be ordering from this place in the future.
… moreNick Zak
Been coming here for many years and it’s slowly gotten worse. Today was the last time I’ll order there. $82 for some subs that sat too long while we waited for the pizza, making them soggy. Breadsticks that were as dry as croutons and a $17 chicken salad that was a bowl of lettuce with hardly any chicken. These places are too expensive for such bad quality. I agree with the rest of the reviews – just a bunch of kids there, none of whom care about making things right.
… moreJulie Zontek
This is My ABSOLUTELY FAVORITE Place to get my Pizza and Wings! Never a disappointment in our family. Also can’t find a better homemade blue cheese than here.
… moreNicole A
Ordered a Philly cheesesteak sub. “Classic thinly-sliced sirloin tips sautéed in our own special steak sauce with melted cheddar cheese, sweet peppers and onions.” Dry. A couple onion slices. No peppers detected. No sauce detected. No cheese detected. It’s a dry sub with some steak and a couple onion slices. Do better.
… more