New York Pizza

  4.1 – 428 reviews   • Pizza restaurant

Social Profile:

New York Pizza, a haven for pizza connoisseurs, awaits your visit at 117 Maryport Drive in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. Experience the artistry of our authentic pizzas, meticulously prepared with the freshest ingredients. Each slice is a testament to our dedication to crafting culinary masterpieces that tantalize taste buds and transport you to the bustling streets of New York City. Dive into a slice of happiness at New York Pizza, the go-to spot for pizza lovers seeking an extraordinary dining experience.

✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery New York Pizza 29575

Address and Contact Information

Address: 117 Maryport Dr, Myrtle Beach, SC 29575

Phone: (843) 492-5999

Website: http://newyorkpizzamb.com/

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Order: Order online

newyorkpizzamb.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

New York Pizza – Myrtle Beach, SC – 117 Maryport Dr

Experience the authentic taste of New York Pizza in Myrtle Beach! Enjoy thin, crispy crusts, fresh toppings, and the bold flavors of classic NY-style pizza.

NY Pizza Kitchen Bar & Grill – Myrtle Beach, SC

Discover a new favorite by trying the top pizzas in Myrtle Beach. NY Pizza Kitchen Bar & Grill is one of Myrtle Beach’s most popular. Give them a try, …

New York Pizza – Myrtle Beach, SC – 117 Maryport Dr – Hours, Menu …

View the menu, hours, address, and photos for New York Pizza in Myrtle Beach, SC. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.

Reviews

Kim Carraway
Stopped here after church today. Open light on but front doors locked. No meat, no veggies to add to anything you pick. Overpriced pizza that really doesn’t taste good. $17.99 for a cheese pizza— seriously? You’d think it would at least have some flavor. Looks like mine will be goose food. Skip this place. Lesson learned. Will NOT eat here again.
… more
Kimberly
This was a horrible experience. First, we could not get in because the door was locked and we were told to come back in 10 minutes (not sure why). We were doing take out so I called my order in. Got home and realized after spending $65 we did not get our garlic knots, the wings might look like they have sauce but they were dry and tasteless and that blob of bread and cheese is what they call a calzone (that is not what a calzone is supposed to be). The knots did not exist and the wings and the calzone were not edible. Horrible experience, avoid wasting your time and money.
… more
kirby smith
We discovered New York Pizza last year. We were there near closing. The owner was so nice. The staff were super nice also! The pizza is awesome! Love supporting local business.
… more
Richard Parris
Ordered a supreme pizza to go on Friday and it was delicious! Fresh peppers and onion chunks! It had shredded cheese as well as mozzarella balls. Maybe could have used a few more pepperoni pieces for the price, but overall it was very good pizza.
… more
Alyssa Gallant
Beautiful place to eat at, great service, the lady that took my order when I was there was so sweet and so helpful, I had the meat lovers pizza it was so yummy cooked just right. I’m from New York and I can say this is real New York pizza. They do get busy so it might be a little wait but yall are waiting for good pizza. Trust me BEST PIZZA YOU’LL EVER HAVE.
… more
travis mays
I have been walking past this place the last 5 years and that was a mistake. This is hands down the best pizza I’ve had in over 10 years. The pizza was perfect and the owner was very genuine and generous. I will definitely be back.
… more
Bohdan Banasky
This place was awesome! Just the right ratio of cheese and sauce! The chicken was seasoned awesomely, the guy here, Benny, recommended to get the Buffalo chicken Pizza and man was it delicious. If we visit Myrtle Beach we would definitely come here again!
… more
Robin Peiper (Robin Sue)
As a native New Yorker I have found that this pizza comes with a side of attitude. For me to say that You must know it’s bad.

The first time I came here, I walked in and they were very rude and told me that they weren’t ready to serve people yet. Now, about a month later, I walked in to find one worker who didn’t know how to break a smile or treat a customer. Not a good thing for a tourist area.

The pizza did not have enough sauce and was heated only to lukewarm. The garlic powder they offer is solid as a rock. I guess they haven’t figured out the humidity Here is not going to work very well leaving a big container on the table open

If you order online versus coming in the store, expect to pay about 15% more

EDIT: 8-24-25 – I went back to see if it got better. It didn’t. The sauce to cheese ratio is off. The slices are small and are $4. I won’t be back a third time.
… more
Ms Kay Leon
I’m so Happy to have a Ny!! By the slice PIZZA!! I’m a Native New Yorker who has been living in the Carolinas for almost 27 years!
I’m a hands down Pepperoni Crispy Slice Woman and this did not disappoint! To be completely honest maybe a tad thicker than most Ny Slices that is not a bad thing and definitely smaller sized slice..BUT THE TASTE WAS GREAT! The Owner was so nice! Gave me that crispy crunch perfect char on the bottom! Perfect! The two slice special with a drink was a good tasty and plentiful bite. Man I’m ecstatic to have this option here in Myrtle! Way to go guys Thank you so much for bringing some of my original Home here to my Beloved New Homestead The Carolina’s❤️ Myrtle Beach come on through and give these delicious bites a try! I haven’t had that crunch and flavor in a while I’m one satisfied lady! See you soon I’ll be back!
… more
A K
That is some very mid pizza for over 20$ ive had way better and more for less money. You are better off driving 5-10 minutes down the road to the many other choices for pizza. They need to make a serious price adjustment for what they are offering.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment