Nicky’s The Real McCoy® at 24th & Cicero Avenue is a fast-casual restaurant located in Cicero. We serve all of the Windy City’s favorites, such as Chicago-style Hot Dogs, Italian Beefs, Gyros, Polishes, Nicky’s The Real McCoy® original location at 58th & Kedzie Avenue is where all the flavorful magic first began back in late 1960s and eventually expanded to 11524 South Pulaski in Alsip, IL and then here in Cicero. And now in our New location 5341 S. Archer “By Midway airport” Our success has let to some counterfeit venues using our likeness, so unless it says, Nicky’s The Real McCoy®, /“Nicky’s The Real-One’’order at your own rick.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2400 S Cicero Ave, Cicero, IL 60804
Phone: (708) 222-8500
Website: https://nickystherealmccoy24.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Nicky’s The Real McCoy – Fast Casual Restaurant – Cicero, Illinois
Let us spoil you with our Service & Hospitality in our friendly fast casual restaurant. Visit us @ 24th & Cicero (708) 222-8500
Nicky’s (24th and Cicero) Delivery Menu | Order Online – Grubhub
Nicky’s Flame-Broiled Dinners-Favorites; Greek Dinners and Sandwiches; From Our Grill Burgers & Steaks; Italian Sandwiches; Nicky’s the Real Mccoy® Famous Hot …
Nicky’s The Real McCoy | Cicero IL – Facebook
. 3 Reviews ; . Open now ; . 2400 S Cicero Ave, Cicero, IL, United States, 60804-3442 …
Reviews
Bailey Guest
This place is overpriced and the billing practices felt very questionable. They’re trying to charge 10% for every dollar spent when you pay with a card — not just credit cards, but any card — and it wasn’t clearly explained. On top of that, the receipt didn’t properly break down the charges or taxes, just a total with extra added on. If you’re going to add fees, at least be transparent about it.
The service was also pretty rude when we asked about it, which didn’t help the situation.
I stopped in hoping it would still be like it was back in the day, but the food was only subpar at best and definitely not worth the price.
… moreThe service was also pretty rude when we asked about it, which didn’t help the situation.
I stopped in hoping it would still be like it was back in the day, but the food was only subpar at best and definitely not worth the price.
Kelly Davis
Great food. Huge portions. The woman we had was kind of rude, but I give passes because Im sure she had plenty of rude customers before us. Casual place to grab and go. We had leftovers for next day.
… moreBrad Lentz
Was visiting from out of town when I found this awesome spot. Was in and out in under 10 minutes, the staff was very helpfull. Ordered a Gyro with fries (added feta and lettuce for a small extra charge). Best part is they have RC cola on tap! Been decades since I have seen that….they also had other menu items that looked enticing, will definitely be back next time I am in Chicago!
… moreuzi uzi
absolutely love this spot! ive been here a few times now and it never disappoints. the staff is super friendly. i tried the rib eye steak meal and it was so good, full of flavor and came out hot and fresh. prices are fair too, especially for the quality. definitely a hidden gem in the neighborhood. highly recommend!
… morekim gutierrez
I and my family of 4 generations have been coming here over 30 years and all the other locations as well. Never had a problem with the food. But to serve you a burnt burger bun on both sides. In my opinion shows inexperience and lack of training on Nicky’s part.I will still come here but I will check to see who is at the grill cooking. My son was hungry so he didn’t see what he was eating. I could smell it was burnt without looking. Not happy because I will need to check my order before I leave the place the next time I place an order. Burger was still eaten by my son but I’m not thrilled to buy burnt food.
… moreVictoria Glaser
It really is The Real McCoy! Service is solid. I wish I could remember the young woman’s name who took our order! She was fantastic… very inviting and fun personality! Food was solid went in for the Italian Beef, a couple of Chicago dogs and some fries with my husband & son for them who aren’t from Chicago. It’s a true Chicago experience. Owner was also on sight and surprised us with av visit. Super to get to know him. Look forward to going again next time we visit. Gyros is next up!
… moreJeff
This has been our go to Friday office lunch restaurant for a while now. I honestly have not had a bad meal here. Service is great, the order taker remembers you and has a smile when you return. We absolutely love their fries!! It’s like an addiction 🙂
Some of the standouts are the Ribeye Steak sandwich and the Grilled Chicken Sandwich. But honestly you can’t go wrong with anything you order here. This place is a hidden gem.
… moreSome of the standouts are the Ribeye Steak sandwich and the Grilled Chicken Sandwich. But honestly you can’t go wrong with anything you order here. This place is a hidden gem.
Jayden Pelagio
The amount of food you get is nice and it tasted good. I did not leave hungry and had some leftover for lunch the next day.
… more