Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–7 PM |
Related Web Results
Mustache Lilly’s Brick Oven Pizza | Hebron IN – Facebook
Mustache Lilly’s is calling out all Florida residents to Come try our delicious brick oven pizza ! We will be at location 4407 US Highway 301 N in Ellenton ,Fl …
Review of Mustache Lilly’s pizza in Hebron – Valparaiso – Facebook
If anyone is in Indiana. Check out Mustache Lilly’s Brick Oven Pizza!!! Wow he has an amazing set up!!! Check out his actual place and then he …
Mustache Lilly’s Brick Oven Pizza (@mustachelillysofficial) – Instagram
245 followers · 154 following · 4 posts · @mustachelillysofficial: “NWI Mustache Lilly’s Brick Oven Pizza is a family owned business that loves pizza done …
Reviews
Elena T
Farms, orchards food is always disappointing…but this pizza is the worst I ever bought…frozen pizza gas station pizza must be better then this one .I wouldn t feed it to the animals if I had any. Burnt, ZERO flavor and sooooooo sweet. How much sugar did you guys put in the tomatoes sauce? Cheese has no taste either not even burnt taste , how is that even possible I have no idea. Crust is tasteless and Burnt. Too bad probably nobody reads these reviews when they have only 2 or 3 options while on a farm, but maybe you seing this , will prompt you to check a little, we’ll hopefully more, the quality of your pizza.
… moreJen Leigh
This is My First time ever having Mustache Lilly’s Brick Oven Pizza and it was Truly Amazing!! The Mobil Food Truck came to my work to promote there business and we all got a promotional Pizza to try. It was Incredible!! From there Awesomely Unique truck which had an actual working Brick Oven in to the hard working lady’s who worked in the heat with a smile. Everything was absolutely perfection! The Pizza was Soooo Good!! I would Highly Recommend Mustache Lilly’s to anyone who wants an Delicious Authentic Brick Oven Pizza! You Won’t Be Dissapointed!!
… moreTim Jackson
I never leave reviews but this pizza was legitimately inedible. Like frozen pizza but worse. Brought 2 pizza’s home, took a bite of each, threw them away, ordered a pizza from a restaurant down the road. Feel scammed out of $40 for 2 10 inch pizzas by the “brick oven” marketing and cool truck buildout they did. The attendants were nice…
… moreJeff Hickman
I stopped by the Meijer today, and they were in the parking lot. Plenty of people were ordering. I ordered a combo, sausage, and pepperoni. 10″ is all they have. $20. It took about 10 minutes. That’s good. Now, the not so good. Bland pizza, really bland. Sauce bland. Toppings had little taste. I really wanted to like this, but I have to rate it as merely okay. For $20 for a 10″ is way overpriced.
… moreSusan Ingham
Had a lovely late lunch with my family, the pizza was delicious and the service was phenomenal! Make sure to save room for the homemade banana ice cream.
… moreCindy R
Experienced them at the county line orchard farm. Horrible service. Skipped my order and wasn’t even apologetic. Waited over 30 mins for a pizza and it ended up being soggy. It is also bland. $20 for 10inch pizza is way overpriced.
… moreM Capone
Tried for the first time at County line Orchard… $20 for a 9-10 inch pizza?!?! Way to rob people… It’s a $10-$12 pie at best… Not sure what they charge at the main location. Flavor was good… Little too spicy for kids… My granddaughter said her lips were on fire.
Update for 2025: Decided to try again at County line. The kid manning the brick oven needs to know what he’s doing. First pizza he somehow put too close to the fire and ended up folding my pizza and had to make a new one. Second attempt he burned it. No… It was not just the normal char.. He burned it but the bottom was not done hardly. Way too much wood and fire in the oven. As for the taste… Less spicy than previous year… Just overall not a great pizza. Sauce is bland, cheese isn’t high quality… Sausage has a strange consistency. Not sure why you wouldn’t use good quality sausage and cheese. If you’re going to do brick oven pizza and charge over $20 (think this year they raised it to $22-$24)…use quality toppings, add some fresh basil (it was on the pizza menu but scratched off and not available), little olive oil, little Pecorino Romano… Not too much to ask.
… moreUpdate for 2025: Decided to try again at County line. The kid manning the brick oven needs to know what he’s doing. First pizza he somehow put too close to the fire and ended up folding my pizza and had to make a new one. Second attempt he burned it. No… It was not just the normal char.. He burned it but the bottom was not done hardly. Way too much wood and fire in the oven. As for the taste… Less spicy than previous year… Just overall not a great pizza. Sauce is bland, cheese isn’t high quality… Sausage has a strange consistency. Not sure why you wouldn’t use good quality sausage and cheese. If you’re going to do brick oven pizza and charge over $20 (think this year they raised it to $22-$24)…use quality toppings, add some fresh basil (it was on the pizza menu but scratched off and not available), little olive oil, little Pecorino Romano… Not too much to ask.
Robert Mihalich
A great pizza fast and a cool place to eat. Could use a little more toppings but overall good. Only 1 size 10” enough for 1 person.
… moreAlexa C
THIS IS THE BEST PIZZA IN THE WORLD!!! If you want to constantly crave a food, it would be the bacon Mac n cheese pizza from Mustache Lilly’s Pizza. I am constantly talking about how good it is and how badly I want some. This pizza is 100% worth every penny and if I could I would eat it everyday for the rest of my life. Google only allows me to rate this out of 5 so I rate it 1000000000000000000000000000/5. Go eat here now!
… moreLindsey Mychal
Lovveee!!! Love their staff, so cute! This is extremely amazingly delicious. I stopped just an hour ago and got a sausage, pepperoni, garlic and black olive pizza… doesn’t sound like much but is sooooooo good!!! The sauce; the crust.. I’m kinda a pizza connoisseur and this holds up next to anything I’ve had honestly so good!!! Yum Yum Yum
Yummy lemonade too!!
… moreYummy lemonade too!!