4.6 – 437 reviews $ • Ice cream shop
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reviews
Lenore Campbell
Cash only ice cream shop. Serves homemade ice cream. REALLY tasty. I had chocolate in a cone and my friend had butter pecan in a waffle cone. YUM. Perfect place to stop for ice cream after mini golf or to stop as you’re driving by. Will definitely stop next time I’m out this way.
… moreMichael Courtright
End of season, diminished variety, but fantastic! Heath bar and butter pecan yogurt flurry was amazing.
We’ll be back next season!
… moreJohn Moledor
The ice cream is good and every interaction with the owner I have had has been above my expectations. He is always overly nice and that is something that is increasingly rare these days. I even once saw him give ice cream to someone without cash. Please visit the locally owned business and enjoy!
… moreKimra Bell
We live about 45-60 minutes away, but we put New Baltimore Ice Cream on our summer bucket list year after year. Great place, delicious ice cream, friendly staff. This time I got mint Oreo – so good!
… moreHoward Hildebrand
We love the ice cream. The frozen yogurt flavors are so good. The butter pecan is amazing.
… moreJeff McKee
Great ice cream but the mint chocolate chip was a let down. Very very skimpy on the chocolate chips. You can do better than that New Baltimore!
… moreDavid Valentine
Friendly staff great ice cream, Mini golf course behind store.
… moreChristy Burmeister
They have the best ice cream! Been going to the new Baltimore location since I was a child, 40 years! Yum.
… moreChad
We waited 30 minutes today to get our ice cream, while multiple people that ordered after us got their order. Also, there was a significant discrepancy in the amount of ice cream given out for the same sizes.
… moreShari
Good service. Ice cream is medicore. Had small butter pecan on waffle cone. Cone was the best part. Ice cream had a freezer-burn taste and pecans were miniscule.
… more … View more