Steven R
The under new management banner they had caught my eye on my way to work. I decided to try it out for lunch. Let me tell you, the Big Mac pizza was the best pizza I have had in a very long time. Fresh food prepared perfectly. They are very friendly and a great atmosphere. It’s been a little over a month of coming here and i have to say they are very consistent. If you’re reading this review, give this place a try! Big Mac pizza for the win.
… moreChristine Reegzzz
We came here on a random night at a random time and had the most delicious Turkey club. Not only was the food great, but the staff was incredibly warm and made sure to make us feel right at home. The business is also veteran owned. Stop in and support a family runned small business and have a delicious meal. Can’t go wrong. Will be back.
… morecassandra cano
we ordered a large pepperoni and it was delicious! cute location and view, we’d come again 🙂
… moreBill McDevitt
Stopped in again today for a Nick Special to go. Tasty as ever !!!!The new owners are doing a great job!!! We had the”Nick” special that was a delicious pizza. Also had a veggie pizza that was flavorful. Both pizzas were mouthwatering, and the crusts were perfect 🙂
… moreLauren
I haven’t gone to Natalie’s in at least 7 years and they probably had their Old owner at that time this was a different owner she was so nice she gave us cups for our drinks they had glass plates real Forks and the pizza was delicious we got a broccoli mushroom black olive and the french fries they looked like they were hand cut
They also have daily specials we got a large cheese 3 topping for 24 dollars and they have fish and chips every day!
… moreserena bissanti
Every time my boyfriend and I order from Natalie’s, the food is absolutely amazing ! Super fresh & delicious.. we love the spaghetti & meatballs with garlic bread & their chicken bombs !
My boyfriend is a regular and the owner’s son will answer the phone and it’s so sweet I don’t even need a dessert!
… moreLauren D’Andrea
First off the owner is incredibly nice has the best temperament ever! Second the food is delicious got a chicken bacon ranch pizza the other day now I lovee piezonis but omg this pizza from Natalie’s was mouthwatering
… moreKeith Cabral
We absolutely love Natalie’s Pizza! We eat here often and are never disappointed. The pizza is always fresh, flavorful, and consistently delicious. The service is quick and friendly, and the staff makes you feel genuinely welcome every time. It’s clear they care about their customers. If you’re looking for great food and warm hospitality, Natalie’s is the spot!
… moreSue Bella
I ordered small cheese pizza, a Coney All the way, and eggplant Parm sandwich. The food was wonderful , best Coney I’ve ever had! Tons of Coney sauce. Will order here again. Wonderful owners . Sue
… moreCafe Zog
Today is the first time my wife and I tried Natalie‘s and we were not disappointed. We ordered a large pizza for Pick Up and we got home and we found that the serving toppings were very generous and fresh. We definitely will be coming back so glad to have a good pizza place in the neighborhood
… more