Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–2 PM, 4–7:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–2 PM, 4–7:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–2 PM, 4–7:30 PM |
| Saturday | 4–7:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–2 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 647 E Main St, Peru, IN 46970
Phone: (765) 473-3142
Website: http://www.mypizzamywayperu.com/?utm_source=gbp
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
My Pizza My Way – Peru, IN – 647 E Main St – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-2:00 PM; Shop address is 647 E Main St, Peru, IN 46970647 E Main St, Peru, IN 46970; (765) 473-3142 · order on the app we prefer.
My Pizza My Way – 647 E Main St, Peru, IN 46970 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Peru, IN! My Pizza My Way is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy your …
My Pizza My Way Delivery Menu | Order Online | 647 E Main St Peru
Order delivery or pickup from My Pizza My Way in Peru! View My Pizza My Way’s January 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with Grubhub!
Last Updates
Reviews
StarSeed
I love My Pizza My Way!!! It’s a smaller Mom and Pop restaurant but that’s what makes it soooo awesome. We like the deep dish pizza and the Hawaiian pizza is amazing as always. I had family visiting from New Mexico and they love the pizza from here, especially the Hawaiian. The owner is always nice and friendly. The atmosphere and decor is great. They got the business of the month as well, Great Job!!!
… morePatsy Howell
Loved it!
Had the pizza buffet for lunch. Excellent!
Salad bar was great! So was the pizza! They offered to bring out any kind of pizza we wanted. Employees kept checking to see if we needed anything. Only &10.00 for full buffet. Pizza, Subs, Bread sticks, Cheese Dip, Soup & drink were all included.
… moreHad the pizza buffet for lunch. Excellent!
Salad bar was great! So was the pizza! They offered to bring out any kind of pizza we wanted. Employees kept checking to see if we needed anything. Only &10.00 for full buffet. Pizza, Subs, Bread sticks, Cheese Dip, Soup & drink were all included.
Ruth McCarty
It is one of the few places left that is all-you-can-eat. It’s a pizza buffet, but also has hot dogs, salad, soup, bread sticks, dessert and your drink. They will bring out any kind of pizza you want. They give you the first one or two pieces and then put it out for everyone else. Tge food is hot and very tasty! The people are friendly, like family. It has tables for 4 or 6. It is very clean. Everyone carries their plates to the trash and puts their silverware in a bucket to be washed. The kitchen staff then washes the tables. It’s a very homey atmosphere and fun to eat there!
… moreMonica Rush
I ordered delivery through the app Slice. After waiting an hour after it was supposed to be delivered, the order was cancelled. I called the store and they said it was due to them running out of dough. Now what would have been nice is if they would’ve called either their partnered app service Slice to inform them of this situation upon my order, or even call me; that would’ve been more understandable. I could have made other arrangements for my family. But I had to call them to find this out instead. After my entire family were waiting, with littles near their bedtimes. I won’t ever be ordering from this establishment again. It could’ve gone a whole different way if they would have communicated to their customers.
… moreJackie Hall
My husband and I have definitely different ideas of favorite pizza so we ordered two different small pizzas this evening ( cheeseburger pizza and super supreme). They were both outstanding. Service was great. I’ve never had a bad pizza from this place!! The owner works so hard to keep everything wonderful for his customers and he’s super nice! Thanks for the great supper!!
… moreDenise Funston
We were looking for a place to dine that could accommodate family members with gluten and nut allergies—and we are so glad we found this gem! The staff and owner were incredibly kind, attentive, and knowledgeable about food allergies. They went above and beyond to ensure everyone felt safe and included, even surprising us with a special gluten-free dessert pizza.
Our only regret? That this place has been around for 15 years and this was our first visit—we’ve definitely been missing out! Rest assured, we’ll be back (often)!
… moreOur only regret? That this place has been around for 15 years and this was our first visit—we’ve definitely been missing out! Rest assured, we’ll be back (often)!
Terrence Jent
WOW! What a hidden gem in Peru! I’d give them 6 stars if I could. Went about 45 mins prior to closing and the food was all fresh and fantastic. They even asked the kids what kind of pizza they like and had one on the buffet shortly thereafter! Prices are fair, food was awesome (bread sticks and cheese were the family fav), service was welcoming and kind. We will absolutely be back!
… moreAl Popa
This staff here is extremely kind and thoughtful.
We will be returning here again, very satisfied with their service.
… moreWe will be returning here again, very satisfied with their service.
Daniel Burke VOH
I am not from this town and was visiting for the Renaissance fair this weekend. I stopped here because I saw it had a buffet. First, let me say 12 dollars for a buffet that includes salad/pizza and bread sticks/soup/even had a sandwich cut up…fantastic price and even included a drink. The woman I spoke to up front was polite and friendly and explained about the buffet, cost etc. I also had another staff member ask later how I was doing. Their pizza was delicious, the sauce to me had a hint of sweetness to it. The breasticks were awesome and one of my favorites I have had from a non major chain. Dip them in the broccoli cheese soup also, sooo good. If I lived in town I would be super excited because they also offer a punch card where your tenth buffet is free. If you have not tried them yet, do so. It is worth it both in cost and flavor. I would recommend this to everyone!
… moreFantasy & World Music by the Fiechters
I really enjoy this place! It has amazing lighthouse decor with other unique decor and the buffet is excellent. One of my favorite pizzas here is the chocolate peanut butter dessert pizza. I highly recommend coming here.
… more