Jennifer Follo
While in Ocean City for the week, our family wanted to have a special bagels and lox brunch. We looked up “Best Bagels” snd found this New York Cafe. Seeing the bagels, lox and toppings platter and we thought we’d give it a try. It was a great move! The platter was full of everything you could want on your bagel and plenty of it! The bagels were delicious too, big and chewy like in NYC! Everyone was impressed and full! Five stars plus for New York Cafe, we’ll be back again!
… morePatrick Giesecke
We came here for lunch a few days ago for lunch. I got an order of the mozzarella sticks and the Prosciutto with Sweet Soppressata (panini) while my gf got the Veggie Panini.
The mozzarella sticks were good though I felt the breading was. About thick and/or they were overcooked. The accompanying sauce was great — a bit sweet with large chunks of tomato. The Prosciutto with Sweet Soppressata was delectable. The meat was very fresh and provolone perfectly melted. In hindsight, I’d have added some onions and tomatoes to cut through all the rich fat on the meats and cheeses but it was still one of the best meals I had while in OC for the long weekend.
My gf loved the Veggie Panini (and told me so no fewer than 3 times while we were eating, along with notifying me we would be stopping here on our way out for another Veggie Panini to-go for our trip home). All in all, the place seemed well run and clean and other guests were audibly enjoying their orders as well. Will def come back to try some more of the very large menu.
… moreNelson Family
After reading the many terrible reviews of this place, we came here just to see how bad it was. Much to our surprise, it was great! Best bagels in town!
… morescott h.
Best bagels in Ocean City. I order a toasted garlic bagel with scallion cream cheese, turkey, swiss cheese, cucumbers and red onion. The best!! We come here at least once for breakfast every trip. Service is always great. A favorite.
… moreTaylor Clapps
Came here for a quick bite to eat. Breakfast sandwiches were made to order and coffee was good. The service was great! Support local businesses and try it out.
… moreJerry Thomas
No longer at this location. It is now Blue Cactus Mexican restaurant
… moreJerry Gordon
THE WORST EXPERIENCE EVER!!!! My daughter ordered 2 plain bagels online and paid for them. We went to get them and were told to come back in 30 minutes. Fine, no problem. We drove around and came back and were told “Go talk to the owner”. The owner told her if she wants it now she can have it raw.
Unbelievable. I was in the grocery business for 50 years and would have bent over backwards to satisfy a customer. DO NOT SUPPORT THIS BUSINESS!! Unworthy of hard earned dollars.
I am only giving 1 star because the review needs a star to be posted.
… moreDavid N Miller
Very good breakfast sandwiches.
Bought 2 dozen bagels to bring home. Bagels are very good!!
… moreAlyssa R
I was looking for a place that served lox and bagels. I called and spoke to a very polite girl that assured me she had what I was looking for. When we arrived, the place was clean, friendly, not crowded, and the food…. OUTSTANDING! The bagel and fish looked and tasted fresh and delicious. They won me over. We will be back for sure! Simply amazing. Ps.. not sure who the girl is that answered the phone and took our order but she obviously knows the food and business well. She was so incredibly sweet. I hope the owner knows she’s a rare find of an employee. Great impressions!
… moreGianfranco Illiano
Delicious food and fantastic service! Very friendly staff. I had the grilled chicken panini with provolone, spinach, and roasted peppers, along with a strawberry banana smoothie. Will definitely return!
… more