New York Pizzeria

Order online at one of the best restaurants in Calimesa, CA! New York Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …

Order New York Pizzaria – Calimesa, CA Menu Delivery … – DoorDash

Get delivery or takeout from New York Pizzaria at 546 Myrtlewood Drive in Calimesa. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …

Last Updates

Reviews

Lynda Huston, Adams

Unfortunately, I put my review for New York Pizza under
A&W. So most of my review is there for New York Pizza. New York pizzas food was delicious. Then went down hill when it was sold. With the exception of Laura. She is a wonderful person & is pretty much the bright star there now . I am going back lately. But I always
ask for an extra side topping . I ask for extra sauce & cheese. There aren’t many choices. Of places to eat around here. I always add an extra layer

… more

Shiro “CuteNekoHere” Neko

Orderd a pepperoni pizza with a lasagna and breadsticks, came about to 32 bucks. Staff was super friendly too. Place is really clean but its pretty old style, color and mood of the place is like a haunted house from the 90’s.

1. Pizza was fluffy and balanced well with a nice cheese to sauce ratio (as seen in picture)

2. Lasagna was ok but honestly bigger portions than other places.

3. Garlic bread wasn’t too oily but dry enough to eat and was pretty tasty.

Would come again just for the pizza.

… more

Felicia Iturralde

Came for my son’s soccer party. I order two meals both which included a salad. The lady called our number there were two salads on the tray. I was surprised at be of the salads but thought nothing of it. About ten minutes later after we already started eating the lady starts to yell at my husband that he grabbed the wrong tray and those salads were for someone else. My husband, and the guys whose salad it actually was both stated she called our number. She continued to yell and then kept making comments to other people getting their order “watch out someone might take your food.” Mind you those customer were also part of our group. I would have said the food was good but I am pretty sure she got angry and held our food back, so our mozzarella sticks were cold and the jalepeno poppers were soggy. This could have been handled so much better. We will not be returning.

… more

Ghoul Von Horror

My fiancé told me he’s been going here since he was a child so I thought I had to try the pizza. He did warn me it’s a little run down. He wasn’t lying. You place your food at the counter and pick it up there too. Paper plates and plastic fork & knife. Pizza was delicious. It was on the expensive side though – 2 medium 2 toppings pizza was $30, but it’s California so I guess that’s pretty normal for the area. Seats are not comfortable. Eat fast and go.

… more

Sarah M.

Food had fairly good flavor. Good bread and calzone, but dinners tasted like Stouffers at best. Previously, we ordered pizza for delivery and was quite good, but had never visited the restaurant in-person before today…whew! What a dirty dive. Filthy walls and doors and floors and glass. Interior of restaurant in terrible condition, and unappealing exterior. So dirty that I couldn’t imagine eating the food in future. I can only picture what the kitchen looks like. Certainly, you can reinvest in your customers, NY Pizzeria, by giving them a cleaner environment in which to dine.

… more

E M

I do not recommend. Pizza dough had no flavor. My pizza was wet/soggy. Sauce appeared to be watered down as it has no flavor. Pepperoni was not crispy or fully cooked. Veggies and pepperoni were on the dough and then the cheese in top. Salad was drenched in ranch dressing. I had to go get my pizza from the counter and fresh out of the oven. I was told to be careful because it was hot and that I should use napkins or something to carry it because tray was still very hot. I would never go back here unless it was confirmed that there’s new management and new ways of cooking a better quality pizza. I have a pizza oven at home and my pizza is way more delicious than this. I went because a while back I was told that it was very good.

… more

Daniel

Stopped in out of the blue. I was in the mood for a salad and sandwich . I got the salami sandwich.my wife got the turkey sandwich. We shared a huge antipasto salad. Everything was fresh and delicious. We’ll be back to try other . I had a very good interaction with the staff they were polite and gracious. I’ve since return several times and each time was the same with respect to the professionalism.

… more

Isac Garcia

Got the Calimesa Family deal. Not disappointed reminded me of back when I was a kid and my dad would pick up pizza / Chicken and a Movie on a Friday night little hiccup with the delivery, Maybe drivers should be advised to check the address on the receipt upon arrival. Don’t trust the internet lol overall satisfied.

… more

Allison Hewitt

You literally have to pay extra just to pick up your own order. Let that sink in. Customer service? Absolute trash. The food that used to be amazing is now overpriced and mediocre at best. They’ve managed to kill the only two things that made them worth going to—quality and value. Don’t waste your money here unless you enjoy being ripped off with a side of attitude.

… more

Elizabeth Cho

Best Pizza Ever!!!! This place is so good, kids love their spaghetti, I love the pizza. The Calimesa special is big and not bad for the price. The workers are always friendly and helpful. I miss being able to sit in n eat the pizza fresh but for now I still order it pick it up and take it home. This place has not disappointed me and we’ve been coming here for years. Great Pizza, Great Price and Great Service. Five Stars Well Deserved.

… more

… View more

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Related Web Results