Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Welcome to Mt. Sinai Bagel & Deli! Now under NEW MANAGEMENT, we are committed to serving the highest quality and freshness in Mt. Sinai. We continue the 20-year tradition of baking our bagels on-site in small batches throughout the day to ensure perfection. We now offer FREE DELIVERY on orders over $25! For your convenience, you can call or text our cell line: (631) 972 6170, for orders from 6:00 AM to 3:00 PMWhether you’re grabbing a quick bite on Route 25A or need professional catering for your office, come rediscover us. Forget the past; taste the difference in every bite!
Address and Contact Information
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Order Mt . Sinai bagel & deli corp – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Mt . Sinai bagel & deli corp at 5507 Nesconset Hwy Ste 14 in Mount Sinai. Order online and track your order live.
Mt. Sinai Bagel & Deli | Mount Sinai NY – Facebook
Mt. Sinai Bagel & Deli, Mount Sinai. 17 likes. Fresh bagels, premium coffee, and sandwiches under new management. Quality you can taste in every bite!
Mt. Sinai Bagel & Deli Corp Delivery Menu | Order Online | 5507 …
Order delivery or pickup from Mt. Sinai Bagel & Deli Corp in Mount Sinai! View Mt. Sinai Bagel & Deli Corp’s February 2026 deals and menus.
Last Updates
Reviews
Sal Sayed
Visited: Weekday
Wait time: No wait
Price per person: $10–20
Noise level: Quiet, easy to talk
Parking: Plenty of free parking (large lot)
Overall Experience
Mt. Sinai Bagel Cafe is a great new addition to the area and offers a very comfortable, clean, and welcoming experience. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted politely and felt genuinely welcomed.
Food Quality
The bagels were fresh, well made, and clearly baked with care. The standout for me was the everything bagel. What made it special is that the seasoning was on both sides of the bagel, not just the top. That alone made every bite consistently flavorful and memorable.
The cream cheese was excellent and well balanced. I tried both the veggie cream cheese and the jalapeño cream cheese, and both were delicious. The jalapeño cream cheese actually contained real jalapeño pieces, which added real flavor instead of just heat.
I also ordered an egg and cheese on an everything bagel, which was cooked properly, not messy, and nicely assembled.
Menu & Options
The menu is clearly written and easy to understand, with items labeled properly. There are breakfast sandwiches, spreads, deli options, drinks, freshly baked cookies, and a good selection of chips. Everything is presented cleanly and professionally.
Vegetarian options are clearly labeled and easy to identify on the menu.
Cleanliness & Atmosphere
The entire place was very clean, well maintained, and organized. The atmosphere was calm and comfortable, making it a pleasant spot to grab breakfast or coffee without feeling rushed or crowded.
Service
Customer service was excellent. The staff was polite, friendly, and professional throughout the visit, which made the experience even better.
Parking & Accessibility
Parking was very easy. There is a large free parking lot with plenty of available spaces, which is a big plus.
Final Thoughts
This is a solid local bagel spot with fresh food, friendly service, and a very comfortable environment. It is always great to support a newly opened small business that is doing things the right way. I will definitely be visiting again.
… moreWait time: No wait
Price per person: $10–20
Noise level: Quiet, easy to talk
Parking: Plenty of free parking (large lot)
Overall Experience
Mt. Sinai Bagel Cafe is a great new addition to the area and offers a very comfortable, clean, and welcoming experience. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted politely and felt genuinely welcomed.
Food Quality
The bagels were fresh, well made, and clearly baked with care. The standout for me was the everything bagel. What made it special is that the seasoning was on both sides of the bagel, not just the top. That alone made every bite consistently flavorful and memorable.
The cream cheese was excellent and well balanced. I tried both the veggie cream cheese and the jalapeño cream cheese, and both were delicious. The jalapeño cream cheese actually contained real jalapeño pieces, which added real flavor instead of just heat.
I also ordered an egg and cheese on an everything bagel, which was cooked properly, not messy, and nicely assembled.
Menu & Options
The menu is clearly written and easy to understand, with items labeled properly. There are breakfast sandwiches, spreads, deli options, drinks, freshly baked cookies, and a good selection of chips. Everything is presented cleanly and professionally.
Vegetarian options are clearly labeled and easy to identify on the menu.
Cleanliness & Atmosphere
The entire place was very clean, well maintained, and organized. The atmosphere was calm and comfortable, making it a pleasant spot to grab breakfast or coffee without feeling rushed or crowded.
Service
Customer service was excellent. The staff was polite, friendly, and professional throughout the visit, which made the experience even better.
Parking & Accessibility
Parking was very easy. There is a large free parking lot with plenty of available spaces, which is a big plus.
Final Thoughts
This is a solid local bagel spot with fresh food, friendly service, and a very comfortable environment. It is always great to support a newly opened small business that is doing things the right way. I will definitely be visiting again.
Tara Gaete
We have been coming here since it opened and their food is delicious! They always greet you with a warm and welcoming smile. My husband LOVES the egg sandwiches. I enjoy their roast beef sandwich ( picture below). The prices are very reasonable as well. We truly enjoy eating here !
… moreAnthony William
Mt. Sinai Bagel & Deli is truly a neighborhood gem. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted by some of the friendliest owners around they make everyone feel like a regular. Their warmth and genuine hospitality set the tone for a great experience every time.
The shop itself is spotless. Everything from the counters to the seating area is clearly well cared for, which makes enjoying your meal even better. It’s obvious they take pride not only in their food but in maintaining a clean and welcoming environment.
And the food absolutely delicious. The bagels are fresh, perfectly baked, and packed with flavor. Breakfast sandwiches are made to order with quality ingredients, and you can really taste the difference. On top of that, the prices are very reasonable, especially considering the portion sizes and quality.
One of the best perks is their current offer: free water, orange juice, or coffee with a breakfast sandwich. It’s such a thoughtful touch and adds even more value to an already great deal.
If you’re looking for friendly service, a clean space, and consistently delicious food at a fair price, Mt. Sinai Bagel & Deli is the place to go.
… moreThe shop itself is spotless. Everything from the counters to the seating area is clearly well cared for, which makes enjoying your meal even better. It’s obvious they take pride not only in their food but in maintaining a clean and welcoming environment.
And the food absolutely delicious. The bagels are fresh, perfectly baked, and packed with flavor. Breakfast sandwiches are made to order with quality ingredients, and you can really taste the difference. On top of that, the prices are very reasonable, especially considering the portion sizes and quality.
One of the best perks is their current offer: free water, orange juice, or coffee with a breakfast sandwich. It’s such a thoughtful touch and adds even more value to an already great deal.
If you’re looking for friendly service, a clean space, and consistently delicious food at a fair price, Mt. Sinai Bagel & Deli is the place to go.
Alexis Marie
First time going here. I ordered two egg sanwhiches and a few bagels. Egg sandwiches were excellent but bread could’ve been a little fresher. Bagels were probably best in the area now that better on a bagel shut down in miller place. Looks like we found our new bagel store! Staff was super friendly! Interior was spotless and updated. Looks great!
… moreChristine Murphy
We stopped in today because we happen to be passing the store on the way home from food shopping. From the minute the person behind the counter walked away with our order, we knew it was going to come out wrong. Unfortunately, we were correct. We wanted two bagel sandwiches (BEC), both on egg everything bagels but one of the bagels we wanted toasted with butter. We received one egg everything bagel and one egg bagel. Neither one was toasted and the bacon was so undercooked we needed to microwave it before eating. While we were waiting, another customer walked back in and returned a sandwich she didn’t order. I understand every business has bad days but in an area where there are a bunch of really great bagel stores, I think you always need to strive for perfection.
As a side note, many words on the menu boards were misspelled. Not the end of the world, I know, but coupled with getting orders wrong, it all adds up.
… moreAs a side note, many words on the menu boards were misspelled. Not the end of the world, I know, but coupled with getting orders wrong, it all adds up.
Sam
Place is dope, food is dope, owner is dope. Food is absolutely incredible. Best bagel in town for sure, would highly recommend. Owner is incredibly nice and helpful. Service is excellent. They also offer free delivery which is clutch. You wont be disappointed with any of the food here
… moreFredric Vencl
Very good, more traditional bagel. Not too big, not too bready. Locks and cream cheese are very good. Coffee is good quality, Colombian for sure.
Service is great.
… moreService is great.
Jarrett M
A+++++ the owners/staff are great . Very nice , great service and have amazing egg sandwiches ! Been going since they opened .
… moreisabella spero
Came here about two months ago got salads, took probably a half hour just for them to come out. They also came out 5 times asking questions after taking our order, which is fine of course but when we got the salad EVERYTHING was messed up.
Anyways have them the benefit of the doubt and said maybe it was just near the opening. Decided to get bagels this time to try them out. I ordered a bagel with cream cheese and asked them to add turkey bacon. She came out 10 minutes after ordering asking if I asked for an egg on my bagel and I said no egg just the turkey bacon. 5 minutes later got my bagel with eggs on it and the girl said “we know you said no eggs” and looked at me and i said “yea i did” and she took it back. I don’t understand why ask me and then bring it out wrong and than acknowledge it was wrong when serving it?
… moreAnyways have them the benefit of the doubt and said maybe it was just near the opening. Decided to get bagels this time to try them out. I ordered a bagel with cream cheese and asked them to add turkey bacon. She came out 10 minutes after ordering asking if I asked for an egg on my bagel and I said no egg just the turkey bacon. 5 minutes later got my bagel with eggs on it and the girl said “we know you said no eggs” and looked at me and i said “yea i did” and she took it back. I don’t understand why ask me and then bring it out wrong and than acknowledge it was wrong when serving it?
Aspen-Drake Elkins
We’ve been there twice now for breakfast and both times the food was fantastic, and the owners are really friendly! Highly recommend the lox and avocado (A5) sandwich. The bagels are great and the wraps are great too. High quality ingredients for sure and they actually pay attention to how they’re putting things together in the kitchen. Will be back!
… more