Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 84 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716
Phone: (732) 204-2340
Website: https://www.nicholascreamery.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Nicholas Creamery: Homemade Small Batch Ice Cream
Nicholas Creamery was created out of a love for homemade ice cream, high … 84 1st Avenue Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 732-204-2340. . Hours: Sun-Thurs …
Nicholas Creamery | Atlantic Highlands NJ – Facebook
Nicholas Creamery makes homemade, small batch ice cream using natural dairy and the purest of ingredi
Nicholas Creamery (@nicholascreamery) · Fair Haven, NJ – Instagram
New Jersey Homemade, Small Batch Ice Cream. Atlantic Highlands, Fair Haven, Tinton Falls, Long Branch, Middletown, Wall.
Reviews
Jay Smith
From the reviews, I thought this was going to be a mind-blowing ice cream experience. Don’t get me wrong, it was good, just not great. I’ve had ice cream in almost every state and this wouldn’t be in my top 10. We had creme brulee, which would’ve been excellent minus the brulee topping, cookies and cream, which was okay and lastly not your cherries Garcia, which was the best of the 3. Also, the large, which I took the pic of, is everyone else’s medium, although the $5.95 price is fair. Store decor is great and service is decent, albeit not fast.
… moreDina
Love the small batch, unique flavor combinations. The taste and quality make it worth a trip. OMG the carrot cake ice cream is incredible.
… moreDeborah Zitomer
Um, yum. Stopped by this place part on recommendation, part just looking for ice cream and it was sure worth it. Delicious, unique flavors, pleasant service, indoor seating and nice decor. Really great ice cream, highly recommend.
… moreGeorge Rodriguez
Me and my family love this place. I get that fatboy excitement when I see a Nicholas Creamery text come in, telling about what new flavor is in. Italian rainbow cookie, cannoli, and pineapple cake being my favorites in that order. However, as of late my pints have been light. Last time it was my cannoli pint, nowhere near full. Ok, 1 time no big deal. Their scoops are almost always healthy. Then today again. My favorite, Italian rainbow cookie is back. So, I got 2 pints. They got them from the back. I didnt check just rushed home so it wouldn’t melt and so me and my family could enjoy. Again, nowhere near full. I feel cheated. Check the pics. That said, I’ll still be back
… moreNitsat Hadas Elami
Great icecream! Creamy, a very nice variety of flavors and a very reasonable price. Will go back for sure.
… moreEE Grimshaw
Absolutely delicious. The Millennial Chum and I stopped by this past Saturday afternoon on her recommendation after a nearby lunch. This is my kind of ice cream place – verging on hipster, with unique flavors that require an extra few minutes of hemming and hawing because there are tons of legit options. This was a rare instance where I was completely okay with there being a few customers in line ahead of us to give me more time to make a decision.
There were a few strong contenders but I ultimately ordered one of their small batch options, Taliercio’s Italian Cookie. I’d…make that a flavor year-round. I’m a big fan of Italian cookies in general (my favorite is probably the anisettes), and one of the main reasons is their emphasis on almond extract. I didn’t notice or confirm any anisette cookies in there, but I’m pretty sure I spied and/or tasted a few rainbows and butter cookies. It’s a great flavor, and the cookies tasted fresh. In my experience from getting, say, a cookie dough-type flavor, the only potential problem that can arise is if the cookies are stale or the consistency is off from the ice cream. Not here. Perfect and tasty. The Millennial Chum went with one of their “normal” flavors, coincidentally their version of the cookie dough with brown sugar, and was enormously pleased.
One big caveat here – they ARE cash only and have an ATM on the premises. In fact, the initial reason we stopped here was because we planned to go to an estate sale and the Millennial Chum needed to use said ATM to ensure we had some viable legal tender for that event. We didn’t end up even going to do that, but I’d say plan B was a lot better and more scrumptious.
… moreThere were a few strong contenders but I ultimately ordered one of their small batch options, Taliercio’s Italian Cookie. I’d…make that a flavor year-round. I’m a big fan of Italian cookies in general (my favorite is probably the anisettes), and one of the main reasons is their emphasis on almond extract. I didn’t notice or confirm any anisette cookies in there, but I’m pretty sure I spied and/or tasted a few rainbows and butter cookies. It’s a great flavor, and the cookies tasted fresh. In my experience from getting, say, a cookie dough-type flavor, the only potential problem that can arise is if the cookies are stale or the consistency is off from the ice cream. Not here. Perfect and tasty. The Millennial Chum went with one of their “normal” flavors, coincidentally their version of the cookie dough with brown sugar, and was enormously pleased.
One big caveat here – they ARE cash only and have an ATM on the premises. In fact, the initial reason we stopped here was because we planned to go to an estate sale and the Millennial Chum needed to use said ATM to ensure we had some viable legal tender for that event. We didn’t end up even going to do that, but I’d say plan B was a lot better and more scrumptious.
Dena Scoullos
Went there on opening day. The ice cream was delicious , very creamy. It has a farmhouse look, very nice decor. The staff was friendly and quick.
They offer vegan ice cream options. You can see all of the description on their website. The smell of waffles was in the air, as they baked fresh waffles cones !!!
… moreThey offer vegan ice cream options. You can see all of the description on their website. The smell of waffles was in the air, as they baked fresh waffles cones !!!
Tara Geraghty
I am an ice cream snob. If I’m going to eat that many calories and sugar it better be good. This place will be the downfall of my summer. It’s crack ice cream. Beyond addicting. Probably one of the top five ice cream experience as you can have. Not surprised the line is sometimes out the door. AH has a new gem.
… moreThomas Nickel
What an absolutely creamy goodness delight!! Everything we tried and had was so fresh and delicious. My son selected a cotton candy style ice cream and it surprisingly tasted like being at the county fair! The long was long, but worth the wait!!!
… moreMatthew PT Casserly
Cash only here yet nothing but friendly staff! Ordered the peanut butter whiskey ice cream and let me just say it was delectable with great hints of whiskey! Will definitely return here!
… more