Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 18406 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32820
Phone: (321) 804-4191
Website: https://nypizzaco.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
New York Pizza Company – Authentic Taste with Every Bite
Welcome to New York Pizza Company, conveniently located inside the Mobil Gas Station at 18406 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32820. Proudly serving East Orlando …
Home | New York Pizza Company
New York Pizza Company features a warm atmosphere, courteous staff and an extensive Italian menu centered around delicious authentic New York style pizza.
New York Pizza Company | Orlando FL – Facebook
New York Pizza Company · Personal details · Details · Links · Contact info. . (321) 804-4191. . [email protected]. Photos. See all. Posts. New York …
Last Updates
Reviews
Kevin Johnson
Hate to leave this review but don’t waste your money. Set a delivery time for 7:30 because my son has baseball and it showed up at 6. That’s the start. Garlic knots were burnt and had NO SAUCE. THEN they say ” well best I can do is give you 10 % off your next order “. You can keep your 10% and shove it.
… moreroseanna bynaker
⸻
Amazing experience! The food was delicious, and watching the pizza being hand-tossed in front of us was so fun—my grandchildren loved it. The staff was incredibly friendly, the atmosphere was wonderful, and even the owner took time to chat and make us feel welcome. It truly felt like being among friends. We’ll definitely be back!
… moreAmazing experience! The food was delicious, and watching the pizza being hand-tossed in front of us was so fun—my grandchildren loved it. The staff was incredibly friendly, the atmosphere was wonderful, and even the owner took time to chat and make us feel welcome. It truly felt like being among friends. We’ll definitely be back!
Rosamaria Blue
First time here actually googled pizza near by and I was confused because it’s in a gas station but don’t let that fool you the food was very good pizza was very yummy . My daughter enjoyed her wings . If you are near by definitely stop by the staff was super friendly . Sorry my photo we already started to eat but I wanted to get a photo of what we got
… morecarlos rivera
Sorry team, this is NOT a five star pizza place..the dough was thick NOT thin like New York style pizza..I ordered 6 wings , asked for the Buffalo sauce in a separate container but they were served mixed together there was more oil than buffalo sauce. The weird thing was they smelled great but didn’t have much of a buffalo taste to them LOL. Also at 1.80 a wing it’s not a great deal..I read all the five star reviews and tried it out but after dropping 30.00 on a pepperoni pizza and six wings I’ll pass next time. Decent pizza considering its inside a Gas station, but sorry not five star like ALL the reviews in Google. Thank you I wish your business great success
… moreLisa
Serba’s pies are fire! Staff is always nice as well. I only gave atmosphere a 3 bc it’s in a Mobil gas station but don’t let that fool you – their food is great!
… moreJuan Esteban
Delicious just delicious… the service amazing and extremely friendly… what a nice people. When the say their pizza tastes like NYC style, they mean it. Gooooood quality!
… moreDragana Bubic
New York Style ✨️ Absolutely Thank you David for the excellent customer service on Halloween night! This pizza was the best I had in Florida! Definitely the treat❤️ no tricks, love it!
… moreGreg
Ignore the fact that it is inside a convenience store. The Pizza is great. Thin slice. Fold it and enjoy. The real test for me was whether it would be good leftover cold out of the fridge. Sure enough it was excellent. For what it is worth the store is clean and the pizza ovens and restaurant is visible and clean.
… moreCarlos Rosario
This place is in a gas station, but don’t be mistaken this is authentic delicious New York style pizza! Thin, crispy, flavorful this is my new favorite New York style pizza spot for quick eats.
… moreEddie D
I’m from NY and agree that this pizza is very good. Don’t let the gas station setting fool you, it’s legit great pizza. They use very good ingredients and the portions are satisfying. Prices are good too. The pizza maker was friendly and cooked the pizza immediately. Their white slice was one of the best I’ve ever had. Full of oh so good grande cheese. The best cheese you can use. I will definitely return .
… more