Guin Geyer
If you’re looking for authentic, flavorful Italian comfort food in Norman, New York Pizza & Pasta absolutely delivers. From the moment you walk in, you’re welcomed with friendly service and that classic aroma of fresh-baked pizza and simmering sauce that instantly feels like home.
The pizza crust is perfectly balanced — crisp on the outside, soft and chewy inside — just the way a true New York-style slice should be. The sauce is rich and well-seasoned, and the toppings are fresh and generous without overwhelming the pie. Their pasta dishes are equally impressive, with hearty portions and sauces that taste like they’ve been perfected over generations.
What truly sets them apart is consistency and hospitality. Whether you’re dining in with family, grabbing a quick lunch, or picking up dinner after a long day, the quality never wavers.
Norman is blessed with some great local spots, and New York Pizza & Pasta is definitely one worth supporting. It’s the kind of place you return to again and again — and proudly recommend to friends.
Highly recommend!
… moreSabina Johnson
Excellent food and service. It was exactly what I was craving. Totally authentic and delicious!! Great lunch specials also! You got to try them out. All the employees were really nice too! Definitely coming back!!!
… moreMacey Miller
On campus corner so it is busy, but delicious pizza by the slice!
… moreL
The food is very average. It’s not gross but for the price the quality doesn’t match up. I’d definitely go somewhere else for much better quality and taste for the same price like Marcos.
The pizza reminds me of school cafeteria pizza for looks and taste. It’s very bland and leaves your mouth feeling oily after you eat it.
The garlic knot bread was fried and you could also taste the oil. Super disappointed with that since garlic bread is my favorite.
The salad was honestly very good I don’t know why they don’t use that same cheese quality on the pizza.
For six dollars you get one chocolate cannoli which isn’t great for the price considering the size. It felt overly sweet.
Honestly, I really wanted to like this place. All the reviews were glowing and very positive but my experience was disappointing. I really hope their quality goes up. But I won’t recommend this place to friends.
… moreWilliam Foreman
A classic college pizza joint, just steps away from the University of Oklahoma campus. I ordered a veggie pizza and enjoyed the thin crispy crust. The toppings were generous. I also got a garden salad that was also good. Sinatra was playing, and a Germany-Latvia youth hockey game was on one of the TVs on the wall.
… moreHanna Foreman
Classic college pizza joint right off OU campus. The service was quick and the food came out hot. I ordered the house salad that was mostly chopped romaine lettuce with small handfuls of tomato and red onion with a sour house dressing (could use some more salt and honey to balance it out). For the main dish, I ordered the veggie pizza which had a good cheese pull and could’ve used some more sauce. As a New Yorker, the pizza crust was a little too thick for me. I can tell this spot is fun during game days with all the tvs and drink deals posted all around the restaurant. Stop in for college pizza if you have a hankering.
… moreErika
I placed my order online at 11:50, received a text saying they’re busy so it’d be ready for pickup between 12:06-12:21, on the way over I received a phone call saying they closed five minutes ago & how much longer will I be. It was a little past 1200 but the hours posted online says they’re open till 0200. Your employees and customers will be happier if hours online reflect actual business hours. It was also upsetting to pay $4 to add shrimp to my pizza especially when I only received 4 shrimp & they were salty. For the most part, the food is generally good but customer service could use some work. Please update your hours.
… moreJasen Castillo
Staff make you feel at home! Really good people. Food is delicious. My favorite place if I want top notch good quality pizza. Drink specials cant be beat and just a cool hang!
… moreTimothy Hudson
You cannot walk 100 feet in any direction in Manhattan without walking past a pizza shop. It is incredibly rare to find a New York style pizza shop that sells pizza by the slice. And in Oklahoma of all places! Stop in to New York Pizza & Pasta today.
… moreQueena Jordan/Barner
This was the first time I’ve ever been here or even heard of it. I’ve always wanted to try some real NY style pizza and man this is truly the best pizza in Oklahoma. The owner is from the Bronx and the style of the shop looks like something from New York. The pizza is really to die for and made fresh n hot. They also have some New York soda and a bar inside also. Location is perfect for business and just a nice vibe all around, I will for sure be back.
… more