Tylor Sherman
What a beautiful and absolutely delicious place. Being from out of town we were not quite sure what we were going to get but this place is an absolute diamond in the rough. The flavor and authenticity of each dish had was phenomenal. If we ever find ourselves in the Rochester area again, this will become in every time stop. Highly highly highly recommended!
… moreAmanda El
A bit of a blast from the past restaurant, the type of place you would’ve gone with your parents when you were a kid, but I still enjoyed the old-school charm. They have a salad bar that was typical of places like this back in the day and I have to admit I have a soft spot for a nice old-fashioned salad bar with soup. Service was excellent. Fresh baked warm bread comes with your meal. Good cocktails.
… moreMichele Finn
Love this place!! The antipasto (salad) bar is so fresh and so good with an awesome homemade soup and homemade salad dressings. We love their Italian options on the menu. The manicotti and ravioli are DELISH! Both homemade! Service is great and their fresh bread is awesome! Family owned. Highly recommend!
… moreSusan Katz Aser
Such a great Rochester Gem. Great atmosphere…especially for movie buffs. Nick is on site to share a great story. Food is fabulous. Staff on point. This will not disappoint. Yummy!
… morePaula DeMercurio
Visiting family here and stopped by Nick’s for the Wednesday night buffet – loved it! The eggplant parm was outstanding, and the salad bar was fresh and full of options. If I had more time, I would have loved to explore the regular menu because everything looked amazing. The real highlight? The owner! Be sure to ask him about stories from the good old times, it adds a personal touch you won’t find anywhere else. Great food, great atmosphere, and great people. Definitely worth a visit!
… moreMatt Ruffell
Very good meal choices and a great antipasto bar. The flavors are good but a little underseasoned. Needs a little more salt and garlic in the red sauce. The place is very old school, but I like it. You get free pizza and bread with every meal.
… moreJane Rivera
We got there with no where to park, we had a 4pm reservation and they sat us at literally the worst table in the house. We sat there for at least 10 minutes before drinks and at least 45 until we got food. We were told we could move to a new table and then they sat some other people there instead. The server was ok. I paid for prime rib and got a plan old nasty steak. My mom got the duck and well it made her sick. I didn’t even eat my “prime rib”. BTW, we had to leave the very second we even got our food because everything and I mean everything was awful. NEVER, will we go there again. And it was my first time there. Worst thanksgiving ever.
… moreCarla M
If you like the Olive Garden you’ll like this place. If you actually know what good Italian food is, you will not find it here. But the people were lovely.
The chicken parm was way to saucey and the sauce is too thick and the pasta is not al dente. it is mushy,
… moreIan Sinopoli
Right across the street from the park, this is a very nice place with warm and friendly service. The portion size is generous, and the food was very good. Whether you are capping off a day at the park or looking for a good dinner choice, I highly recommend Nick’s.
… moreRochelle Bayne
We were celebrating a birthday and had a wonderful time with delicious food. I had seafood and others had pasta and chicken parmesan. Service was fantastic; we ate at the bar which had plenty of space for our meals which was nice. Have always had great meals here.
… more