Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Snug waterfront counter serve for gourmet pies & slices & custom salads, with deck seating.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4036 S Virginia Dare Trail, Nags Head, NC 27959
Phone: (252) 715-3455
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Where to Eat | Nags Head Pizza Company
The best pizza in Nags Head with a view to match. Classic, vegan, and gluten free pizza offerings. Outdoor waterfront seating. Dine in, take out, …
Nags Head Pizza Company
The freshest pizza in the OBX! Dine in, take out, or delivery. Located in Kitty Hawk and Nags Head and serving Kill Devil Hills, Pirate’s Cove, …
Nags Head Pizza Company – Facebook
Nags Head Pizza Company, Nags Head. 9099 likes · 77 talking about this · 1239 were here. Pizza & salads for dine in, take out & delivery. We prepare…
Reviews
Tara Richardson
Nags Head Pizza Company was delicious! We called in for takeout during the weekend after Christmas, and the order was easy and quick. The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and really hit the spot after a long day. I believe they may be takeout only, though I’m not entirely sure. Either way, it’s a great option if you’re looking for good pizza in the area. Would definitely order again.
… moreLeeanna
Great pizza! Good combinations of toppings and flavors. Very nice staff!! Everything is take out or eat at the few picnic tables on the side. That’s OK, if you want to eat at a dirty table. … but the pizza was good and the staff was nice. We really didn’t know it was carry-out only. Cool positive encouragement on the boxes!!
… moreSydney Spaulding
Enjoyed this spot on a quick visit to Kitty Hawk. The two of us enjoyed the Endless Summer 16” pizza and were pleasantly surprised by the flavor combo. The tomatoes were perfectly ripe which is a gripe I often have with restaurant tomatoes. Would highly recommend! Also the leftovers microwaved perfectly
… moreCourtney Johnson
This is some of the best pizza I’ve had ANYWHERE. It’s DELICIOUS. The ingredients are fresh. They followed the takeout order instructions to the T. The crust is perfection, there’s a DELIGHTFUL pillowy doughiness, a light crisp. I can’t even tell you how wonderful this pizza is. I’ll dream of it. I recommend extra mozzarella cheese — the Milky Way + tomatoes + extra mozarella is everything you could ever want in a white pizza. Get this pizza immediately!
… morejason molidor
Prior to eating here I believed that Cosmo’s was the only genuinely decent pizza in OBX. I am really happy to see this spot doing well because it is a solid pizza spot with a ton of unique pies, and lots of great toppings for build your own options. Love that they have vegan cheese options and vegan pepperoni. Many beach towns on the east coast lack inf veggie and vegan choices. The pizza was quick, affordable, and the staff was superb. The pizza was cooked nicely (I personally prefer a little longer bake, but it was still good). The dough was just airy enough to be good. The undercarriage had a decent browning to it. The space was super cute. You order at a window. 5 picnic tables and some adirondack chairs outside. you could order in advance via the web and just pick up and eat outside. There was little back yard with cornhole set up. They had some beers and a really nice restroom. Absolutely ad this spot to your Nags Head list. (Remember it is the beach. In prime season it might get super busy, and temporary help might not be on point all the time, you’ll have to get over it if it isn’t perfect on a super busy day).
… moreJim M
Pizza was excellent. Service was friendly, helpful and very quick, especially with how busy they were.
No inside seating, but it was a beautiful evening and outside seating worked great. Prices were reasonable.
The cheese bread was excellent, and all 4 custom pizzas were exactly as ordered.
… moreNo inside seating, but it was a beautiful evening and outside seating worked great. Prices were reasonable.
The cheese bread was excellent, and all 4 custom pizzas were exactly as ordered.
Richard Noecker
The pizza was very good. It was super thin crust and thinly cheesed. It might have benefitted from being a little crisper. The “breadsticks” are basically just the pizza with no sauce.
I don’t think they have indoor seating, but you can order at the window and then eat in the outdoor area which has picnic tables. It is nicer than it sounds.
Also, the person taking the order will ask if you want to put a tip on the card. Don’t get me started on how stupid the concept of tipping is, but I always tip, but it is better to let the patron choose discreetly.
… moreI don’t think they have indoor seating, but you can order at the window and then eat in the outdoor area which has picnic tables. It is nicer than it sounds.
Also, the person taking the order will ask if you want to put a tip on the card. Don’t get me started on how stupid the concept of tipping is, but I always tip, but it is better to let the patron choose discreetly.
Ryan Carey
Easy to access location with outside seating available.
Ordered To Go! Reasonably priced.
A Milky Way Pizza and an order of Dippers.
The pizza was a tad greasy but overall a decent pie. Would have liked more Ricotta cheese provided the limited toppings and mozzarella base.
After trying the marinara sauce with the dippers, I would definitely suggest a pie with a pizza sauce base. This sauce was far superior to “American Pies” pizza. Cheese Sticks were better at American Pie however.
I’d put both pizza joints on par with each other and they are in relative close proximity.
… moreOrdered To Go! Reasonably priced.
A Milky Way Pizza and an order of Dippers.
The pizza was a tad greasy but overall a decent pie. Would have liked more Ricotta cheese provided the limited toppings and mozzarella base.
After trying the marinara sauce with the dippers, I would definitely suggest a pie with a pizza sauce base. This sauce was far superior to “American Pies” pizza. Cheese Sticks were better at American Pie however.
I’d put both pizza joints on par with each other and they are in relative close proximity.
Julia
This was one of the best pizza places I’ve been to in the OBX. It was so fresh, and overall delicious! I will definitely be coming here more often. Also, the girl at the counter was so kind. Also, the ROOT BEERS are fantastic. Definitely stop by if you’re in the area!
… moreRadha Lakshmi
Holidaying in Kitty Hawk with family! Young children hungry! We decided to stop at this Pizza place! No dine in but there were benches outside! It was a very hot day! We ordered several pizzas and beer! Service, food and atmosphere was really good! The pizza box has a handwritten motivational quotes. That was exceptional. Did i mention that they had an air conditioning bathroom! I recommend this place ❤️
… more