Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Unassuming counter-serve pizzeria offering slices on paper plates, plus salads & beer.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 409 E Hyman Ave, Aspen, CO 81611
Phone: (970) 920-3088
Website: http://www.nyp.pizza/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Beer & Pizza | New York Pizza
New York Pizza Aspen 409 E Hyman Ave Aspen, CO 81611. New York Pizza Basalt 400 E Valley Rd, Unit D Carbondale, CO 81623. New York Pizza Carbondale 901 Hwy …
NEW YORK PIZZA ASPEN-BASALT-CARBONDALE
Aspen Valley’s Best Pizza.
New York Pizza Aspen, Colorado – Facebook
. $. . Open now. . 409 E Hyman Ave, Aspen, CO, United States, 81611. Services. . Specialties. In-store pickup · Outdoor seating · Dine-in. Contact info.
Reviews
Sam Shahidi
Best pizza slice in Aspen! Tom at the counter is a vibe! Also they have the new Happy Dad Peach Tea
… morevatsal shah
Food that’ll make you sick. For $7 a slice, the basically reheat old pizza slices and give it to you in a box. Even their garlic bread came out of a plastic bag and went for a quick reheat in the oven with cheese on top.
For $25 we got 2 slices of bad tasting pizza and a store garlic bread. Only thing “New York” about this place is the thinness crust and the price of the slice. Would’ve been fine if the pizzas had any taste to it. Super disappointed as this was supposed to be our quick mid-day meal on an otherwise long drive from Denver
Skip and go to a real restaurant in Aspen even if it seem expensive.
… moreFor $25 we got 2 slices of bad tasting pizza and a store garlic bread. Only thing “New York” about this place is the thinness crust and the price of the slice. Would’ve been fine if the pizzas had any taste to it. Super disappointed as this was supposed to be our quick mid-day meal on an otherwise long drive from Denver
Skip and go to a real restaurant in Aspen even if it seem expensive.
Will G Marks III
I love New York Pizza it’s a must go to if you’re in Aspen and you like pizza. The front door is a little tricky if you have never been there the entrance is right next to The Green Dragon and you have to go up stairs to get to New York Pizza. The slices are huge and the pizza is always cooked to perfection and they serve local IPA’s and the staff is always in a good mood and there is usually some decent music playing. I like to sit by the window and watch the walking traffic while I eat.
… moreTony Scardina
We rode all the way in to New York pizza from Taylor Park trading post it was about 10 of us the food was great service outstanding the vibe everything from the music to the food top notch. If you’re looking for a real feeling of New York this is the place.
As you will see by the pictures attached but some of the video everything not only looks delicious but tasty originally from New York I feel like my opinion is more important than most.
Enjoy your pizza let them know that you read the review that Tony from Phoenix posted. Tom and Emily run an amazing restaurant.
… moreAs you will see by the pictures attached but some of the video everything not only looks delicious but tasty originally from New York I feel like my opinion is more important than most.
Enjoy your pizza let them know that you read the review that Tony from Phoenix posted. Tom and Emily run an amazing restaurant.
Jessica
This place has the worst customer service. The woman at the register was extremely rude, unorganized, and had a horrible, disgusting attitude. We accidentally took the wrong pizza slices, and instead of calmly fixing the mistake, she immediately yelled at us and accused us of taking food.
I told her to simply charge us for the slices or remove them from our order — a very simple solution. Instead, she continued yelling, called me “soft,” and said she would refund my food so I could leave. This was completely unnecessary and disrespectful.
For a town like Aspen, especially in what’s considered a higher-end area, this behavior is unacceptable. Mistakes happen, but the way this situation was handled was embarrassing and uncomfortable. I would not recommend this place based on customer service alone. The food is also not as good as people claim it is.
… moreI told her to simply charge us for the slices or remove them from our order — a very simple solution. Instead, she continued yelling, called me “soft,” and said she would refund my food so I could leave. This was completely unnecessary and disrespectful.
For a town like Aspen, especially in what’s considered a higher-end area, this behavior is unacceptable. Mistakes happen, but the way this situation was handled was embarrassing and uncomfortable. I would not recommend this place based on customer service alone. The food is also not as good as people claim it is.
David Brewitz
Great pizza at a great location. Stop by anytime and take care of that pizza craving, served by great people.
… moremuralidhar yadav
Run by a couple, very helpful and they were ready to customize, overall we enjoyed pizzas
… moreMariela R. Callaway
New York Pizza in Aspen deserves a solid 5-star rating! From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. This is not a fancy place; it’s super chill and casual, which only adds to its charm. The pizza slice was not only bigger than my head but also incredibly delicious. The flavor was spot-on, and it truly lived up to the New York pizza reputation. The atmosphere was fantastic, with great music and a cozy ambiance that made it the perfect spot to enjoy a slice. Service was impressively fast, ensuring that I didn’t have to wait long to satisfy my pizza craving. I also couldn’t resist trying the buffalo wings, and they were equally great. If you’re in Aspen and craving a taste of New York-style pizza in a laid-back and casual setting, this is the place to go.
… moreDavid Shusterman
Great pizza place and it’s open late night huge pie. The only issue is it’s on the second floor, which is not a big issue but you’ll have to climb the stairs. But the food is great. It’s worth getting there. It’s a small little sign though so it’s gonna be kind of a little bit hard to find, but you’ll be able to find it.
… moreCharlesTexian
Staff and Pizza are the best in Aspen! Grab a slice and sit outside.
… more