Freestanding fast-food spot with outdoor seats for strawberry milkshakes, franks, nachos & pretzels.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 142 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
Phone: (269) 469-4240
Website: https://www.facebook.com/pages/category/Fast-Food-Restaurant/Nancys-at-the-Lake-114076175290548/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Nancys at the Lake | New Buffalo MI – Facebook
Nancys at the Lake, New Buffalo. 1066 likes · 6 talking about this · 267 were here. Ice Cream Shop.
Nancys: The Ultimate Ice Cream Destination in New Buffalo, MI
Nancy’s, located at 142 N Whittaker St in New Buffalo, MI, is a bustling hotspot known for its delectable ice cream specialties and mouthwatering comfort …
Nancy’s at the Lake (@nancysatthelake) · New Buffalo, MI – Instagram
141 Followers, 15 Following, 33 Posts – Nancy’s at the Lake (@nancysatthelake) on Instagram: “Walk-up & order ice cream & food restaurant in New Buffalo, …
Reviews
Abbey Metzger
Quick grab and go spot that was perfect for a lunch. The food variety is your typical fast food hot dog style but it was still pretty good. There were spots to sit on the side but we took our food to the beach. While we didnt get any ice cream, that seemed to be one of the top things people were ordering. If in the area and needed a quick lunch we would stop again.
… moreAndrew Renteria
The place was packed when we arrived at about lunch time. I got a chili dog and some cheese curds and the chili dog was delicious. The cheese curds were also super crunchy with a nice gooey inside and tasted fantastic with honey mustard. I didn’t have a chance to try their ice cream but it looked phenomenal.
… moreJennifer Munoz
Be prepared you may have to wait a bit as they are very, very busy. They have many ice cream specialties to choose from. We ordered two extra large french fries and an ice cream. Everything was served to us fresh and fast. There’s a great side area to sit and eat not far from Lake Michigan quick walk if you wanna go explore the beach.
… moreTony Davey
We came up here after new buffalo ⛱️ and this place is the place to be ! They have plenty of seating outside, and they have alot of flavors of Ice Cream, they also have awesome shakes ! Be prepared to wait ! Long lines but well worth the wait
… moreCourtney Scott
Great summer stop to grab whatever ice cream treat you want. Quick service, tastes great, and clean. Even color changing spoons!
… moreScott Ryan
Easy 5 stars. We stop at Nancy’s every single time we roll through New Buffalo — it’s basically the toll you happily pay before getting to Chicago. My go-to is the strawberry shake (elite, undefeated), but the kids love the ice cream and plenty of people come here strictly for the Chicago dogs.
Yeah, there’s usually a line… but it’s a beach town. Relax, enjoy the evening, and pretend you’re on vacation even if you’re just passing through. Great spot, great vibe, always worth the stop.
… moreYeah, there’s usually a line… but it’s a beach town. Relax, enjoy the evening, and pretend you’re on vacation even if you’re just passing through. Great spot, great vibe, always worth the stop.
Josh Taylor
Great food, great ice cream. Busy time of year I get it. If you have a line at 8:51. I feel like most businesses would love the business. Not turn away business to competitors and have 4 employees standing in line. Saying sorry we are closed. Could have very well taken our order before 9. But no , said “o well , said they do not care sorry.” Kids were dead set on ice cream our last day here.
… moreEmily Barker
Super disappointed. Stopped here because it was busy and seemed like it would be a tasty bite. Ordered a chocolate milkshake and received a vanilla milkshake made with chocolate syrup which was confusing considering they have chocolate ice cream, when I asked apparently they have two kinds of milkshakes and I was supposed to know to order with actually chocolate ice cream. Instead of just fixing it and giving me what I ordered they rather give me a refund which is fine even though I offered to pay the difference and I gave the drink back… I’ll grab one from somewhere with better customer service. Also, what is this mess!? Like I paid for this and this is how you give it to me. I should have gotten a refund on everything
… moreLarry Dungca
Overpriced food for a mediocre experience. Nancy’s is only seasonal because the locals are smart enough to stay away from this place. Since when is a near 6 inch beef sandwich by itself over $11.00. A small fry for $4.00! Their only redemption is the ice cream, shakes and Italian ice. It’s ok, but there are other shops in the area to fulfill your frozen sweets appetite.
… moreNick Donald
Ordered hot dogs, chili dogs, and fries. The fries seemed old and stale. The hot dogs were very skinny and overcooked or microwaved possibly? Guy that took my order was nice, but the food took way too long for this kind of food to be prepared. Im guessing their niche is ice cream but I was really hoping for a meal similar to the hot dog places we have in central Illinois. Also very overpriced for the quality.
… more