Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Naples Pizzeria – Roselle, NJ – 115 E 2nd Ave – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-10:00 PM; Shop address is 115 E 2nd Ave, Roselle, NJ 07203115 E 2nd Ave, Roselle, NJ 07203; (908) 241-4440.
Naples Pizzeria – 115 E 2nd Ave, Roselle, NJ 07203 – Slice
Naples Pizzeria · Naples Pizzeria – View Menu & Order Online – 115 E 2nd Ave, Roselle, NJ 07203 – Slice.
Naples Pizza | Roselle NJ – Facebook
CONGRATULATIONS to Naples Pizza in Roselle. WINNER of the 2025 Knights of Columbus Best Pizza Around Tasting & Competition!!!
Last Updates
Reviews
Armani Braud
Staff is chill, kind, and very patient. That’s important for someone as indecisive about food as I am. I only ever get the pizza and wings from here. It’s really good. I always order a custom version of a meat lover’s, and pretty much just add black olives and a ranch drizzle to the mix. When I’m feeling festive, we do a whole pizza: half meat lover’s, half buffalo chicken with ranch drizzled on top. They do so many cool customizations, and you can also buy by the slice, which I love. Their spicy garlic wings are to die for, and they leave the tips on the flats. 10/10
… moreJ B
Was looking for a local pizza shop. Checked out their reviews and was a little reluctant because they were so mixed.
Ordered a Grandma pizza…it was amazing!!!
Baked to perfection, sauce had the right amount of garlic and they sprinkle black pepper on the mozzarella which added a nice touch. Definitely going to order again. Thank you guys a delicious dinner!
… moreOrdered a Grandma pizza…it was amazing!!!
Baked to perfection, sauce had the right amount of garlic and they sprinkle black pepper on the mozzarella which added a nice touch. Definitely going to order again. Thank you guys a delicious dinner!
Joseph Eulo
DoorDash Pizza Diaries — Unfavorable Edition: Naples Pizza
Alright, I don’t like doing this—but honesty is the gig. If I deliver it, I try it. And sometimes… the slice just doesn’t show up ready for the audition.
Naples Pizza in Roselle was one of those stops where expectations were reasonable, not sky-high. Classic NJ pizza joint, right? Unfortunately, the pizza didn’t quite stick the landing.
The slice itself was heavy and limp, with a crust that felt more steamed than baked. No crisp, no structure—just a sad fold that gave up halfway to my mouth. The sauce was bland, like it forgot why it was there, and the cheese sat on top more like an obligation than a partnership. Nothing offensive flavor-wise, just… aggressively forgettable.
From a Dasher’s POV: orders were ready, but presentation and consistency felt rushed. This is the kind of pizza that fills a box but not the soul. The kind you eat because it’s there—not because you want to.
Look, I’ve had incredible mom-and-pop pizza all over New Jersey, and that’s the standard I hold spots to. Naples just didn’t meet it this time around.
Dash Verdict:
✔️ Edible
❌ Not memorable
❌ Not a slice I’d stop my dash for again
Maybe it was an off day—every kitchen has them. But as delivered and tasted? This one’s a pass for me.
On to the next stop.
… moreAlright, I don’t like doing this—but honesty is the gig. If I deliver it, I try it. And sometimes… the slice just doesn’t show up ready for the audition.
Naples Pizza in Roselle was one of those stops where expectations were reasonable, not sky-high. Classic NJ pizza joint, right? Unfortunately, the pizza didn’t quite stick the landing.
The slice itself was heavy and limp, with a crust that felt more steamed than baked. No crisp, no structure—just a sad fold that gave up halfway to my mouth. The sauce was bland, like it forgot why it was there, and the cheese sat on top more like an obligation than a partnership. Nothing offensive flavor-wise, just… aggressively forgettable.
From a Dasher’s POV: orders were ready, but presentation and consistency felt rushed. This is the kind of pizza that fills a box but not the soul. The kind you eat because it’s there—not because you want to.
Look, I’ve had incredible mom-and-pop pizza all over New Jersey, and that’s the standard I hold spots to. Naples just didn’t meet it this time around.
Dash Verdict:
✔️ Edible
❌ Not memorable
❌ Not a slice I’d stop my dash for again
Maybe it was an off day—every kitchen has them. But as delivered and tasted? This one’s a pass for me.
On to the next stop.
Jennifer
Excellent pizza, pasta, and garlic knots. I the buffalo chicken salad is ok. I’ll get it in a crunch, but it’s not my favorite menu item. I look forward to trying more menu item.
… moreN H
Ordered online and delivery took an hour. We ordered pizza with some sides and a 2 liter Sprite – instead we got orange Fanta. I said something to the delivery guy and he said, oh they were out. When I called the restaurant to double check I was told that all they had was Fanta (you ran out of sodas at 230PM on a Saturday??) and it wasn’t their policy to call to check to see what we would like instead. So I paid for something I didn’t get. Then I opened up the pizza and it looked terrible – I could’ve thrown some frozen broccoli on it myself and paid way less for the same thing. Definitely won’t be ordering from here again.
… moreClaire Serpenter
There was No tomato sauce inside whatsoever, the cheese is not stretchy, it looks like glue instead of cheese. I went there dozen of time but this time this one was simply not good . It doesn’t taste like pizza I don’t know what is going on but it was just not good at all.
… moreJenn Santiago
If you haven’t tried the Philly Cheese Steak from Naples Pizza, you’re missing out! The steak is cooked perfectly, its very well seasoned, the bread is nicely toasted. Everything just compliments each other perfectly. Super friendly staff and very clean location.
… morejoseph a colombo jr.
I’ve been living in roselle for 13 years never tried this place, till today, 7/13/25. I stopped in for the first time, pick up two slices to go. When I came home and tried the first slice, it didn’t flop down and it tasted very good, plenty of flavor. I’ll definitely be going back for sure. I just hope that the person that took care of me would be a little better in his approach of being more friendly.
… moreJay Jay
This has to be a sick joke! I ordered on UberEats – fried calamari, garlic knots, and penne vodka pasta. I order the same exact thing two days back to back – yesterday and today, Feb 21. Today my calamari looks disgusting; just thrown in a box, greasy, soggy, and undercooked. This is the LAST time I’ll be ordering from here. Also, keep your cut and paste response and fix your kitchen and food presentation. Ppl work too hard to spend money on mediocracy.
… moreSherly P
The people are nice overall. Today was just different, idk.
I can only guess, dont order lunch special at the last 4 mins? Or check box before you leave.
On the phone, he was really nice about it. I just called to see what the hours for lunch special was and he said I could still do it.
I came in, got the pizza.
I’ve had them in the past and they were good, even bought for whole family once. (I’ve only ever ordered lunch special 2 or 3 other times, so can’t speak for other foods)
Today tho…not good at all. Not sure what happened. I should have looked at it before I left but never had a bad experience before so didn’t bother. Crust was hard, cheese a lil dark (some people like that, but then it’d be ordered, dark, not come that way) but I thought thats fine. I don’t mind a lil color. But pizza itself was not crispy exactly, but chewy hard, and the bottom was dark.
I dont get to usually come except for days I’m off so kind of sad. But its ok I guess. Made the best of it. Maybe will try one more time next time cuz overall, they’re good and the people are nice.
Edit: I tried again and it was gooood and the ppl are nice. Everyone gas their off days. That pic was an off day.
Oh!! And I’ve been Sleeping on fried oreos. My brother bought some while we were getting wings and I tried the, A-friggin-Mazing!! so definitely try those if you’re here and you like those kind of desserts.
… moreI can only guess, dont order lunch special at the last 4 mins? Or check box before you leave.
On the phone, he was really nice about it. I just called to see what the hours for lunch special was and he said I could still do it.
I came in, got the pizza.
I’ve had them in the past and they were good, even bought for whole family once. (I’ve only ever ordered lunch special 2 or 3 other times, so can’t speak for other foods)
Today tho…not good at all. Not sure what happened. I should have looked at it before I left but never had a bad experience before so didn’t bother. Crust was hard, cheese a lil dark (some people like that, but then it’d be ordered, dark, not come that way) but I thought thats fine. I don’t mind a lil color. But pizza itself was not crispy exactly, but chewy hard, and the bottom was dark.
I dont get to usually come except for days I’m off so kind of sad. But its ok I guess. Made the best of it. Maybe will try one more time next time cuz overall, they’re good and the people are nice.
Edit: I tried again and it was gooood and the ppl are nice. Everyone gas their off days. That pic was an off day.
Oh!! And I’ve been Sleeping on fried oreos. My brother bought some while we were getting wings and I tried the, A-friggin-Mazing!! so definitely try those if you’re here and you like those kind of desserts.