Hours
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday (Labor Day) | 10:30 AM–9 PM Hours might differ |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1811 Golden Eagle Way #25, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Phone: (904) 579-3488
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza in Fleming Island – New York Pizza
Local Family owned New York style pizzeria located across from the Fleming Island High School. Voted best pizza in Fleming Island – New York Pizza.
Menu – Pizza in Fleming Island – New York Pizza
All Pizzas & Wings Are Made To Order. 14″ Cheese Pizza & 10 Jumbo Style Wings … (2) – 18″ Cheese Pizzas, 40 Jumbo Style Wings, Large House Salad, …
Online Menu of New York Pizza, Fleming Island, FL – MenuPix
View the menu for New York Pizza and restaurants in Fleming Island, FL. See restaurant menus, reviews, ratings, phone number, address, hours, …
Reviews
Donnell Wyatt
This was my first time trying this place. The lunch special was expensive, $10.74 for 2 slices and a drink. Sadly, it wasn’t good. I had the works and the chic fil a pizza slices. To be honest, I have had frozen pizza that tastes better than this. The only plus was the convenient location. I honestly cannot return to this place again. The dining room is also used for store near the back. Don’t know why this is the case, since they have another storage space next door. Their food quality really needs to be improved. Right now, their pricing has surpassed their quality.
… moreAllison Moore
My family and I ate here the other day and I wasn’t very impressed. Pizza was just ok, a little tough. The kind you have to rip apart rather than it tear apart. A little soggy /floppy in the middle too. The wings had good flavor but were definitely overcooked. The salad wasn’t great but not the worst I’ve ever had. We got a garden salad, which was just iceburg, black ilives, tomatoes, red onion and croutons. The ranch tasted like it was Hidden Valley, which I’m not a fan of. They only do bottled drinks and charge $1.99 for a bottle of Aquafina water, not a big bottle either. The drinks, straight out of the fridge, weren’t very cold and they don’t have an ice machine or cups. Coukd have used a few more plates. They only gave us 5 plates for 5 of us to share a salad, pizza, wings and garlic bread and they’re the cheapest paper, bending, leak through the bottom kind of plates.
… moreDesiree R.
Amazing pizza. New to the area and so happy we found this place. Thin crust NY pizza at its finest.
… moreMark Goldwich
First time in today. Got a lunch combo (cheese slice, side salad, fountain drink) for about $8.50. Thin NY style pizza, not floppy, and a good sized salad. The pizza was good, but not my favorite. I think I enjoyed the salad more. AC was out, so that didn’t help. I’d try it again.
… moreHOYA LEE
We ate buffalo chicken fries and Chick fil A. Chick fil A Pizza was not salty.
… moreBryan Anderson
Best pizza and wings by far!! I’ve been ordering from here for years, they know me by name that’s how much I order from them!! Highly recommend, you won’t be disappointed!
… moreHeidi Steele
Delivery was cold and greasy. Couldn’t even eat what was called garlic bread. Don’t recommend this if you truly want fresh, hot and taste worthy NY style pizza.
… moreJames Davitt
First time eating here and I went based on the reviews. It was a bit of a drive for us but I have to say definitely worth it. I was born and raised in NY and the pizza is very close. So fresh and greasy and fabulous. Absolutely going back
… moreFrank Martinez
Superb pizzas in an attractive setting with outdoor seating in the back.
… moreTim Johnson
They set up the outback chairs and tables and even gave my dog a bowl of water! Was aweso.e, even when we got rained on! It was an experience I will never forget!
… more