Nick Hartwell
We had ordered the Italian beef calzone and realized we got subs instead. They were super friendly and offered to make us fresh calzones – and keep the sandwiches. Everything was delicious. This level of customer care is rare these days!
… moreHose bose
$5 Lunch Special is phenomenal. Drive Thru and online ordering is uner convenient.
I’ve also ordered their pizza, cheesy sticks, toasted ravioli (try the buffalo chicken stuffed one with ranch), calzone, salads, and cinnamon sticks. The only one I wouldn’t recommend was calzone, just get it as a pizza, when they cut it open liquid comes out and the canzone had some too soggy crust.
Please make a homemade ranch, the packets suck and I’ve had a friend bully us into expensive quatros bc of ranch…they were kinda right.
… moredebra travelstead
Order was placed. Food was delivered quickly and was hot when arrived. Person taking order and delivery driver were very nice. Pizza was awesome supreme is loaded down. So good. The Philly cheesesteak is outstanding! My personal favorite. Just one of the best around here.
… moreCatherine Lewis
I called and ordered over the phone for dinner for four. We ordered cheese sticks, which was the right balance of cheese and crust! We also ordered a thin crust, which was crispy and thin, with the right amount of cheese and sauce.
Lately, the other competitors have skimmed back on the ingredients. So far this place is fast, hot and good. My family enjoyed the pizza, and we had no lovers! The guy taking the order had trouble hearing me but stayed professional and polite. We worked through it! Would recommend.
… moreLatoyah Gates
We ordered dinner here and it was nice and good. I like the art work and pizza the lady that took my order was nice.
… moreTim Carter
An excellent addition to the Carbondale experience. Quality ingredients, commitment to high quality food. Fantastic pizza. And you can’t beat the 11:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. deal. A massive slice of pizza, a can of soda, $5 out the door. Tax included. Whether you’re going to stop by for lunch or have something delivered for dinner or something else in between, you won’t be disappointed. Did I mention they have a drive-thru? They do!!
… moreMelvin C
Drive through, carry out, delivery. Went inside and was greeted by a friendly person at the counter. Ordered Chicken spinach calzone. It was made fresh and quick. You can watch them make and bake your order. It had awesome flavor. The customer area is small with two benches to sit on while waiting. I will return.
… moreabdulrahman abulkhair
Ordered a large pizza, meatball sub and a chicken Parmesan sub, and it was fantastic. It’s some of the best food I’ve ever had. You guys are gonna give the rest of the pizza spots in Carbondale a run for their money. From now on I’m not ordering from anywhere else. I would highly recommend Newby’s Pizza 5/5
… moreJanet Trader
We normally loved their pizza but the last 2 pizzas have not been cooked in the middle. The crust is doughy and chewy on a thin crust pizza. The topping are sliding off when you try and bite into a piece. We called to let them know the issue and they said ‘ok’. A little disappointed.
… moreariel lanier
Ordered for the first time for delivery I had never had pizza from this place before but my husband insisted it was great. Got a pizza a apple cinnamon dessert pizza some fried raviolis along with a pasta and a calzone. Everything was amazing but the dessert pizza was my absolute favorite and I will not be able to live without it. Will be ordering from these guys again soon thank you guys for the amazing food.
… more