Nina's Pizza - Utica, NY 13502 - Menu, Reviews, Hours & Contact

Stop by Nina’s Pizza today for lunch or dinner and stay warm while enjoying all your favorites! Choose from a delicious variety of pizzas, pinwheels, subs, …

Nina’s Pizza – 100 Genesee St, Utica, NY 13502 – Slice

Order online at one of the best restaurants in Utica, NY! Nina’s Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy your …

Reviews

Meri O.

Definitely our favorite pizza and chicken wings! We’ve been ordering from them a lot lately, and they never disappoint. Today we chose delivery instead of pickup, and everything arrived still hot and fresh, even with the horrible weather. It was icy and windy, but the pizza and wings were perfect. Thank you!

… more

Ryan Mazierski

Nina’s Pizza has great pizza! The pizza has a nice crispy crust and great sauce. All the ingredients are quality. Service here was friendly and fast. Pickup was easy. They have a large menu with many different types of pizzas, sandwiches, subs, pastas, and salads. If you’re looking for a great restaurant in Utica this is the place to go.

… more

Cawley

The best and by far the biggest calzone I’ve ever had

Nina was lovely, and made me a gigantic mozzarella & ricotta stuffed calzone. The garlic parm sprinkled over the top was a great touch. The food came quickly. I fully recommend.

… more

Stephanie Derosa

What a horrific restaurant!!! It’s gone down hill fast and I will never return after tonight! First we order and when my husband arrives they said the tickets didn’t print and his food wasn’t “ordered” he proceeded to have to wait there an additional 40 minutes for the food while the employee was screaming at another patron and calling him vulgar names! In a rush and now late, he grabs it and goes. He gets back home to find the entire pizza smothered in mushrooms. However half was ordered as cheese. We call to explain the incident very nicely even given the already terrible service stayed calm assuming they would accommodate us. She proceeds to be rude and disgusting on the phone!! Says if we want to bring all the food back down they’ll trade our pizza for another! Absolutely gross! Terrible management. I’ll never return.

… more

Matthew Costello

Ordered a large cheese on the Slice App. Had to wait a little, but definitely worth the wait. The owner apologized for the wait which was appreciated. When I got home, I had a perfectly cooked cheese pizza. Crust was crunchy with generously added cheese, which was the chefs kiss. The best pizza in Utica hands down. Thanks for making a perfect pizza.

… more

Megan Colvin

10/10! Nina’s has the best Pizza and food I have found anywhere in NY! Nothing like coming home to Utica and finding a taste of Italy in my back yard!! And her PIZZA! The best I have had anywhere I have lived. I recommend Nina’s to all my friends and family! Her restaurant is also so warm and friendly and she makes you feel like family coming in!!! Truly the best in town!

… more

Nor Grigsby

Have had the pleasure of eating at Nina’s twice, and definitely plan to continue eating here for as long as they’re around (hopefully a long time!). I have a wheat allergy and everyone there is so kind and knowledgeable about what is/isn’t gluten free (GF), and also explained *why* anything was not GF which is such a reassurance. My first visit I had the gluten free pizza, and my husband (has no allergies) had the CBR slice and Buffalo chicken dip riggies. It was definitely in the top two gluten free pizzas I’ve ever had, and my husband raved about the riggies and says the CBR is the best he’s ever had. My second time eating there, I learned they have gluten free pasta! I was thrilled and again, everyone there was extremely knowledgeable and we decided on a gluten free shrimp alfredo. It is *hands down THE best* shrimp alfredo I’ve ever had – sauce was light and flavorful, shrimp were seasoned and cooked to perfection, and the pasta was high quality. My husband also had their garlic and upside down slices (again, not GF) and is adamant they are a 9.4 and 9.8 out of 10 respectively! Parking is easy and free, so next time you’re looking for your new favorite authentic pizza joint, put Nina’s at the top of your list!

… more

Jamie True

I stopped in, as a first time customer while visiting Upstate NY. Two huge slices, a veggie and a cheese and it was definitely amazing. I haven’t been back to NY since we moved in 2010 and I am so glad it did NOT disappoint. This is why NY is known for the BEST pizza. Thank you or the hospitality and amazing slices.

… more

Jose Acosta

It might be the best pizza I ever had. It’s really good food but better people! We talked with the owner, and he was so passionate about the pizza. He was also very proud of the pizza. It seems that he got everything figured out. We had a great time and I am glad we found this place. I will recommend it 100%. Congrats, guys!

… more

Elias Romero

Very welcoming environment and the service is always perfect. There was an instance where I had a problem with a order refund and both the staff and the owner made sure to communicate and resolve the issue as soon as possible. The food is always delicious, hot, and fresh

… more

… View more

Nina’s Pizza

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Nina’s Pizza Utica, New York

Nina’s Pizza | Utica NY – Facebook

Nina’s Pizza – 100 Genesee St, Utica, NY 13502 – Slice

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

🍽️ List or Update Your Restaurant

Recent Posts